Our curated selection of reviews
For the thoughtful baseball fan. Alternate realities, hard truths, provocative topics. Don’t listen if you don’t want your values and preconceptions to be challenged. Sully is unabashedly biased in some ways, and that’s why I appreciate him. He’s refreshingly human and honest. He’s laceratingly funny, too. Best of all, he’s an absolute force of knowledge on the greatest American game.
-UPDATE, about a year later-
I’m listening less often nowadays. Partly to do with my need to listen to Fantasy Baseball Today from the young guys who run that show for CBS and do a great job. But Locked on MLB is becoming a bit tedious to listen to because of all the ads and the number of guests Sully has on. It seems to be Millard Thomas every other day. Or that H-Town guy. Nothing against Millard Thomas, it’s just that I came from the days of Sully Baseball Daily and thought that was a perfect show where guests were infrequent but quality, and ads were nonexistent. I understand that things sometimes have to evolve over time, not always to our liking. C’est la vie. But podcasts exist in the past, present, and future, and I’m missing the past, not loving the present, and hoping for a better future for this show.
Read more
Sully does a fantastic job on his daily podcast. He is a true baseball fan who covers the entire league; no frills, no gimmicks, just a knowledgeable and passionate baseball podcast.
Read more
6/29/22 stumbled on this MLB referenced podcast on Audacy, then went to Apple to make this review…Love it! Sully is unabashed but not annoying and doesn’t talk all the fluff and kissy crap you hear on MLB network. Further, he exudes his love for the game while not acting as a “know it all”. I’m listening to library shows now: good stuff indeed .
Read more
I love listening to podcasts in bed to wind down, and maybe it’s my imagination but it seems the sound quality has improved a lot recently. The show is now much easier to listen to than it was. If there have been recent efforts to improve the sound, please know it’s appreciated!
Love the content too! I used to think we went off on too many tangents but I’ve grown to enjoy that part of the show. There also seems to be less of them now that baseball has started (I began listening in the off-season).
Thanks for the show!
Read more
The show is totally unorganized. It’s as if the host creates a list of things to talk about for a set amount of time the show has to run, but there’s no research or thought put into it. It’s simply ranting.
If you want to listen to someone loudly discuss narratives they create based on headlines they saw because they think they know everything, enjoy the show. I’m looking for more depth and actual insights.
Read more
We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts