The Redrum Theatre

Latest episodes

Showing 20 · updated from the feed

S1E187 - Barbarian

It's our annual Halloween tradition of making Nesto watch movies that are stinking scary!!!!

Oct 5
1 h 08 min

S1E186 - Wildcats

# Yo mama said you oogly!

Sep 7
1 h 07 min

S1E185 - Boyz in the Hood

Either they don't know, they don't show, or they don't care what happens in the hood.

Jul 20
1 h 07 min

S1E184 - An American Werewolf in Bruges

It's Swap Meet time! The Brothers trade movies. Nesto takes An American Werewolf in London while Tony watches In Bruges.

Jun 22
1 h 03 min

S1E183 - Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

"A toon killed his brother. Dropped a piano on his head."

May 3
1 h 00 min

S1E182 - 98th Annual Academy Awards

And the awards goes to....

Mar 23
1 h 03 min

S1E181 - Best in Show

A tip of the hat to the late Catherine O'Hara.

Mar 16
20 min

S1E180 - Tender Mercies

"I ain't never trusted happiness."

Feb 23
50 min

S1E179 - Out for Justice

Anyone see Richie?

Jan 26
1 h 00 min

S1E178 - 2025 All Media Roundup

The wait is finally over. The brothers release their 2025 best of list. Our favorite music, tv shows, and movies from a stellar year.

Dec 29 2025
1 h 09 min

S1E177 - Armed and Dangerous

"It's only legal in two states. And this isn't one of them."

Nov 17 2025
1 h 09 min

S1E176 - Halloween

# Evil has come to your little town.

Oct 29 2025
39 min

S1E175 - Late Night with the Devil

Antonio's Movie of 2024!

Oct 20 2025
43 min

S1E174 - The Natural

"I'm gonna be the best there ever was."

Sep 22 2025
1 h 07 min

S1E173 - Weekend at Bernies

He's not dead. He's alive!

Aug 25 2025
1 h 11 min

S1E172 - Michael Madsen In Memoriam

The Greatness Test has commenced!

Jul 28 2025
32 min

S1E171 - Crocodile Dundee

G'day mate!

Jul 14 2025
49 min

S1E170 - The Accountant

Happy Mother's Day from the Brothers!

May 11 2025
1 h 04 min

S1E169 - Gene Hackman

It's time for a Greatness Test!

Mar 31 2025
48 min

S1E168 - Hook

"What would the world be like without Captian Hook?"

Mar 17 2025
54 min

Chart trend

Position in the Film History chart (US), last 90 days.

#1#91#181JulAugSepOct

#52

all-time peak

days in the top 100 since Nov 2024

Chart positions

Where The Redrum Theatre ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Oct 10, 2026).

#117 NEW Film History US

What listeners say

A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.

Informative, edgy and a ton of fun to listen to. Every episode I find myself looking up scenes mentioned that I forgot existed. I highly recommend picking 1 episode and giving it a try, you’ll be hooked after that. This podcast is fun as a “mug” dude!

Brutusthebuckguy · Sep 2021

They go off the rails a lot, but that’s where the interesting conversation is! This one is never dry, it’s always super high energy and fun. Give it a shot, it’s worth it!

Necromerlinoid · Jan 2019

I love Redrum Theatre. I had to stop listening to it at the gym due to outbursts of laughter. As a fellow latch key kid, movies played a huge part in my upbringing. The Brothers have reminded me of stories that I had forgotten and even brought me to tears with their honesty. I suggest Highlander for a future episode. Thanks for an incredible podcast.

eliznoles · Jan 2019

I recently found these guys after listening to them on Not Your Pastors podcast. Went back and started binged listening to all the episodes. Love the concept, love how they go through how each movie raised them right and raised them wrong. Gives a unique twist to movie reviews. Keep up the good work guys

Hula hoop 123 · Apr 2018

We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.