Who Shat On The Floor At My Wedding? And Other Crimes

These three wonderful women are HYSTERICAL. I absolutely loved their antics, their senses of humor, their simultaneous amateurism and dedication when cracking the case. But there is also a real element of tension and mystery in the podcast as well, and a real excitement as Detective Lauren and her partners in non-crime inch closer to their ultimate revelations.

I want more of this type of entertainment. Super funny and ridiculous hijinks. Solved or not solved it’s still a fun journey. Love how candid Mike Berry and Jo the forensic person are about how amateur the detective work is. Great contrast! People that take the podcast too seriously are not the right audience for this. Easy listening entertainment. Relax 1 star people! Or go listen to some science if you can chill out a bit. I want more seasons!! Totally binge-worthy!

I was intrigued when I found out about this podcast, but I had no idea what to expect. After listening to most of the first season, I can say this is one of the funniest things I’ve ever listened to. It’s NOT a typical whodunnit true crime podcast! It’s a joke, people! The perfect amount of silly and fun, the characters are hilarious, and their Australian accents are the cherry on top

Both a thoughtful meta examination of true crime podcasts and a thoughtless romp full of laughter and warmth. And the sound design is top drawer too!

I initially liked the premise and I do find the women to have very funny personalities. And all of the “suspects” were all good sports - at least the ones that appeared in the podcast anyway. Where I think it went left was when they keep harping on how the act tarnished their wedding. Someone dealt with it and I’m sure the actual night went on just fine. As they also reiterate often, the guests at the wedding are all people they have close relationships with. Given the incident was likely an accident because common sense would suggest so (I mean really, why would someone you have a close relationship do that on purpose?), they didn’t even have the decency to not make it such a huge deal that they managed to make 13 episodes? I can’t imagine how embarrassed the “culprit” must feel now knowing these women went to such great lengths to figure out who did it, spoke to so many people, shared everything worldwide, etc.