Mama Mystery isn't your average true crime podcast. Every Tuesday, your host Kelly rips into the cases that keep people up at night: the headline-grabbers everyone thinks they know, and the overlooked ones that deserve a hell of a lot more attention. Backed by real research (not just Wikipedia and vibes), Kelly breaks down evidence, picks apart theories, and calls out the details that don't add up — all in a voice that feels less "true crime lecture" and more "your friend who's read every case file." Her husband Austin crashes the mic often enough to keep things honest and occasionally hilarious.
This isn't storytelling for shock value — it's for the victims who deserve to be remembered right and the listeners who want the truth, not the theatrics. Subscribe, get obsessed, and join a community that takes true crime as seriously as it deserves. Make sure you also follow True Crime Kelly on Facebook and TikTok to stay up to date on all things True Crime.
Welcome to Mama Mystery. ✨
Latest episodes
Showing 20 · updated from the feed
Ep 232 : Caleb Flynn Trial: Everything We Know About the Ashley Flynn Murder Case
Former American Idol contestant and worship pastor Caleb Flynn is on trial for the murder of his wife, Ashley Flynn, a beloved Tipp City, Ohio teacher and volleyball coac
Sep 16 34 min
Ep 231 : Lindsay Clancy MISTRIAL & Corie Walsh
Seven weeks of trial. Eighty-plus witnesses. Seven days of deliberations. And then, nothing. A Plymouth County jury could not agree on whether Lindsay Clancy is criminall
Sep 9 52 min
Ep 230 : The Trial of Lindsay Clancy
In January 2023, Duxbury nurse Lindsay Clancy strangled her three young children and then jumped from a second-story window in a suicide attempt that left her paralyzed.
Sep 2 1 h 27 min
TWD: Another Teacher Predator, Mansion Chaos & a Vice Mayor’s Death
Finalist for Colorado Teacher of the Year Sentenced for Relationship with Student Former American Idol Contestant Accused of Killing Wife — Trial Date Set NHL Reporter
Apr 3 40 min
TWD : Realtor Open House Murder Arrest, Triple Homicide in Illinois, Utah Nurse Conviction, Hawaii Doctor Trial & More
This week’s Weekly Docket breaks down multiple major cases across the country, from long-awaited arrests to ongoing trials and shocking new charges. Here’s everything we’
Mar 27 1 h 02 min
Kouri Richins Trial : THE VERDICT
Kouri Richins will be sentenced on what would've been Eric's 44th birthday.
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.co
Mar 17 30 min
Kouri Richins Trial Days 9-14
In this episode, we’re breaking down the latest developments in the Kouri Richins murder trial. Kouri is accused of poisoning her husband, Eric Richins, with a lethal dos
Mar 17 25 min
TWD : Nurse Affair Murder, Teacher Killed in Senior Prank, Fake Cancer Insulin Trial & ISIS Bomb Plot
This week’s Weekly Docket covers six major true crime cases making headlines right now.
First, we break down the arrest of Florida nurse Rene Perez in the brutal killing
Mar 13 36 min
Kouri Richins Trial Days 2-5
In this episode, we’re breaking down the latest developments in the Kouri Richins murder trial. Kouri is accused of poisoning her husband, Eric Richins, with a lethal dos
Mar 11 30 min
Ep 137 :The Death of Eric Richins: A Children's Book, Fentanyl, and a Chilling Mystery
Eric Richins was a successful businessman, a devoted father, and a well-respected member of the Kamas, Utah, community. But his sudden death in March 2022 sent shockwaves
Mar 10 46 min
Kouri Richins Trial Day 1 - Opening Statements and First Witnesses
In this episode, we’re breaking down the latest developments in the Kouri Richins murder trial. Kouri is accused of poisoning her husband, Eric Richins, with a lethal dos
Mar 10 28 min
TWD : Cheer Competition Tragedy, a Hockey Rink Shooting, and a Navy Reservist on the Run
Las Vegas, Nevada — Mom Kills Pre-Teen Daughter and Then Herself in Hotel During Cheerleading TripPawtucket, Rhode Island — Targeted Hockey Rink Shooting Leaves Two Dead
Feb 20 40 min
Ep 229 : The Ponzi Scheme Murder
From the outside, Michael and Natalie Cochran looked like a successful, involved West Virginia family — youth sports, church, a growing business, and a life that seemed t
Feb 19 54 min
Ep 228 : The Devil's Daughter : Sharon Louise Carr
In 1992, the brutal murder of an 18-year-old young woman shocked a quiet English community and sent police searching for a violent, experienced predator. The crime scene
Feb 11 45 min
