Relationships · Dear Media
by Dear Media
Join professional Private Investigator Mackenzie Fultz and Comedian Hanna Anderson each week as they delve deep into the stories of the liars, cheaters, and con-men who have left a trail of broken hearts and shattered trust in the dating world. We'll uncover the lies, scams and manipulations of these con artists, as we shine a light on the red flags to look out for in the wild west of the dating apps.
Showing 20 · updated from the feed
Where The Dating Detectives ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Nov 18, 2026).
A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.
I love the stories and am grateful for the vulnerability of the guests! However, Mackenzie’s responses to shocking claims are so judgmental. Her “OMGs!!!!” sounds like an indignant teenager and they are incredibly shaming. The gasps don’t seem supportive or empathic.
I absolutely love The Dating Detectives podcast and look forward to it every Monday!! Hanna and Mackenzie are the best and are so attentive and respectful to all their guests.
This podcast is literally my favorite thing about the week ! Mondays are now my favorite day.. listening to these lady’s talk while I start my morning (I own a daycare and this is how I open in the morning) it feels like I have been friends with them for years and we are just chatting in the morning! I love how informative it is yet casual !!
These ladies have a great concept for a podcast and I think they do an amazing job! I always tune in on Monday and have a debrief with my sister and mom later that day. Kinda like a book club. I consume a lot of true crime and this podcast is exactly what I needed to break up all the intense cases there is in the world. These stories are very real and traumatic for guest. I appreciate the safe space Makenzie and Hannah give to them to share. I wish people were nicer and understand everyone’s experiences and opinions are ever changing. Not everything is for everyone. All the low star review people need to touch some grass. Love you guys! 💕
It was pretty upsetting and disappointing to open up the newest episodes the last few weeks and them be about a victimized man. The timing of these episodes is tone deaf at the least and dangerous at best. Given the news cycle being overcome with gendered abuse (Cornell r*pists) the timing of these episodes is in poor taste. Especially to not even mention or acknowledge the news while offering up a story where women are so easily villainized. Abuse is awful no matter who does it, but platforming a story in which men are framed as victims during the most horrific news cycle for women this year? In one word- disappointing.
I’ve listened to and followed The Dating Detectives for a while now because I appreciated the way they publicly frame themselves as a supportive platform that gives women space to safely share vulnerable dating and relationship experiences. I was referred to the podcast by a friend of mine who strongly suggested I share my story with them. Unfortunately, my personal experience with them has felt very different from the values they promote. I began submitting my story in May of 2025, soon after my friend encouraged me to submit, and continued submitting/following up over the course of many months. I never once received acknowledgment, closure, or even a simple “no thank you.” At the same time, I continued hearing episodes featuring stories submitted only weeks before airing — some more traumatic than mine, some much less traumatic. To be clear: I do not believe anyone is entitled to airtime. Podcasts are allowed to curate their content however they choose. The issue is the disconnect between publicly encouraging vulnerability and privately responding to some people with complete silence. If you are going to market yourselves as a safe, supportive, women-supporting-women platform, there should be basic respect and accountability built into the process — especially when people are sharing painful and/or deeply personal experiences. And then are just completely disregarded entirely. For those of us with histories of emotional invalidation, dismissal, or manipulation, repeatedly opening up and being ignored by a platform that explicitly promotes “support” and “community” can have a real psychological impact. It reinforces the exact feelings many listeners come to these spaces carrying in the first place: that some voices matter and others simply don’t. Again, this isn’t about not being chosen. It’s about the hypocrisy of publicly preaching support, empowerment, and safe storytelling while privately failing to acknowledge people who trusted you enough to share their stories at all. I genuinely hope they reflect on the gap between the values they claim to promote and the experience some contributors are actually having behind the scenes.
We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.
Popular shows in Relationships, for your next listen.
Daily updated Apple Podcasts rankings for the United States.
Here you find the Apple Podcasts chart positions of The Dating Detectives, its latest episodes to listen to directly, and reviews from listeners. Rankings are updated daily for the United States.
Questions or issues? Reach us at hello@reason.fm