Our curated selection of reviews
I have been listening to this podcast for years (it’s my longest relationship at this point) and continue to love it. Marcus is an incredible historian and doesn’t spare any juicy details. Henry’s voices and characters have me cry laughing. Ben and his mustache could rule the world. Love his one liners and his kind way of keeping the episodes on track. Thank you for all of your hard work to bring some laughter to the darker days. I appreciate y’all so much!!!
Read more
Love this podcast! I found these guys after looking to give myself a break from my other true crime favorites like Morbid or Sword and Scale. They are well researched, have a wide range of subjects, tons of content, and enjoy off-color funny banter with each other. It’s a great listen for anyone in the mood to keep your murder chat on the sillier side. I think it’s great.
Read more
Marcus is creepy. Henry is strange. Ben is special. But this is still my favorite podcast. Hearing Marcus in a manic spiral? Priceless. Listening to Henry scream “I’m having one” while I’m sitting in the school pick up line? Epic. Hearing Ben tell us what he and Puffin talked about the previous evening. Oddly endearing.
This podcast, made by 3 guys who were clearly made in a lab, makes me laugh out loud more often than my own intrusive thoughts, so that’s a win. It’s also so thoroughly researched that you’ll be an expert on things that will ruin your life in no time. Murder, aliens, cults and conspiracies! What’s not to love.
Read more
These guys research their topics well and riff on the details hilariously. I listened to their Manhattan Project series before seeing Oppenheimer, and I was able to appreciate the movie more than I probably would have with little to no background information on the topic. I also loved their Salem Witch Trials and MK Ultra series. That being said, if you’re easily offended, this podcast probably isn’t for you.
Read more
I have listened to this show for over a year. Their jokes about victims of these horrible crimes always made me feel uncomfortable, and they discuss killers in a way that glorifies them. However, I pushed my own feelings aside as women are told to do (you’re being too much, too emotional, too sensitive, etc) and chalked it up to “bro culture.” However, Ben’s horrible abuse of his ex girlfriend and other women that have come forward, and Henry and Marcus’ active covering up of Ben’s offenses made something click for me. This show and the hosts are extremely disrespectful towards women. Their show is not victim centered, they make victims punch lines in their jokes as they profit off of crimes committed against these women. I cannot support this show any longer and suggest you listen to female-made true crime shows like My Favorite Murder who actually care about the victims and who actively donate to organizations supporting women. These men have not acted in a way that illustrates that they care about women or their well-being.
Read more
Tried to listen to an episode. Stopped after they started making sexual jokes towards the victim who was murdered, stating “oh you’re so tight”. Insanely disgusting. Don’t understand why they’re so popular.
Read more
We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts