Sinisterhood is the comedy podcast about all things sinister, covering true crime, cults, cryptids, unsolved mysteries, and strange phenomena.
Join Dallas-based comedians and best friends Christie Wallace and Heather McKinney each Wednesday as they bring you weekly episodes with plenty of research, lots of laughs, and legal insight from Heather, a licensed attorney.
Plus, catch all new odd but true tales submitted by listeners every Friday.
Latest episodes
Showing 20 · updated from the feed
Episode 414: Sweat Lodge Guru James Arthur Ray, Part 1
He went from a telemarketer to an Oprah-endorsed self-help guru, charging thousands for "enlightenment" retreats. His journey from unknown to one of the biggest stars in
Sep 16 1 h 40 min
Freaky Friday: Episode 231 (Best Of)
A North Texas Backroads Terror; The time a vampire stole a bird and asked if he could take my picture??; Terrorists lived in my neighborhood; My Psychic Awakening and Gho
Sep 11 1 h 28 min
A Conversation with Brian Buckmire
Since December of 2024, the killing of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, and the prosecution of the man accused of pulling the trigger, Luigi Mangione, has played out
Sep 10 36 min
Episode 413: True Crime Headlines Special Edition
Additional remains have been identified, and a set of mystery photos are at the center of a new documentary as we approach the 25th anniversary of the Sept. 11 attacks. P
Sep 9 1 h 46 min
Freaky Friday: Episode 230 (Best Of)
The Navy SEAL Con Man Who Tricked Us All; Pretty Sure My Dad Worked at Area 51; The Muhfugga in the Attic, I See...STATIC People; I Think My House is Haunted by a Feminis
Sep 4 59 min
Episode 412: Best of Legendary & Cursed
The persistent ghost of a little boy. Crazy water that makes you see something that isn’t there. A doll that won’t stay on his shelf. The most powerful horse you’ve ever
Sep 2 1 h 30 min
Sunday Scaries: 59 (Audio Only)
You're about to hear the audio from our Sunday night stream. We're keeping you in the chat even when you couldn't make it live. Come hang with us live Sunday nights at 8.
Aug 31 1 h 27 min
Freaky Friday: Episode 229
The Time I Almost Got Kidnapped Right Outside of my Grandparents’ House!; $1MIL Reward in Australia Cold Cases; I Didn't Know What to Do; From Poisoning to Words from Bey
Aug 28 1 h 21 min
Episode 411: Nolan Wells the Case So Far - Part 3
As the missing 18-year-old’s family celebrated his 19th birthday without him, investigation records were released publicly, describing the efforts to find him. But within
Aug 26 1 h 18 min
Sunday Scaries: 58 (Audio Only)
You're about to hear the audio from our Sunday night stream. We're keeping you in the chat even when you couldn't make it live. Come hang with us live Sunday nights at 8.
Aug 24 1 h 32 min
Freaky Friday: Episode 228
I Found my Missing Husband From 2,000 Miles Away; My Mother-in-law Got Pete Buttigieg’s Kids Taken Away for 24 Hours; A Serial Killer was a Patient of my Dad; Another Pue
Aug 22 1 h 12 min
Episode 410: Nolan Wells the Case So Far - Part 2
A young man went missing in Mississippi, from an island with hundreds of witnesses, after arriving with a large group of friends. As his family frantically searched for a
Aug 19 1 h 28 min
Sunday Scaries: 57 (Audio Only)
You're about to hear the audio from our Sunday night stream. We're keeping you in the chat even when you couldn't make it live. Come hang with us live Sunday nights at 8.
Aug 17 1 h 35 min
Freaky Friday: Episode 227 (Best Of)
I Can't Get Rid of Treadmill Man; Mr. Llyod's Shed; Dinner with an (alleged) Serial Rapist; I Work on a Haunted Steamboat; High School Shenanigans: The Malevolent Muppet
Aug 14 1 h 17 min
Episode 409: Nolan Wells the Case So Far - Part 1
A group of friends headed out to a barrier island along with hundreds of others to celebrate the Fourth of July. But, when the friends came back, one of them was left beh
Aug 12 1 h 28 min
Sunday Scaries: 56 (Audio Only)
You're about to hear the audio from our Sunday night stream. We're keeping you in the chat even when you couldn't make it live. Come hang with us live Sunday nights at 8.
Aug 11 1 h 09 min
Freaky Friday: Episode 226
My Friend was Murdered in Puerto Rico; In 1989 My Mom Nearly Killed Me; I Was on the Terrorist List; My Dad Knew He Was Going to Die; My Postpartum Brain Could Have Gotte
Aug 7 53 min
Episode 408: The Prairieland Antifa Test Case Pt. 2
After the president’s antifa declaration, the government increased charges on nine protestors, who soon found themselves in a federal courtroom. Despite little evidence a
Aug 5 1 h 48 min
Freaky Friday: Episode 225
Kia Boys Strike Again; We Were Almost Part of a Real-Life Slasher Story; 3AM Sighting of...Something; What the Fuck-y in Kentucky; A Serial Killer and A Paranormal Invest
Jul 31 58 min
Episode 407: The Prairieland Antifa Test Case Pt. 1
Last year, a few concerned North Texas residents marked the Fourth of July with a noise demonstration in solidarity with those held in ICE custody. What started as an exe
Jul 29 1 h 30 min
Chart trend
Position in the Comedy chart (US), last 90 days.
#1#100#199JunJulAugSep
#56
all-time peak
16
days in the top 100 since Nov 2024
Chart positions
Where Sinisterhood ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Sep 16, 2026).
A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.
I stumbled upon your podcast randomly and I now listen to you every day, catching up on the years of podcasts I missed.
Please keep sharing your true hearts. Politics is personal and you have a powerful platform In which to share what is important to you. You've worked hard to establish your prominence in this overcrowded crime podcast world.
Never apologize, never stop.
Emily in Oakland · Dec 2024
Out of all the paranormal and true crime shows I spend time with, Sinisterhood really has the best delivery. Stoked to be able to listen to topics where I don’t have to fast fwd to get to the good stuff. Freaky Fridays are my fave! 🖤
Kadeena · Dec 2024
These women are phenomenal, and it often feels like I am listening to my own friends. However this review is intended for everyone leaving negative reviews due to K&H’s vocalizations of their political beliefs. I’m going to make it as simple as I can for you:
Regardless of who you, the reader, voted for, the result of the election is highly likely to affect these hosts and their families. On top of that, they seem to be humans that are capable of feeling empathy, which means that they are able to see how things will negatively impact other groups that they are not a part of. In other words, they care about others that are unlike them who are about to suffer.
And on top of THAT, this is their platform that they created, host, record, and have families assist in editing. They are allowed to discuss whatever they’d like on their own podcast.
If the notion of people being upset on behalf of themselves and others ANNOYS YOU, you are part of the problem.
500/5 stars, will listen forever.
HanBranson · Nov 2024
These women are on the correct side of history. Their empathy and passion for justice are a breath of fresh air in the current state of humanity. It is also their podcast and they are entitled to speak their truth as they bear witness to the impending darkness. Anyone who feels the need to leave a one star review because of “politics” is completely missing the point of this podcast and should reevaluate their morality and their choices. These women are brilliant, kind, empathic, and above all honest. And I think we could all use more of that.
RCB1010 · Nov 2024
I was a long time listener of this show until the recent episode about America’s dark web where Heather & Christie not-so-subtly shamed anyone who isn’t liberal. I had so much respect for the both of you and used to encourage anyone who would listen to check out Sinisterhood. All of that went out the window when you decided to use your TRUE CRIME podcast as political propaganda. When discussing cases, you both always acknowledge if/when you’re not experts in whatever the given subject matter is. So I have to ask, what in the world qualifies either of you (a lawyer and a psychology major) to educate people on politics?
You are entitled to your own opinions but you have no business using your platform to influence how people should vote. You have lost a loyal, long time listener -which is unfortunate for me too, by the way, because Sinisterhood used to be my favorite podcast. But I can’t bring myself to continue supporting you as I now feel unwelcome because my political beliefs differ from yours.
jagamomma · Nov 2024
Much like what happened with My Favorite Murder - this podcast talks too much about politics. Why can’t we stay on brand of being comedy & true crime? It’s not a good look and while everyone is entitled to their own political stance, this platform and show has strayed away from its original purpose and now belittles the beliefs of others. I don’t care who you voted for but just please stick to what we came here for…
London_A_93 · Nov 2024
We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.
Here you find the Apple Podcasts chart positions of Sinisterhood, its latest episodes to listen to directly, and reviews from listeners. Rankings are updated daily for the United States.