TWD : Abduction of Nancy Guthrie, Captor Mauls Woman's Face, Murder of Hailey Buzbee, Man Shot After Good Deed
Tucson, Arizona — The Disappearance of Nancy Guthrie84-year-old mother of Today co-anchor Savannah Guthrie missing under suspicious circumstances; home treated as a crime
Feb 6 36 min
Ep 227 : The Au Pair Affair : Brendan Banfield
When Christine Banfield was brutally attacked inside her own home, her husband Brendan claimed he had interrupted a violent intruder and acted in self-defense. But as inv
Feb 5 1 h 00 min
TWD : Olympic Snowboarder turned Drug Lord, True Crime Producer on FBI Most Wanted List, and Student Stabs Teacher in Montana
This week’s Weekly Docket covers the following cases:
Lakeville, Minnesota: Jack Joseph Ball pleads guilty to the murder of his pregnant sister, Bethany Ann Israel.Inter
Jan 30 41 min
MAMA MINUTE : Taylor Swift Legal Drama, Fernando Mendoza, Building an Igloo (WITH AUSTIN!) and more!
Welcome back to the Mama Minute — because sometimes, you just need a minute.
A minute away from the weight of true crime.
A minute away from the monotony. A break in to
Jan 28 48 min
Ep 226 : The Gentry House of Lies *PATREON EXCLUSIVE*
To listen to the full episode, click here!
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Jan 26 2 min
TWD : Who Is Michael McKee, Homicide in England, Machete in Scotland, M/S in Idaho
We begin with the latest developments in the murders of Spencer and Monique Tepe, including new context surrounding the suspect, his background, and unanswered questions
Jan 23 22 min
Chart positions
Where Mama Mystery with Kelly Evans ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Sep 28, 2026).
A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.
6/30/25 Update: i have officially gotten through every episode!! Now i dont know what im going to do with my extra time 😂
Love this podcast and love both Kelly and Austin.
I work at a desk for 8-9 hours a day and then drive 30 minutes one way to get my kiddos before and after work. This is my go to and i’m listening to this podcast the entire time. Over the past year i’ve really gotten into the true crime world and hearing about some of the craziest stories out there. Some of the episodes i’ve heard on other podcasts but i really enjoy Kelly and Austin’s take on it. I love that it’s not filtered because honestly that’s how i am as well. Austin reminds me so much of my brother 😂 It’s also so cool because i actually went and started at episode one on this podcast so i feel like (even though not in real time yet) im growing with kelly and austin through all the technical difficulties and life in general. Way to go. I’m on episode 100 now. still got quite a ways to go but i’m going to be so lost when i have to wait for episodes lol
Darrian Dorsey · Jun 2025
I just LOVE Kelly and Austin! Kelly does her research and is very thorough. The two of them are entertaining together and hilarious! Top 5 podcast for sure! Been listening since the beginning and they just keep getting better!
ashgreen82 · Jun 2025
I’ve been a listener since the beginning I love the deep dives and the weekly docket episodes
Thanks for doing such great investigative work!
KikiCarter · May 2025
I was late to the game in discovering this podcast, but I have enjoyed it and have added it to my library for my commute. I have a 45 minute drive, and I like how I’m able to listen to at least one whole episode within that time. I also love Austin, and their banter with each other. I have about 50 episodes left, and will be completely caught up on all the older episodes! I have also enjoyed how she’s branched out and have been covering the highlights of high profile cases as well. I do want to keep up on some court case, but unfortunately find myself losing interest with other podcasters recaps, but I don’t with Kelly.
KHay724 · May 2025
Sharing a religious book while talking about the lives lost due to the flooding in Texas is insensitive. Can you imagine someone who lost their family member seeing that who doesn’t subscribe to the same religion? I don’t think you intended to hurt anyone but please consider how something like that comes across.
nickname_9001 · Jul 2025
We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.
More podcasts like Mama Mystery with Kelly Evans
Popular shows in True Crime, for your next listen.
Here you find the Apple Podcasts chart positions of Mama Mystery with Kelly Evans, its latest episodes to listen to directly, and reviews from listeners. Rankings are updated daily for the United States.
