Pink Shade: Reality TV Recaps with Mary Payne artwork

After Shows · Mary Payne Gilbert | Reality TV Podcaster

Pink Shade: Reality TV Recaps with Mary Payne

by Mary Payne Gilbert | Reality TV Podcaster

Pink Shade, hosted by Mary Payne Gilbert, has the best breakdowns and takedowns of your favorite reality TV. Mary Payne recaps the shows we all love (and love to hate) three times a week with rotating co-hosts. Popular topics include:  WeTV's Love After Lockup franchise (including Love During Lockup, Life After Lockup and more)TLC's 90 Day Fiance franchise including Before the 90 Days (BT90Days), 90 Day The Other Way (90DayTOW), 90 Day Happily Ever After (90DayHEA) and moreBravoTV's Real Housewives (RHOSLC, RHOC, RHOBH, RHOP, RHONY, RHOM, and more), The Valley, VanderPump Rules, and morePopular guests include: Keisha Owens (The Libra Lounge with Keisha) - permanent co-host on MondaysKimberly (A Date with Dateline) - permanent co-host on TuesdaysKate Casey (Reality Life with Kate Casey)Doug Budin (Jeff Lewis Live)John Hill (Radio Andy)Amy Phillips (Drama, Darling)Ace Fanning (Sh$t Talk with Ace & Katelyn)Mandy Slutsker (Is This Real Life)Ryan Bailey (So Bad It's Good)Brian Moylan (New York Times Bestselling Author: The Housewives: The Real Story of the Real Housewives)Gibson Johns (Gabbing with Gib)Chris DeRosa (Fixing Famous People)Mary Payne and her guests untangle the complexities, love lives, family relationships, and general ridiculousness of the fascinating people on Bravo, WeTV, TLC and more! Learn more: www.pinkshadepodcast.com

Latest episodes

Showing 20 · updated from the feed

2147 PINK SHADE - 90DayTOW (s8e7) "Out of the Frying Pan Into the Family" with Kimberly & Mary Payne

#37 trending · TV & Film

Mary Payne chats with Kimberly about 90 Day Fiance The Other Way (s8e7) "Out of the Frying Pan, Into the Family". On this episode, Andi dons a Where's Waldo sweater and g

Nov 17
1 h 37 min

2146 PINK SHADE - LALU: Relationship Rehab (s1e7) "Sink or Swim" with Keisha and Mary Payne

Mary Payne and Keisha chat about the latest episode of Love After Lockup Relationship Rehab (s1e7) "Sink or Swim". Thank goodness this episode was a bit lighter than the

Nov 16
1 h 08 min

2145 - Pop and Bravo with Brian J. Moylan and Mary Payne

Mary Payne talks with writer, fashion icon, friend and President of the Real Housewives Institute, Dame Brian J. Moylan. Of course we chat about the Housewives, The Golde

Nov 12
1 h 10 min

2144 - Pink Shade: 90 Day Fiance The Other Way (s8e6) "Hakuna Ma-Drama" with Kimberly

Mary Payne is BACK from Italy and ready to chat about 90 Day Fiance The Other Way (s8e6) "Hakuna Ma-Drama" with Kimberly. On this episode, Zuri learns manners and stands

Nov 10
1 h 47 min

2143 - Pink Shade TAKEOVER: Love After Lockup - Relationship Rehab (s1ep6) with Kimberly and Keisha

We did it! Keisha and Kimberly's Bunkie Takeover Week is finished and we didn't ruin the podcast! Hopefully. Not yet at least. We still have this episode of Love After Lo

Nov 9
1 h 22 min

2142 Pink Shade - The Swan (Hulu) with Mary Payne and Chris DeRosa

Mary Payne talks to her friend, podcaster and reality TV producer, Chris DeRosa about Hulu's The Swan. The Swan was a 2004 TV show that made "regular" women beautiful thr

