People are the Worst

Cynthia Hoffman | 223

Cynthia Hoffman was 19-years-old living in Anchorage, Alaska with her family who she was extremely close with. On June 2, 2019 Cynthia told her father she was going on a

Am I The Worst? | 8

For todays palate cleanser, we're going to tell you about a (hilarious-turned-not-so-much) scuffle between husband and wife over the name of their unborn baby Original P

Introducing: Crimes of Reddit

Reddit is an endless archive of humanity’s most disturbing, bizarre, and deeply human stories. If you love going down internet rabbit holes, you are going to love CRIMES

Todd Kohlhepp | 222

In 2016, a young couple named Charlie Carver and Kala Brown went missing from Anderson, South Carolina. After over two months of searching, investigators were led to a 95

Isaiah Carvalho | 221

From the outside, Isaiah Carvalho and Valerie Cincinelli's life looked picture-perfect. But behind closed doors there was a crumbling marriage, a secret relationship, acc

Kat Torres | 220

Kat Torres had a terrible childhood growing up in Brazil. She was determined to break away from her family & make a name for herself. After a modeling agency discovered h

Donna Ferres | 219

On August 2, 1979 at 3:30 a.m. Donna Ferres was working the overnight shift at a 7-Eleven when a man walked through the door. He kept his hat low and his head down, immed

Am I The Worst? | 7

Imagine donating to a cause and accidentally donating 100x more than you meant to... Click here for the original post Click here for the GoFundMe Sponsors: -Goodles

Shannon Melendi | 218

In 1994, 19-year-old Emory University student, Shannon Melendi, was working as a scorekeeper at a softball game when she left in between games and never came back. She se

Jennifer Holliday & Ana Franklin | 217

In 2005, 27-year-old EMT, Jennifer Holliday, was living in Lufkin, TX with her son and 18-year-old cousin, Ana Franklin.  On the night of May 29th, Jennifer was picking

Bonnie Hood | 216

In August 1990, a small mountain town in California was shocked when two people were shot at the beloved Camp Nelson Lodge, a retreat in the Sierra Nevada Mountains. The

BONUS: 5 Cases You Need To Know About | 215

Today is a bonus for everyone! This will NOT take away from this week's episode, you're getting 2 because you rock. Today we're talking about specific cases we learned ab

Maternal Instinct: A Discussion with Jami Rice of Murderish | 214

This episode is a special edition where we sit down with Murderish podcast host, Jami Rice, to talk about the Netflix documentary, Maternal Instinct, which details the he

THROWBACK EPISODE 143: Taylor Parker

Originally aired 3/13/2025 Following the new Netflix documentary, Maternal Instinct, we are re-releasing our own episode on Taylor Parker. Truth be told, the documentar

Rozanne Gailiunas | 213

When Detective Morris McGowan walked into the brutal crime scene of a 33-year-old woman in Dallas, TX, he knew it wasn't going to be an ordinary investigation...but holy

Am I The Worst? | 6

Another month, another problematic fiance. In today's AITW ep, we discuss boundaries and overstepping in-laws. Produced by Jacob Hollabaugh SPONSORS: -Goodles: Goodle

Corinna Mullen | 212

On October 2, 1987, a city worker in Central City, Kentucky noticed a car parked where it shouldn't be. Upon examining the car, he realized blood was dripping out of the

Shelly Tyburski | 211

In March 2015, a developer was checking his construction site in North Ridgeville, Ohio when he finds the body of a young woman behind a mound of snow. She was beaten, bo

Michael Benanti and Brian Witham | 210

In 2015, Matthew Yussman and his 70-year-old mother were held hostage and Matthew was forced to rob the very credit union that employed him. The entire situation is bizar

Sherry Hopson | 209

It was 1981 in Naperville, IL. A woman, who lived alone, woke up to use the bathroom in the middle of the night. In her groggy state, she walked out of her bedroom and sa