Everything They Missed

Episode 13: The Motivational Speaker

Nearly a year after Everything They Missed began, Andrew Hayes finally gets his day in court. But nothing about it goes as expected. As a storm closes in on Memphis, ol

BONUS EPISODE 6: Stephen Harris

In this special bonus episode of Everything They Missed, Stephanie sits down with Stephen Harris, son of murder victim Danny Harris, to look back at the extraordinary yea

BONUS EPISODE 5: Investigator Q

Every breakthrough begins with someone willing to look where no one else has. Go behind the scenes with Stephanie and Investigator Q to see how forgotten witnesses, overl

BONUS EPISODE 4: The Sound of a Story

Behind every unforgettable story is a sound. In this bonus episode, Stephanie Tinsley sits down with composer Braison Cyrus to explore how music and sound design became t

BONUS 3: June 29

Just hours before the TN Innocence Project on behalf of Andrew Hayes was set to present evidence that could prove his innocence, an unexpected courthouse shutdown brought

Episode 12: Purgatory

As the case reaches a critical crossroads, hope, frustration, and uncertainty collide. With a pivotal hearing on the horizon, two families wait to learn whether the truth

Episode 11: Bombshells and Burritos

A major breakthrough sparks renewed hope, but in a case full of twists, nothing is ever simple. As momentum builds, shocking news threatens to upend everything. See Priv

Episode 10: All These Years

There comes a moment when the questions stop and the listening begins. This is that moment. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice

Episode 9: Leverage

What sounds like a breakthrough arrives with conditions. As access to proof is controlled and motives blur, Stephanie is forced to confront how easily truth can be levera

Episode 8: Bluffs

Promises come easily. Proof does not. As lines blur between strategy and manipulation, Stephanie realizes the game may be bigger than she thought—and that she might be pl

Episode 7: A Father's Son

Grief needs a clear answer. So when a son reaches out, his version of events complicates and begins to reshape the entire investigation. See Privacy Policy at https://ar

BONUS 2: Hope Is a Dangerous Thing: Inside the Tennessee Innocence Project

In this bonus episode of Everything They Missed, Stephanie sits down with Tennessee Innocence Project executive director and attorney Jason Gichner for a raw, unfiltered

Episode 6: Room To Speak

Stephanie searches for a way forward, only to be drawn into Andrew’s past and the people left in his wake. With every revelation, another layer of time is stripped away -

Episode 5: The Other Story

Inside prison walls and hidden in family homes are whispers of theft, grudges, and betrayal that have taken on a life of their own. Stephanie Tinsley pulls at the stories

Episode 4: Fourteen Strangers

Stephanie and Mark Tinsley break down the defense’s moves in Andrew’s trial. Witnesses came and went, but one testimony—revealed publicly for the first time in court—stil

Episode 3: Her

Attention turns to one woman—whose name kept coming up, and who the police let walk away. She was caught pawning Danny’s property, possibly linked to his stolen ATM card,

BONUS: Origin Story: From the Murdaugh Murders to the Mic — A Conversation with Stephanie & Mark Tinsley

Before Stephanie launched Everything They Missed, she was living inside one of the biggest crime stories in the country. In this roundtable with her husband, attorney Mar

Episode 2: The Record Button

Stephanie Tinsley revisits an investigation that quickly spiraled: a stolen truck, a rotating cast of suspects, and a web of stories that never quite add up. When detecti

Episode 1: Protocol | The First 48 Hours After Danny Harris’s Murder

Danny Harris, a father of four and military vet, is found murdered in his Tennessee apartment. The scene was savage: blood on the walls, air fresheners failing to hide th

Introducing Everything They Missed, A True Crime Investigation

Host Stephanie Tinsley explores a case that for more than a decade has been considered settled… but to this day, there are far more questions than answers. With exclusive