Our curated selection of reviews
Season 1 set a high bar with its captivating storytelling and engaging content. However, Season 2 unfortunately unfolded with a pace that can only be described as languid, stretching out episodes with minimal new information or developments. This approach led to a listening experience that felt more like a prolonged wait rather than the compelling journey. The charm of a podcast lies in its ability to weave intricate stories and present insightful content within a limited timeframe, a balance that Season 2 struggled to find. In its pursuit to build on the success of the first season, it seems to have misstepped by diluting the very essence that originally captivated its audience.
Read more
I truly enjoy the podcast!
I think the case is expressed very well (in both seasons).
The episodes fit in a way that tells a story, and keeps you interested/invested until the end.
I also like the fact that the host (Neil Strauss) has a way of reminding you of the facts, as you listen along, without being annoyingly repetitive.
I am impressed with his heartfelt reporting. He truly becomes involved & invested in advocating for the VICTIM. I can greatly appreciate that! Most of the time the reporter becomes overly attached to the family left behind… which is commendable, absolutely… but it can sometimes hinder how you assess a case… doing so can facilitate in missing facts, or over-looking key pieces of evidence. In the end, a case is about find justice for the missing person. It’s about telling their story to the best of your ability, representing THEM… all without them being there to do it for themselves. I think he achieves that!
The only thing I can say… the thing that bugs me TREMENDOUSLY… the ADs!
The first season wasn’t bad at all… probably has the least amount of advertising I’ve heard.
However…. Season 2 is ate up with Ads that REPEAT & takes up 15-18 minutes from each episode! It’s actually RIDICULOUS! I almost wanted to take a step back from listening because I had to constantly watch the timeline progression… that way I could “fast-forward” by hitting the 30 Second button several times! It’s irritating!
Read more
Absolutely love the way you handle this case. You literally had and have me on the edge of my seat. I cannot wait for the next season. Thank you for caring especially for those who seem to be absent the love of their parents. I lost my only child, he was 13. This mother is going to live with much regret for life!
Read more
Wow! Incredibly sad story.
I am a true crime junkie and this pod cast is the most well done and compelling that I’ve ever heard.
If I go missing, I want Neil Strauss on the case, great investigator, compassionate, fair minded and tenacious.
Read more
We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts