That Aged Well artwork

Film Reviews · That Aged Well Podcast

That Aged Well

by That Aged Well Podcast

Feel conflicted about the movies you loved as a kid? Let Paul and Erika guide you through all that beloved garbage we watched...after all, nostalgia is more fun when you aren't the only one embarrassed by it. Come dive into yesterday's pop culture today (and connect with the show on Instagram, BlueSky, and Threads)!

Latest episodes

Showing 20 · updated from the feed

Designing Women (1986) - Pigs, Condoms & an Actual F***ing Angel

After two (TWO!) weeks away, Erika and Paul are back for September to bring you sit-com discussions all month. First up is the southern classic Designing Women, which is

Sep 14
1 h 48 min

Mailbag Episode! (Labor Day, 2026)

They’ve been threatening it all year, and now Erika and Paul are actually doing it…it’s a mailbag episode for Labor Day! That Aged Well is brought to you by Quince! Shop

Sep 7
1 h 02 min

Feed Drop: Weirdly Helpful

Hello, Insolent Musical Peasants, Backdoor Broncos, and Stagedoor Sallies! We've got a Friday bonus for you today in the form of a feed drop: it's an episode of Weirdly H

Sep 4
25 min

That Aged Well Interviews: Justin C. Key

It’s the fifth Monday in August which means it’s time for a bonus episode! This week, Paul welcomes author Justin C. Key to talk all about his dystopian sci-fi novel The

Aug 31
50 min

Zoolander (2001) - Fashion Campaigns, Private Screenings & a Good Dude

Comedy August is coming to a close (but look forward to that bonus episode next week) with a 2001 classic: Ben Stiller’s Zoolander. Come join Erika and Paul as they re-ex

Aug 24
2 h 05 min

The Jerk (1979) - Canon Events, Shinola & a Cosmetologist

The laughs keep coming as Comedy August rages on! This week, Erika and Paul tackle the 1979 Steve Martin vehicle The Jerk, a film with a premise that will knock you sidew

Aug 17
1 h 58 min

Feed Drop: The Great Pop Culture Debate

Bonus alert! We’re dropping a snippet from our friends over at The Great Pop Culture Debate, where Eric and his panel are debating the Best Emmy Winning Comedy Actress! G

Aug 14
30 min

My Cousin Vinny (1992) - Grits, Maroon Suits & an Oscar Winner

It’s finally time…Paul and Erika are diving into My Cousin Vinny this week, possibly the film most referenced on the podcast that had actually not been given an episode a

Aug 10
2 h 16 min

Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure (1989) - History Reports, Modern Distractions & a Pageboy

July is over and August is here, and Erika and Paul will be taking all month to celebrate comedies, starting with the late 80’s classic time travel extravaganza Bill & Te

Aug 3
2 h 03 min

Ocean’s Eleven (2001) - Disguises, Museums & a Perfect Cockney Accent

And so we bring Heist Month to a close with a modern classic: Steven Soderbergh’s Ocean’s Eleven! Paul and Erika get into all the twists and turns of the remake…perhaps T

Jul 27
2 h 10 min

Set It Off (1996) - Beloved Sitcom Actors, Car CDs & a Sensual Massage

Heist Month continues its whiplash ways, as Erika and Paul leap from the joyful silliness of the Muppets to the heartbreak of F. Gary Gray’s Set It Off! A film that’s pac

Jul 20
2 h 09 min

The Great Muppet Caper (1981) - Ladies, Henchmodels & a Jar of Calf’s Foot Jelly

Heist Movie July is in full swing, but even though we’re talking all about heist movies this month, this week we still have the chance to say: now for something completel

Jul 13
1 h 56 min

The Usual Suspects (1995) - Murder Outfits, Asterisks & a Woman

We’re ringing Heist Movie July in with a classic of the genre: 1995’s Oscar-winning The Usual Suspects! We probably all know how certain aspects of this production have a

Jul 6
2 h 14 min

That Aged Well Interviews: Crystal

It’s the fifth Monday in June, which means it’s time for a Bonus Episode! This week, Erika and Paul are joined by the co-host of the Camp Classics podcast Crystal (@cryst

