So Supernatural - Podcast Rankings and reviews

I agree with some of the other recent reviews, I enjoyed the show more with just Ashley. I am open to different hosts other than Ashley, but the sisters sound too scripted and not relatable. Some of it is downright cringy. It’s hard to listen sometimes, but I continue on because I love Ashley and all the work she does for her various podcasts and books. The episode about nightmare deaths came as a surprise that just Ashley was hosting! It was a great episode and I felt like we were back to the enjoyable and interesting podcast Supernatural once was. Not sure the sisters are right for this job.

It is bizarre to me that people are hating so much on the host transition. I think the roll out and framing it as a “big surprise” was part of the problem. That made for a much more awkward transition - “surprise, I’m completely changing the format of this show that you love!” is probably what generated so much hate. You hear “big surprise” and think something cool is coming, not a huge change like new hosts and a different format.

That aside, it is abundantly clear that they are listening to the feedback and adapting accordingly. Things change. Give them a chance to find their stride & lay off the Haterade y’all.

I just wanted to say that I thoroughly enjoy this podcast, keep up the great work. I especially like how the format is very casual in a way that feels like I’m hearing a story from a couple of friends. I LOVE hearing about other people’s experiences with the unknown. Very 10/10 definitely recommend! :3

Absolutely LOVED this podcast when it was just Ashley. The new format and hosts just aren’t really doing it for me anymore.. the topics are awesome, I just miss the way Ashley used to present them. Not so spooky/chilling anymore. I honestly can’t stand one of their voices and I hate being that way but it just throws things off a bit for me ☹️

I was so excited when they started to post shows again and I have tried to like the new hosts and format, but it’s just not the same. Ashley did a great job at presenting the stories in a way that kept the listener engaged and allowed them to decide whether the source of the story was supernatural or not. She also just researched things very thoroughly and from a variety of perspectives. Sadly the new format doesn’t seem to reflect this same level of desire for objectivity and thoroughness. Like other reviewers, I hope they can get the kinks out and work it out!

I was absolutely obsessed with season 1. Ashley had me hooked from the second she introduced the topic of each show. Ever since the host change though I’ve never really been hooked, I usually stop listening after 5-10min which bums me out cause I love the supernatural, just miss Ashley’s story telling.