What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast - Podcast Episodes, Ranking & Reviews

Latest episodes

Showing 20 · updated from the feed

We survived our first horror convention. Did our wallets? (vlog)

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! We’re taking you with us to our very first horror convention: HorrorHound Weekend! ⚠️This one’s a little different from our usual for

Sep 24
29 min

Onslaught & Fall 2: Deadpoint Reviewed | New Release Horror Movie Double Feature

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Your killer hosts are back with a sickening double feature: Onslaught and Fall 2: Deadpoint. We put them head-to-head after they were c

Sep 10
56 min

Faves We Missed: Weapons, Barbarian, The Monkey & More | Resurrected

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! We're back 😱 and we've got 4 years of horror movies to catch up on. In the first episode of our Resurrected miniseries, Parke

Sep 3
31 min

Halloween Hype Ranking: Resident Evil, Other Mommy, Carrie & More | Resurrected

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! It's officially spooky season 🎃 We watched 14 horror trailers and ranked how hyped we are for the movies (shows, video game, etc)

Sep 3
45 min

Welcome to What's Your Favorite Scary Movie: the cozy horror review podcast

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Your killer hosts are back! Welcome to What's Your Favorite Scary Movie, a cozy horror podcast where Parker, Ian, and Caroline inv

Aug 27
2 min

Ranking Scream 1-4 | From the Vault

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! From the vault: We're curating our greatest hits ahead of our September 3rd relaunch 😱 Throwback to one of our most chaotic, but p

Aug 20
1 h 24 min

The Cabin in the Woods review | From the Vault

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! From the vault: We're curating our greatest hits ahead of our September 3rd relaunch 😱 This one's extra special—it's our

Aug 13
51 min

I Know What You Did Last Summer review | From the Vault

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! From the vault: We’re curating our greatest hits and pulling them from our archive ahead of our September 3rd relaunch. 😱 Just like Jul

Aug 6
51 min

X (Freaky Favs)

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Let's talk about sex, baby! Tune in for the debut of our new segment Freaky Favs, where we share our top recommendations of the mo

Mar 23 2022
45 min

Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2022)

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! The buzz is back, baby ⛓ We're a few weeks late, but couldn't let our favorite Leatherbaby slash us by without discussing! Li

Mar 9 2022
1 h 21 min

Scream (2022) feat. Marley Shelton, Matt Bettinelli-Olpin, Tyler Gillett and Chad Villella

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! The question isn't WHO am I, the question is WHERE am I streaming? Stream our spoiler review of Scream (2022) now 🔪 featuring dire

Jan 24 2022
1 h 58 min

Scream (2022) SPOILER FREE feat. Matt Bettinelli-Olpin, Tyler Gillett & Chad Villella

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Hello, Sidney. It's an honor 🔪 Scream (2022) is FINALLY here! Listen now for our spoiler-free review of the latest Ghostface massa

Jan 17 2022
45 min

Scream-A-Thon (Scream 1-4)

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Surprise, Sidney 🔪 What's Your Favorite Scary Movie has returned just in time for the biggest horror event of the new year 😱 Just

Jan 12 2022
1 h 22 min

The Cabin in the Woods

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! WELCOME TO OUR 100TH EPISODE 🥳🎉🍾🎊 To celebrate, we're finally covering the much-requested film THE CABIN IN THE WOODS 🌲 Enjoy the

May 31 2021
49 min

Spiral: From the Book of Saw feat. Marisol Nichols

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Do you want to play a game Enjoy our review of SPIRAL: FROM THE BOOK OF SAW featuring an exclusive interview with lead actor Marisol Ni

May 17 2021
1 h 17 min

Urban Legend feat. Julieann Marie

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Okay listen up guys, 'cause this is how the story really goes. We've got the truth about URBAN LEGEND - tune in now 🔪 We wou

Apr 26 2021
1 h 02 min

Honeydew

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Get lost with us in the bizarre world of HONEYDEW 🍈 In this episode, we're talking melons, butt meat, and perhaps Ian's new f

Apr 12 2021
54 min

The Toll feat. Michael Nader

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Pay up! It's time to talk about THE TOLL 💸 Enjoy our review featuring an interview with Michael Nader, writer/director of THE TOLL

Mar 29 2021
23 min

Pet Sematary (1989) feat. Julieann Marie

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Sometimes dead is better, but we can't stop digging up PET SEMATARY 🐈‍⬛ This time we're trucking back to the original to deci

Mar 22 2021
1 h 06 min

Leprechaun

Haunt our inbox 👻 Message us now! Try as they will, and try as they might, who listens to me podcast won't live through the night 🌈 Let's celebrate horror&apos

Mar 15 2021
37 min

Chart trend

Position in the Film Reviews chart (US), last 90 days.

#1#100#199AugSep

#27

all-time peak

days in the top 50 since Aug 2026

Chart positions

Where What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Sep 24, 2026).

#49 ▼ 5 Film Reviews US

What listeners say

A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.

This is such a fun podcast. I’m not even a huge scary movie girl, but they cover such a broad range of “scary” that I still get to feel like a part of the crew. I love learning more about the variety of scary movies and this group’s knowledge is vast! I really enjoyed the previous eps of the show, but I’m really excited about this newest iteration!

Plemons! · Aug 2026

We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.