Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal artwork

Relationships · Choosing To Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal

Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal

by Choosing To Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal

Choosing To Stay After Infidelity & Betrayal is a podcast for couples navigating the aftermath of infidelity, betrayal, and broken trust. Whether you’re a betrayed partner making sense of the pain, or the partner who caused harm and wants to repair what was broken, this show offers trauma-informed tools, honest conversations, and grounded hope. Hosted by Hali Roderick, the podcast explores trust repair, emotional regulation, accountability, boundaries, and discernment—without rushing forgiveness or pushing a one-size-fits-all outcome.

Latest episodes

Showing 20 · updated from the feed

#182 She's Not Coming At You — She's Coming To You

"Why is she coming at me?" It's one of the most common things men say after betrayal — when their partner's pain shows up as tears, anger, a raised voice, or questions th

Oct 22
20 min

#181 Emotional Infidelity: When the Affair Was Never Physical with Jill Pool

What counts as cheating if nothing physical ever happened? In this episode, Hali sits down with Certified Partner Coach, Jill Pool to name what so often goes unnamed: th

Oct 15
36 min

#180 Doing Recovery vs. Living Recovery: What Actually Heals a Relationship After Betrayal with Mike Tiede

You've done the work. So why does healing still feel like something you're performing instead of living? In this episode, Hali sits down with psychologist and partner spe

Oct 8
42 min

#179 - 5 Ways to Stay in Your Marriage Without Losing Yourself After Infidelity and Betrayal

When you're trying to heal a marriage after infidelity or betrayal, it's easy for recovery to become the center of everything. In this episode, Hali explores five ways c

Oct 1
23 min

#178 Understanding Intimacy Anorexia — with Dr. Janice Caudill, PhD

"Intimacy anorexia" is one of the most talked-about — and most misunderstood — terms in betrayal recovery. In this episode, I set out to understand it honestly, with one

Sep 24
41 min

#177 One Hour a Week Was Never Going to Be Enough

If you're a woman and you’re doing the work — therapy, coaching, reading everything you can get your hands on — and you're still white-knuckling it alone most days of the

Sep 17
11 min

#176 The Fight Under the Fight — Decoding What Betrayal Trauma Does to Your Everyday Arguments

If you're rebuilding trust after infidelity, you've probably noticed something strange: small disagreements can escalate way faster and way bigger than the topic seems to

Sep 10
14 min

#175 The Separation Plan Guide: Navigating Time Apart After Betrayal Trauma with Shawna Meek, PCC, CPC-S

"Separation" doesn't have to mean divorce. In this episode, I'm joined by Shawna Meek of Living Stones Coaching to talk about the therapeutic separation — a structured, i

Sep 3
43 min

***BONUS Choosing Different Mini Series: What I Wish I'd Done Differently with my daughters, Mataia and Morgan

In this episode of the Choosing Different mini-series, Hali is joined by her daughters, Mataia and Morgan, for an honest conversation about betrayal trauma's impact on th

Aug 29
29 min

#174 It's Not Too Late: Healing an Affair You Thought Was Behind You

If the betrayal in your relationship happened years ago — and life moved forward, but the deepest layers of healing never actually happened — this episode is for you. Ma

Aug 27
14 min

#173 Betrayed Men: Why Their Trauma Looks Different — and What Actually Helps with Dr. Laney Knowlton

When we talk about betrayal trauma, the picture most people carry is of a betrayed woman. But men experience betrayal too — and their pain often goes unseen, misread as a

Aug 20
44 min

#172 Why the Right Words Aren't Enough: Embodied Empathy in Betrayal Recovery

You can say all the right words and still leave your partner feeling completely unsafe. If you're the partner who caused harm, that may be the most frustrating thing you

Aug 13
27 min

*** BONUS Choosing Different Mini Series: Three Words Every Parent Owes Their Child: "I Believe You" 

What happens when a child no longer has to convince their parent that their pain was real? In this episode of Choosing Different Mini Series, Hali sits down with her dau

