Nightmare Soup

If you're a fan of the modern Nosleep Podcast, you'll enjoy Nightmare Soup. Many of the same talented voice over artists lend their talents here, and it shares a similar anthology format. The team's passion behind this podcast is also evident and proudly displayed. My reason for the three-star review is that the stories themselves are a mixed bag. The quality of writing ranges from mediocre to great, with a majority being average. The mid-roll ad breaks are also very intrusive and take up a good portion of each episode's run time.

We all had that book with the creepy black and white illustrations when we were kids. That’s why we’re here now still consuming horror content every day. Nightmare Soup aims to carry the torch that Alvin Schwartz lit with “Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark.” And oh yeah they keep that fire burning bright. Captivating creepy stories. Well produced all around. And even if you don’t enjoy horror you should listen to Nightmare Soup for the Theme Song because it is SO COOL. Love hearing a show take fun risks. When it would be so easy to just sound like every other horror show, Nightmare Soup went big, bold and unique. I love it. Nightmare Soup is a fantastic horror podcast, perfect for macabre fans of all ages.

This is a very well crafted production It has it all. I love that I’m listening to a great cast with all of my favorite voice actors. The stories are fresh!

Nightmare Soup is delightfully creepy, gross in exactly the way kids like, and voice acted with care and skill. What a good show.