In season 1, we explore Holly's massive family secret. When she was just 17, Holly Brown’s dad was dying of cancer. It looked like life couldn’t get more traumatic, until her dad dropped a bombshell….or two bombshells, really: twin brothers that her entire family kept secret. She was the only one who didn’t know they existed. After his death left her with more questions than answers, Holly sets out to uncover how a secret this big could be hidden, and why the sitcoms that raised her were often the only way to make sense of a life stranger than TV.
But Season 1 was only Holly's f*cked up family sitcom. In season 2, we get to know yours...
Latest episodes
Showing 20 · updated from the feed
The One With 'Not Just A Terrible Story'
#29 trending · Personal Journals
When Stacie Love married her former high school teacher, she thought it was a whirlwind romance.
Two decades later, she discovered the truth behind the day their lives
Oct 28 38 min
Episode 12 - The One Where Holly Gets Catfished...Twice!
This week, the camera is turning back toward the OG main character for two stories Holly considered telling in Season One - but wasn’t ready to share.
We’re talking catf
Oct 21 1 h 02 min
Episode 11 - The One With Lisa Wallen's Trial By Internet Trolls
Comedian Lisa Wallen and Holly have a lot in common: alcoholic dads, complicated childhoods, and an ability to make a joke at the worst possible time. But Lisa’s life cha
Oct 14 1 h 09 min
Episode 10 - The One With Hunter Hill and His Grandpa's CIA Secret
This mission, if you choose to accept it, is unlike any EKBM mission we’ve had before…and it’s top secret.
After his grandfather died, comedian Hunter Hill and his siste
Oct 7 1 h 08 min
Episode 9 - The One Where Licensed Therapist Minaa B. Listens To Your Stories
You asked, we answered - this week is all listener stories, and you really came through with the wildest sibling revelations, secret family drama and EKBM level dysfuncti
Sep 30 1 h 11 min
Episode 8 - The One Where Bridget Todd Befriends A Chatbot
Award-winning journalist, podcast host, and digital activist Bridget Todd has spent years examining how technology shapes our lives. Then in 2025, within an incredibly sh
Sep 23 1 h 05 min
Episode 7 - The One Where Gabrielle Moss Escapes The Parent Trap
A lot of you probably think your parents are a little annoying, or even kinda overbearing. But how far would they have to go for you to decide to cut them off completely?
Sep 16 1 h 05 min
Episode 6 - The One Where Laurie Kilmartin Laughs in the Face of Death
Emmy-nominated writer and comedian Laurie Kilmartin spent 11 years making Conan O’Brien laugh, made the entire country laugh on Last Comic Standing, Comedy Central and Th
Sep 9 1 h 02 min
Episode 5 - The One With Eric Owusu's Passport Trauma
What if your family sitcom’s vacation episode came with a few extra shocking plot twists? Comedian and writer Eric Owusu got his own when a trip to Ghana brought some sho
Sep 2 57 min
Episode 4 - The One With Evan Ayers' Celebrity Intervention
What if the person you were watching on TV actually did step out of the screen and into your life? After nearly a decade battling addiction, comedian Evan Ayers walked in
Aug 26 1 h 08 min
The One With The 'Burden of Guilt'
Just five days after her engagement to Kenny, Cindy learns that her fiancé was accused of abusing one of Cindy’s children. The facts behind the accusation didn’t add up t
Aug 19 6 min
Episode 3 - The One With Adam Loyd's Genetic Genie In A Bottle
WGA screenwriter and fellow sitcom expert Adam Lloyd always thought his family was just him, his mom, and a dad who wasn’t really in the picture. Then he sent his spit in
Aug 12 1 h 02 min
Episode 2 - The One With Julia Austin's Inner Child Detective
Comedian Julia Austin thought she knew her father...until she walked into her dad's office one day and discovered he'd been living an entirely different life. Julia joins
Aug 5 58 min
Episode 1 - The One With Valerie Tosi's DNA Plot Twist
Comedian, actress, and Millennial Mood Board host Valerie Tosi joins us as our first guest of Season 2 to chat about growing up with addiction, parenting yourself, and br
Jul 29 1 h 03 min
Welcome Back for Season 2!