Nov 5
1 h 02 min

2141 - Pink Shade TAKEOVER: 90 Day Fiancé - TOW (s8ep5) with Keisha and Kimberly

It's Day 2 of K & K Try To Ruin Pink Shade AKA Bunkie Takeover Week! It's 90 Day The Other Way, S.8 Ep. 5! Mary Payne is off in Italy stalking Vittorio, while we are stuc

Nov 3
1 h 26 min

2140 - PINK SHADE TAKEOVER: LALU Relationship Rehab (s1ep5) with Keisha and Kimberly

Mary Payne is living her best life in Italy and she's left Keisha and Kimberly in charge for some very ill-advised reason! On Day 1 of "K & K Try to Ruin Pink Shade", it'

Nov 2
1 h 17 min

2139 - Pink Shade: Pop & Bravo with Aliza Rosen and Mary Payne

Mary Payne chat Bravo and podcasting with her friend, Aliza Rosen.  We give our thoughts on the new RHONY (love), the new season of RHOP (love), RHSLC (love/hate) and of

Oct 29
1 h 00 min

2138 - 90 Day: The Other Way (s8e4) "Schnapps on the Rocks" with Kimberly

Mary Payne and Kimberly chat about the latest episode of 90 Day Fiance: The Other Way (s8e4) "Schnapps on the Rocks". We have a new couple, Michelle and Felix from Ghana.

Oct 27
1 h 48 min

2137 - Love After Lockup: Relationship Rehab (s1e4) "Confessions" with Keisha

Mary Payne and Keisha talk about Love After Lockup: Relationship Rehab (s1e4) "Confessions". On this episode, we find out that Joey snorted his prescribed Xanax through a

Oct 26
1 h 13 min

2136 - Pop and Bravo with Jason Zeffir

Mary Payne talks to writer Jason Zeffir (Zombies of the Upper East Side) about The Golden Life on E! Long story short, we love this show! Episode 1 had everything: Ramona

Oct 22
1 h 06 min

2135 - 90 Day Fiance: TOW (s8e3) "No Shoes, No Trust, Big Problems" with Kimberly

Mary Payne and Kimberly break down the latest episode of 90 Day Fiance: The Other Way (s8e3) "No Shoes, No Trust, Big Problems". Andi arrives in Australia and we immediat

Oct 20
1 h 17 min

2134 -Love After Lockup- Relationship Rehab (s1e3) "Breakdowns and Breakthroughs" with Keisha 

Mary Payne and Keisha talk about Love After Lockup: Relationship Rehab (s1e3) "Breakdowns and Breakthroughs," and wow, don't take a shot every time Michael cries!  Poor M

Oct 19
1 h 19 min

2133- BONUS-  Interview with Justine, Michael and Dr. Ish of LALU- Relationship Rehab

Mary Payne chats with Justine, Michael and Dr. Ish of LALU: Relationship Rehab.  Mary Payne gives Dr. Ish his flowers as the best therapist we've seen on TV!  MP also div

Oct 19
25 min

2132- Pop and Bravo with Melissa Reich (Your Bish Therapist)

Mary Payne chats with Melissa Reich (Your Bish Therapist) about the latest in our Bravo world!  We give our thoughts on the non sisterhood of the Salt Lake city women.  W

Oct 15
1 h 17 min

2131- 90 Day Fiance- The Other Way (s8e2) "Kiasu, Kancheong and Carry On" with Kimberly

MP and Kimberly are back from LibraFest and ready to dive back into the 90 Day world!  On this episode of 90 Day Fiance: The Other Way (s8e2) "Kiasu, Kancheong and Carry

Oct 13
1 h 22 min

2130-Love After Lockup-  Relationship Rehab (s1e2) "Trauma Bonds" with Keisha

Trigger warnings - this episode discuses domestic violence, child abuse and sexual assault. Mary Payne and Keisha chat about a very somber episode of Love After Lockup: R

Oct 12
1 h 19 min

2129-BONUS: 90 Day Hunt for Love (s2e1) "The Girl Who Got the Ick" with Kimberly

Mary Payne and Kimberly chat about a new season of Hunt for Love.  It's 90 Day Hunt for Love (s2e1) "The Girl Who Got the Ick".  Our 90 Day cast members are Emma, Brittan

Oct 8
1 h 19 min

2128 -90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way (s8e1) "Love Lies and La Dolce Vita" with Kimberly

Mary Payne and Kimberly discuss the brand spanking new season of 90 Day Fiance: The Other Way and the premiere episode (s8e1) "Love Lies and La Dolce Vita".  We have the

Oct 6
1 h 20 min

Chart trend

Position in the After Shows chart (US), last 90 days.

#4
all-time peak
125
days in the top 10 since Nov 2024

Chart positions

Where Pink Shade: Reality TV Recaps with Mary Payne ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Nov 18, 2026).

#12 ▲ 2 After Shows US
#89 ▼ 7 TV & Film US

What listeners say

A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.

Love Kimberly’s quick wit and relatable humor; always makes my podcast-listening days better!

Inquisitively · Jul 2026

Got introduced to Pink Shade from the Bad TV podcast. Love listening to the Pop and Bravo episodes- especially the ones where Pat, Dylan and/or Ruby join. Thanks for the laughs!

Babushka310 · Jul 2026

The only reason I watch any of these shows is for the Pink Shade recaps. Mary Payne is hilarious (her impressions are spot-on) and Keisha and Kimberly are the best!SO funny. I stream YouTube to my TV and never miss an episode. Thank you so much, ladies for the hours of laughter you provide! (I’ve been a listener for many years, finally got around to writing a review 🫤)

Sherryann112 · Jun 2026

I’m very late to the party but I’ve heard Mattie of The Reality Gays talk so much about Mary Payne I decided to give it a shot and I’m so glad that I did! I was pleasantly surprised - I’ve tried other 90 Day podcasts but the sharp humor and good feedback from Pink Shade definitely shades most of the other pods out there! And since I’ve started I’ve only heard Kimberly - but I can’t imagine the show without her! She elicits the giggles and great points throughout. Thank you Mary Payne and Kimberly!

Pdxbella · Jun 2026

I love pink shade for 90 day fiancé and love after lockup podcast but Kimberly is the worst part of the pod to me . MP and Keisha are a great duo for LAL but when it comes to 90DF I sometimes wish it was just MP. Kimberly seems to have a real disdain for men and alway puts the faults on men for every scenario on the show no matter the issue at hand. She’s quick to always say “ let’s not talk about women’s body” but in the same breath has no problem critiquing men’s bodies in all capacities. My wife and I cringe often at her wildly off takes and blaming of just men even if the women cause issues from time to time. I would also love what “ gangster street talk is” in the latest episode for last resort. Kara said the word “fa sho” and Kimberly went on to say now she talks like a street gangster 🙃🙃. She acts like the most progressive person ever but says micro aggressive things like that smh do better

Mac Donny · Jun 2026

I’ve been a listener since it was Erin’s podcast.., many years. I really enjoy the show… and I know they have to make money with sponsors…. But there are WAY. TOO. MANY. ADS. And they are LONG ads… like 15 mins of a 1 hour podcast.

Workingk9 · Nov 2024

We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.

More podcasts like Pink Shade: Reality TV Recaps with Mary Payne

Popular shows in After Shows, for your next listen.

Browse charts by category

Daily updated Apple Podcasts rankings for the United States.

About Pink Shade: Reality TV Recaps with Mary Payne on Reason.fm

Here you find the Apple Podcasts chart positions of Pink Shade: Reality TV Recaps with Mary Payne, its latest episodes to listen to directly, and reviews from listeners. Rankings are updated daily for the United States.

Contact

Questions or issues? Reach us at hello@reason.fm

0:000:00