Reality After Show

Latest episodes

Showing 20 · updated from the feed

Survivor: Marquesas Vecepia Robinson-Beyond The Torch

In this episode of Beyond the Torch, host Leslie Nease is joined by guest co-host Scott Ransom (a fan contest winner) to interview Vecepia Robinson, the winner of Survivo

Oct 28
1 h 08 min

Survivor 51 Episode 5 After Show - Reality After Show

Join Special Guest and Two Time Survivor Winner Sandra Diaz-Twine, Survivor and Traitor Carolyn Wiger, Survivor Legend Jonny Fairplay and Producer Bobby Goodsby as we bre

Oct 22
53 min

Survivor Guatemala's Cindy Hall -Beyond The Torch

Today, Todd & Leslie (both from Survivor: China) welcome Cindy Hall from Survivor: Guatemala for an insightful conversation about her Survivor experience and her remarkab

Oct 20
1 h 03 min

Ramble Battle Royale Live Reaction! - Reality After Show

Join Producer Bobby Goodsby and Podcaster Lauren Pratt as they Live React to The Ramble/RHAP Live Big Brother VS Survivor Battle Royale! Join the chat and get your questi

Oct 16
4 h 21 min

Survivor 51 Episode 4 After Show - Reality After Show

Join Survivor Legend Jonny Fairplay and Producer Bobby Goodsby as we breakdown the Episode 4 of Survivor 51. We will be assessing all of the action from Survivor 51 all

Oct 15
1 h 00 min

Survivor Legend Jerri Manthey Beyond the Torch

In this episode of Beyond the Torch, host Leslie is joined by guest co-host Courtney to interview three-time Survivor player Jerri Manthey — famously known as the show's

Oct 13
1 h 11 min

Survivor 51 Episode 3 After Show - Reality After Show

Join Special Guest Survivor 43 Winner Mike Gabler, Survivor Legend Jonny Fairplay, Survivor 49's Jake Latimer, DONDI Season 2's Phillip Solomon, and Producer Bobby Goodsb

Oct 9
1 h 17 min

Survivor Samoa's Ashley Trainer Beyond The Torch

In this episode of Beyond the Torch, hosts Leslie Nease and Todd Herzog (both from Survivor: China) interview Ashley Trainer from Survivor: Samoa (Season 19). Ashley shar

Oct 6
55 min

BB28 Entrance to Eviction Finale Recap- Reality After Show

Big Brother 28 is in the books and we are here to break it all down. Join hosts Bobby Goodsby, Lauren Pratt, and DONDI Season 2's Phillip Solomon as they discuss the Fina

Oct 2
1 h 03 min

BB28 FINALE Watch Party Live From Crush and Brew -Reality After Show

Join host Bobby Goodsby in the chat where he will take your questions live on stream during the #BB28 Finale Watch Party Live from Crush and Brew In Southern California!

Oct 2
41 min

Survivor 51 Episode 2 Recap- Reality After Show

Join Special Guest from Survivor 47 Sam Phalen, Survivor Legend Jonny Fairplay, Survivor 47's Gabe Ortis, and Producer Bobby Goodsby as we breakdown the Episode 2 of Surv

Oct 2
1 h 02 min

Survivor 51 Episode 2 Watch Party After Show- Reality After Show

Join Survivor Legend Jonny Fairplay, and Watch the episode live. Watch as they breakdown Episode 2 of Survivor 51. We will be assessing all of the action from the episode

Oct 1
1 h 29 min

Survivor 51 Episode 2 After Show- Reality After Show

Join Survivor Legend Jonny Fairplay, and Survivor Island of The Idols Janet Carbin as they breakdown Episode 2 of Survivor 51. We will be assessing all of the action from

Oct 1
39 min

Survivor 44's Carolyn Wiger- Reality After Show

In this episode of Beyond the Torch, hosts Todd Herzog and Leslie Nease welcome Survivor icon Carolyn Wiger for a wide-ranging, deeply personal conversation. Carolyn shar

Sep 29
56 min

Wonka's The Golden Ticket! Episodes 1-5 After Show

Join Podcaster Lauren Pratt and Squid Game The Challenge's Dan Bartolomeo as the discuss episodes 1-5 of Netflix's new hit show Wonka's The Golden Ticket! Let us know in

Sep 28
1 h 18 min

BB28 Thursday Eviction Livestream Live From Crush and Brew -Reality After Show

Join host Bobby Goodsby in the chat where he will take your questions live on stream during the #BB28 Thursday Eviction Watch Party Live from Crush and Brew In Southern C

Sep 25
39 min

Survivor 51 After Show Premiere Recap - Reality After Show

Join Survivor Legend Jonny Fairplay, Survivor 47's Gabe Ortis, and Producer Bobby Goodsby as we breakdown the Premiere of Survivor 51. We will be assessing each of the ac

Sep 24
54 min

Survivor 51 and Big Bother 28 Live Watch Party- Reality After Show

Join host Bobby Goodsby in the chat where he will take your questions live on stream during the #Survivor51 and #BB28 Watch Party. Hangout as he watches the episode's, a

Sep 24
3 h 11 min

Survivor Guatemala's Brooke Struck Stephens -Reality After Show

In this episode of Beyond the Torch, hosts Todd Herzog and Leslie Nease interview Brooke Struck from Survivor: Guatemala, covering her brief but memorable four-episode ru

Sep 22
58 min

Survivor 51 Cast Draft

Join Hosts Lauren Pratt and DONDI Season 2's Phillip Solomon as they welcome in guests Danni Boatwright (Survivor Guatemala and Winners At War), Lyrsa Torres (Survivor Da

Sep 21
1 h 31 min

Chart trend

Position in the After Shows chart (US), last 90 days.

#1#99#196JulAugSepOct

#48

all-time peak

days in the top 50 since Nov 2024

Chart positions

Where Reality After Show ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Oct 29, 2026).

#173 ▼ 31 After Shows US

What listeners say

A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.

I listen to Jonny and his team on occasion for the Survivor content. It’s good counter programming to the usual fare if you are looking for a point of view that is more raw and unfiltered. My biggest issue is with the ads. They are frequent and disruptive, interrupting the podcasts without warning. If they can clean that up a bit, it would be a better listening experience.

QuietRiot76 · Nov 2025

Thank you for telling it like it is- no kissing up to the Challenge contestants , you tell what you REALLY think! Refreshing change from the other Reality TV podcasts that are afraid to call people out! Johnny has many nostalgic memories that make this Podcast really fun.

Luluwans · Jul 2022

I can only speak towards their challenge recaps as I don’t listen to their other podcast episodes. That being said I think their challenge episodes are great! The group is funny and has good chemistry and is the only challenge podcast that doesn’t have a past (or present) cast member as the host and is still good. I think Johnny and his own fame helps but his connection to the show is strong and their cast guests are great. Love the show, keep doing it and keep doing you.

PMart96 · Apr 2021

I was really glad to see this podcast cover The Circle UK, especially with the interviews of the cast. However Professor Tim, whom I loved on his season, dominates the conversation speaking more about his season than showing genuine curiosity to the guests. Many of his questions seem to be structured for himself to answer rather than eliciting the responses from the guests. Would be improved if we heard from Elaine more and Tim less.

BeltlineJunkie · Apr 2021

We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.