You didn’t think we were done, did you? Season 2 is coming in hot. And it will have even more family secrets, chaos, drama, big feelings, wild twists… but this time, it’s
Jul 22 3 min
You Might Like...Discount Dave (and the Fix) from CBC’s Personally
Everybody has a party story. Host and creator of Personally: Discount Dave (and the Fix) Rebecca Auerbach’s involved in a run-in with rock icon David Lee Roth (you know,
Jul 15 23 min
Episode 10 - The One With The Season Finale
We finally made it! It’s the season one finale. And like any good sitcom season, it ends with revelations, reflections, guest appearances (yes, we finally hear from the s
Jul 8 42 min
Episode 9 - The One With Dana Gould's Fictional Father
Holly can’t be the only one who has processed their family secrets and trauma by creating art. So what can she learn from someone else who has been through this before? H
Jul 1 55 min
Episode 8 - The One Where I Meet My Brothers
Every sitcom has to have it’s special holiday episode. Holly’s version has family drama, a meal at a Mexican restaurant, and some extra special guest appearances: her br
Jun 24 44 min
Episode 7 - The One Where I Find The Punchline
What to do with a childhood filled with trauma? Become a stand-up comedian of course! Holly shares how comedy helped her process her past, and how it’s getting her ready
Jun 17 50 min
Chart trend
Position in the Personal Journals chart (US), last 90 days.
#1#20#38JulAugSepOct
#1
all-time peak
34
days in the top 3 since Mar 2026
Chart positions
Where Everybody Knows But Me ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Oct 29, 2026).
A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.
This podcast found me at the right time! I too have been toying with art as a mechanism for emotional processing and connection. I found myself relating strongly to the FEELINGS Holly and others in her family experienced, even though I did not have the same experiences as Holly and her family. Great work!
MeLorraine · Sep 2026
First season - The most personally relatable podcast I’ve ever heard. I feel less alone listening. I’m excited for each episode and also hopeful knowing I’m not the only one who made it out. 5 stars. Second season - Lots of unnecessary swearing that adds almost nothing to the podcast. It’s also sometimes hard to hear the narrator because she mumbles at the end of a joke. I do appreciate how they can recognize terrible things their parents have done, but also hold space for the fact that they’ve gone through a lot of bad stuff too — 4 stars
SRM4:36 · Sep 2026
Found the story mostly interesting and her dynamic with her siblings was sweet and they seem great. But I couldn’t believe how she handled when her family invited the brothers to thanksgiving….they’re their family too, and they had to ask your permission? She completely changed how I saw her—she made them all about her. And she literally said at one point after she met them that this story wasn’t about them, it’s about her. I think Holly needs to do some self reflection and realize these two people actually aren’t only important because of how they relate to her.
Definitelybusy · Aug 2026
This show was such a surprise that I started to listening to solely because it was rated one of the top Apple podcasts. I was not disappointed and listened to every episode back to back! Holly takes such serious topics and brings them to life in a way that definitely keeps your attention. It’s the most unique podcast I’ve ever listened to.
RGAdopt · Aug 2026
This podcast is well edited but the first episode drags on and on, promising a shocking secret at the end… when you finally get there, the secret is one we’ve heard a million times before. I felt duped.
Ricky R Richard · Jul 2026
The story may be compelling but I didn’t make it past Holly and her obnoxious sister - they speak like teenage girls and Holly has an obnoxious tendency to set the stage like a theater kid. It’s all very juvenile. I don’t need to hear six examples of sitcom dads to remember the 90s. Get to the point and learn to tell stories in a more concise way.
NYC131313 · Sep 2026
We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.
More podcasts like Everybody Knows But Me
Popular shows in Personal Journals, for your next listen.
Here you find the Apple Podcasts chart positions of Everybody Knows But Me, its latest episodes to listen to directly, and reviews from listeners. Rankings are updated daily for the United States.
