Supernatural Then and Now - Podcast Rankings and reviews

Rob and Rich bring more of their signature charm and humor to this fun recap-rewatch-episodic review podcast. If you’ve ever watched Supernatural, this is a delightful way to get more of two awesome personalities from the cast. And if you haven’t, this is a great companion podcast to listen to as you watch the show for the first time. Finally, if you’ve ever been to a Supernatural convention, this dynamic will give you more of that satisfying feeling of being with your favorite cast for a fun hour or more. Highly recommend. Oh, and for those interested in “how the sausage is made” and behind the scenes info, you can learn SO much from the hosts and their guests who range from crew members to production designers to sound designers and engineers to directors. It’s a wonderfully insightful way to learn about the magic of episodic television production.

I have a few (3-4) staple podcasts in my library and I don’t know what I would do without Supernatural: Then & Now. Even if I weren’t a super fan of the show, the ridiculousness and hilarity of Rich & Rob provides me with so much joy! Absolutely a must listen every week!

BIG TIME SPN fan and BIG TIME fan of this podcast. Been listening since the beginning, only just now realized how easy it is to leave a review(sorry it took so long!!) I absolutely LOVE the detail and behind the scenes magic yall get into. It truly fills the SPN sized hole in my heart!! The laughs, the unfettered reviews, the detail, everything about this is amazing! Thank you guys so much for doing this!! I love yall!!!!

This show started out really great, and there are still good aspects of it, but over time Rob has gotten better but Rich has become more annoying. He can be funny but it’s obvious he thinks he’s extremely funny, but it gets tiresome with his interruptions and repetitive juvenile jokes. I don’t mind them once in a while but he acts more like an irritating teenager than a show host. Getting to the point where I will just read the transcripts so I don’t get annoyed by his immaturity.

These guys have the pull to get well know guests, but it’s hard to listen to - contrast with Ghostfacers, which is headed by two hardcore fans of the show, not a couple of guys looking for something to do during COVID. Ghostfacers is funny, witty and intelligent. Give that one a listen.