Aug 8
20 min

#171 Elements of Healthy Relationships in Recovery with Randi Gray

What does a truly healthy relationship look like after infidelity and betrayal — and is it even possible to get there? In this episode, Hali sits down with Dr. Randi Gray

Aug 6
45 min

***BONUS: Choosing Different Mini Series: The Conversations I Wish Every Parent and Child Could Have with my 2 Adult Daughters, Mataia and Morgan

This is the first episode of the Choosing Different mini-series of conversations between Hali and her two adult daughters, who were both teenagers when their family was i

Aug 1
24 min

#170 "Why It Sometimes Gets Worse Before It Gets Better — And What Actually Helps After Disclosure"

You finally know the truth. So why do you feel worse? If you're the betrayed partner and your fear, anger, and grief have grown rather than shrunk since disclosure, the

Jul 30
18 min

#169 The Spiritual Intelligence Behind Real Change After Betrayal with Dr. Yosi Amram

When someone betrays a partner and then starts doing "the work," the person who was hurt is left with an exhausting question: is this real, or is he just saying the right

Jul 23
46 min

#168 Apology vs. Amends: Why "I'm Sorry" Isn't Enough After Betrayal

An apology is a moment. Making amends is a process - and confusing the two is one of the most common places betrayal recovery gets stuck. In this solo episode, Hali brea

Jul 16
15 min

#167 Masculine and Feminine: Why Getting the Balance Right in Your Relationship Matters with Tyler Patrick

There's a dynamic underneath a lot of disconnected relationships that almost nobody names — and when it collapses, it can quietly erode intimacy. In this episode, I'm joi

Jul 9
42 min

#166 Why Shame Is the Enemy of Accountability — And What to Do About It with Jacob Fletcher, CMCH, CSAT

One of the biggest obstacles to healing after betrayal isn't a lack of love — it's shame. When the person in recovery floods with shame, they lose the ability to truly li

Jul 2
40 min

Chart trend

Position in the Relationships chart (US), last 90 days.

#130
all-time peak
122
days in the top 200 since Dec 2024

Chart positions

Where Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Oct 24, 2026).

#190 NEW Relationships US

What listeners say

A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.

This podcast is helpful and explores topics I haven’t heard on other betrayal podcasts. The hosts share some great insights and I appreciate their wisdom and experience. My only suggestion (sorry!) is that Stephanie stop saying “I was thinking…” or “it made me think…” several times per episode.

Mahanamama · Apr 2025

I’m so grateful to you both for this work you are doing. During a time where I feel 10,000 emotions all at once, this podcast is so grounding for me. I’d love to see some Q&A sessions where we can ask some specific questions about our experiences!

beckigriswold · Nov 2024

There are not a lot of good podcasts out there that cater to this and as a man that’s been betrayed by my spouse this has been great for me to hear I’m not alone in my feelings. There is a stigma with men and mental health listening to this podcast has helped me tremendously and use these tools to help on my side and I’ve even shared them with my wife.

Fumundamynuts · May 2024

When you're at a place that you've never been before, how do you know what to do, what path to take, and what choices are rational? There are many things I did not know but many emotions I was feeling. Thankful for this podcast and the information that it brings. If you are offended that someone's faith has led them to a place of healing, then this podcast is not for you. But, if you are genuinely wanting to stay and needing clarity with points of reference to faith and open to that, then, this is definitely content worth listening to so that you can make the sound decision to stay and work things out in your marriage.

RT2027 · Sep 2023

We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.

More podcasts like Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal

Popular shows in Relationships, for your next listen.

Browse charts by category

Daily updated Apple Podcasts rankings for the United States.

About Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal on Reason.fm

Here you find the Apple Podcasts chart positions of Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal, its latest episodes to listen to directly, and reviews from listeners. Rankings are updated daily for the United States.

Contact

Questions or issues? Reach us at hello@reason.fm

0:000:00