Jun 29
48 min

Chicago (2002) - Downbeats, Killer Gams & a Half-Used Jar of Cold Cream

We’ve talked about it for years…but now it’s finally time! Paul and Erika are finishing out June (at least the full episode portion of it) with a deep discussion of Rob M

Jun 22
2 h 19 min

Y Tu Mamá También (2001) - Manifestos, Public Pools & an Oyster in Lime Juice

After spending the last two weeks of Pride Month in Europe, Erika and Paul are heading across the Atlantic to Mexico to talk about Alfonso Cuarón’s breakout Y Tu Mamá Tam

Jun 15
2 h 13 min

Velvet Goldmine (1998) - Death Hoaxes, Feathers & a Glitter UFO

This week in Prideful June, Paul and Erika are doing one of those movies that’s only really half a movie…the rest of it is a mashup between a fashion show, a music video,

Jun 8
2 h 20 min

Victor/Victoria (1982) - Eclairs, Sonic Screams & an 80s Bathroom

Happy Pride Month, y’all…June is here and we’re kicking it off with Blake Edward’s stone-cold classic Victor/Victoria! Erika and Paul are here to celebrate Julie Andrews,

Jun 1
2 h 14 min

The Land Before Time (1988) - Sea Turtles, Geography & a Long Pause

Paul and Erika are closing out Animation May with another healthy helping of childhood trauma…now with dinosaurs! Do they wonder about certain storytelling choices in thi

May 25
1 h 51 min

That Aged Well Interviews: This Week In Fandom History

Bonus episode alert! Erika is off gallivanting at an undisclosed location, but Paul had a chance to sit down to talk with Emily and V from This Week In Fandom History. Th

May 22
1 h 10 min

Chart trend

Position in the Film Reviews chart (US), last 90 days.

#3
all-time peak
1
day in the top 3 since Nov 2024

Chart positions

Where That Aged Well ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Sep 20, 2026).

#20 ▲ 2 Film Reviews US
#187 ▲ 1 TV & Film US

What listeners say

A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.

This podcast has saved my life! After my sister mairin recommending this podcast in the doldrums of last winter I have been unable to do anything but listen to the entire back catalogue and wait with impatiently bated breath for every single new episode. My sister, cousin (to whom I recommended listen post haste!!) and I spend countless hours discussing your delightful monologues, opinions and how much we love you in general. So glad I’m not the only one who found the Robin Hood Fox sexy!!! Please please please please for the love of all things holy please review Blowdry. Alan Rickman with barber scissors foot sole tattoo? Josh Hartnett horrific British accent??? Corpse in a morgue with brightly dyed hair?? Need it go on. Love you all so much.

Identicalcousins · Sep 2026

There is no better way to start the week than with Paul and Erika’s intelligence, insight, and humor. The only downside to this podcast is that the hosts shake my belief that I am too smart to develop parasocial relationships. Paul and Erika, you are the reason I finally got around to watching Sunset Boulevard, so let me return the favor by suggesting another classic that I think you’ll enjoy, based on your Beverly Hills Cop episode: the clip for Serge’s Survival Boutique. Thank you for putting so much joy and laughter into the world - no notes!

Bella_Brunette · Aug 2026

Found this pod a few weeks ago and now my wife and I are both fully hooked — I’m officially a Benjamin Franklin Rodriguez Patreon member. Send help (don’t, actually, I’m having too much fun). Still got a mountain of back catalog to dig through, so no recommendations yet, but the commute has never been funnier. Wouldn’t change a single thing. Keep cooking, guys

Niki Phillips · Aug 2026

I found this podcast thanks to K&K at a Date with Dateline and love it! That Aged Well is the first non true crime podcast in my regular rotation and I am working my way through all the back episodes. Thanks for making me laugh!!!

Mama Llama in Pajamas · Aug 2026

We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.

More podcasts like That Aged Well

Popular shows in Film Reviews, for your next listen.

Browse charts by category

Daily updated Apple Podcasts rankings for the United States.

About That Aged Well on Reason.fm

Here you find the Apple Podcasts chart positions of That Aged Well, its latest episodes to listen to directly, and reviews from listeners. Rankings are updated daily for the United States.

Contact

Questions or issues? Reach us at hello@reason.fm

0:000:00