Examined: The Backfire Effect artwork

True Crime · Western Sound and Pushkin Industries

Examined: The Backfire Effect

by Western Sound and Pushkin Industries

About Examined: Overlooked cases that never got the real investigation they deserved. Each season features deeply reported stories about crime, punishment, and the people inside the criminal legal system.  Nearly 40 years ago, in the parking lot of a community college in Port Huron, Michigan, a 20-year-old student named Scott Macklem was shot dead in broad daylight. His murder shocked the community. It made no sense. The police quickly found their suspect. There was only one problem: the man said he was nowhere near the scene of the crime. And he could prove it. In Examined: The Backfire Effect, journalist Josie Duffy Rice talks with eyewitnesses, investigators and local reporters to unravel a shocking story of judicial apathy and expedience — a story that leaves no one off the hook.

Chart trend

Position in the True Crime chart (US), last 90 days.

#148
all-time peak
44
days in the top 200 since May 2025

Latest episodes

Showing 20 · updated from the feed

Trailer: The Backfire Effect

In 1986, a man named Scott Macklem was killed in broad daylight. Eight days later, a suspect was arrested. But now, almost 40 years later, reporter Josie Duffy Rice is re

Sep 8
3 min

Lost Hills is Becoming Examined

Lost Hills has been quiet for a bit, so we've decided to do something different: turn this feed into a home for a new kind of story, told fresh each season. Starting this

Sep 4
1 min

Episode 8: The Finish Line | Valley of Shadows

A reunion between two retired detectives brings new focus to the Aujay investigation, just as Hayley and Betsy find out about another tragedy in the Punchbowl area. When

Mar 2
53 min

Episode 7: The Trial | Valley of Shadows

While the DEA showers Hager in accolades, the LASD turns against him. But Hager fights back, and drags the department’s dirty secrets out into open court. Betsy and Hayle

Feb 23
50 min

Episode 6: The Big Takedown | Valley of Shadows

Brandenburg is taken off the Aujay case, but the LASD can’t stop Hager and the federal task force. With the help of wiretaps, informants, and 18 months of investigation,

Feb 16
42 min

Episode 5: The Legend of Bigfoot | Valley of Shadows

Decades before Jon Aujay’s disappearance, the Devil’s Punchbowl was infamous for something else: Bigfoot sightings. Sasquatch became a known boogeyman in the area. But be

Feb 9
43 min

Episode 4: Outlaw Country | Valley of Shadows

As Detective Brandenburg follows leads in the Aujay case, he finds himself with an unlikely ally. A young buck narcotics detective named Darren Hager, who’s trying to dis

Feb 2
46 min

Episode 3: Tweaker Talk | Valley of Shadows

At the time of Jon Aujay’s disappearance, California is under siege by a meth epidemic and the Antelope Valley is the epicenter. So when investigators receive tips that A

Jan 26
46 min

Episode 2: An Unreasonable Act | Valley of Shadows

After deputy Jon Aujay disappears, the sheriff’s department claims he was suicidal — pointing to marital troubles and erratic behavior in the weeks before he vanished. Bu

Jan 19
40 min

Important Lost Hills - Dark Canyon Update | Lost Hills

The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department listened to our podcast and now they’re asking us some new questions — and answering some of ours. Are they ready to reopen th

Nov 13 2024
20 min

12. Dig Two Graves | Lost Hills

Dana lays out all the evidence, and we await results from forensic testing. We reconnect with Mitrice’s loved ones, as they celebrate what would have been her 39th birthd

Jul 17 2024
42 min

11. The Suitcase | Lost Hills

A round of cold calls yields brand new information tying the Person of Interest to Mitrice. We return to the fort in the woods, and make a startling discovery.  See omny

Jul 15 2024
33 min

10. The Wallypad | Lost Hills

The home of a local firefighter is infiltrated by an informant hoping to get more information on the Person of Interest. And a hike planned for Dark Canyon instead leads

Jul 10 2024
30 min

9. Fearful Witness | Lost Hills

A 2011 exhumation of Mitrice’s remains leads to a second autopsy. Meanwhile, a woman describes a disturbing encounter in Monte Nido around the time of Mitrice’s death. 

Jul 8 2024
33 min

8. Rick Trouble | Lost Hills

We learn everything we can about our Person of Interest — a longtime member of the Monte Nido community, who went from golden boy to convict to off-the-grid survivalist l

Jul 3 2024
37 min

7. In the Shit | Lost Hills

Looking for a way into Dark Canyon, we follow a former pot grower on a treacherous route, and pay a visit to the Porn Ranch, which borders Dark Canyon. Plus, a retired LA

Jul 1 2024
34 min

6. Reconnaissance | Lost Hills

Eleven months after her disappearance, Mitrice’s naked remains are discovered in an abandoned pot field in Dark Canyon, just above Monte Nido. Deputies on scene make a co

Jun 26 2024
31 min

Bonus: Get Jim | Lost Hills

Three years before Mitrice’s arrest, Mel Gibson was arrested for drunk driving on Pacific Coast Highway. An interview with the arresting officer, James Mee, reveals the p

Jun 24 2024
32 min

5. So Close | Lost Hills

As the months pass with no sign of Mitrice, rumors abound. Law enforcement questions the artist behind a creepy mural. And deputies raid a fort in the wilderness looking

Jun 19 2024
40 min

4. Hopscotch | Lost Hills

Six hours after her release from Lost Hills Station, Mitrice is spotted in the rural community of Monte Nido. Investigators find Mitrice’s footprints, and neighbors repor

Jun 17 2024
32 min

Chart positions

Where Examined: The Backfire Effect ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Sep 13, 2026).

#184 ▼ 12 True Crime US

What listeners say

A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.

Season 4 is beautifully written and edited, I felt I was there with the journalist, not only I was able to feel present during the meetings, the interviews, the crawling through the canyon, but also every time she thought of a connection or a detail and how to pursue a hunch… Definitely a must listen!

Moky in AZ · Aug 2025

This is the best podcast I’ve listened to in a long time. I heard about it through Cautionary Tales, my second favorite podcast ever, after Revisionist History, and this is a super close third. Great work investigating, super great delivery and writing, and very relevant. Thank you for your work!!

Christina Hoagie · Jul 2025

So well done. One of the best podcasts covering true crime. This case is especially interesting and frustrating given the inadequate if not neglectful local and state governmental responses.

Cgkeepgoing · Mar 2025

Thank you for your in depth reporting on Surf Culture icons of the past. I really enjoyed learning more about Kathy Kohner-Zuckerman. Surfing culture has some very dark sides by exposing the truths of some icons of the past we can hopefully move into a more inclusive culture.

Ragnar's kingdome · Aug 2024

It pains me to give this podcast two stars. However, the background music is not only unnecessary but really annoying; at times cloying and others manipulative. These narrators are too excellent for this gimmick and I think the production person who made this decision dropped the ball.

angie mcq · Oct 2025

The ads way outweigh what ends up to be a only a few minutes of actual content in the latest *20 minute* episode of what is said to be an (ultimately underwhelming) update in the case. This overly commercialized podcast lost it’s purpose and listen ability.

Znamenity · Nov 2024

We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.

More podcasts like Examined: The Backfire Effect

Popular shows in True Crime, for your next listen.

Browse charts by category

Daily updated Apple Podcasts rankings for the United States.

About Examined: The Backfire Effect on Reason.fm

Here you find the Apple Podcasts chart positions of Examined: The Backfire Effect, its latest episodes to listen to directly, and reviews from listeners. Rankings are updated daily for the United States.

Contact

Questions or issues? Reach us at hello@reason.fm

0:000:00