Are You My Podcast? artwork

After Shows · Sarah Colonna & Mary Radzinski

Are You My Podcast?

by Sarah Colonna & Mary Radzinski

Comedians Sarah Colonna and Mary Radzinski laugh their way through trending topics, pop culture, and entertainment — peppering in personal stories along the way. And yes, they're obsessed with Married at First Sight.

Chart trend

Position in the After Shows chart (US), last 90 days.

#8
all-time peak
4
days in the top 10 since Nov 2024

Latest episodes

Showing 20 · updated from the feed

Married at First Sight, Season 20, Episodes 16 and 17 - Seattle

#29 trending · TV & Film

Sarah and Mary go hard into MAFS Season 20 Eps 16 and 17: another couple calls it quits, couple’s retreat weekend drama ensues, “attraction” comes into question yet again

Sep 9
1 h 18 min

Married at First Sight, Season 20, Episodes 14 and 15- Seattle

Sarah and Mary dive deep into MAFS Season 20 Eps 14 and 15: one couple calls time of death, sexual exploration, hot tub pushups, extreme indecisiveness - and more.  Join

Sep 2
1 h 21 min

Married at First Sight, Season 20, Episodes 12 and 13 - Seattle

Sarah and Mary RIP into MAFS Season 20 Eps 12 and 13: physical connections, zero physical connections, loyalty, rejection, group therapy - and more. Join us on Patreon f

Aug 26
1 h 34 min

Married at First Sight, Season 20, Episodes 10 and 11 - Seattle

Sarah and Mary RIP into MAFS Season 20 Eps 10 and 11: bad lying, a sexy game of HORSE, wifely duties (no thank you), cooked pickleball - and more. Join us on Patreon for

Aug 19
1 h 30 min

Married at First Sight, Season 20, Episodes 8 and 9 - Seattle

Sarah and Mary RIP into MAFS Season 20 Eps 8 and 9: love bombing, light dimming, family chats, feather ruffling, group therapy - and more. Join us on Patreon for more of

Aug 12
1 h 29 min

Married at First Sight, Season 20, Episodes 6 and 7 - Seattle

Sarah and Mary RIP into MAFS Season 20 Eps 6 and 7: bedroom regrets, bold accusations, expert interventions, group dinners - and more. Join us on Patreon for more of the

Aug 5
1 h 26 min

Married at First Sight, Season 20, Episodes 4 and 5 - Seattle

Sarah and Mary dive in head first on MAFS Season 20 Eps 4 and 5: red flags are flying high already! Icks, rejections, voices, laughs - and more. Join us on Patreon for m

Jul 29
1 h 33 min

Married at First Sight, Season 20, Episodes 2 and 3 - Seattle

Sarah and Mary go hard in the paint on MAFS Season 20 Eps 2 and 3: Editing conspiracy theories, expert mismatches, insecurities revealed - and more. Join us on Patreon f

Jul 22
1 h 24 min

Married at First Sight, Season 20, Episode 1 - Seattle

Sarah and Mary share their thoughts, laughs and rage (already!?) about MAFS Season 20 Ep 1. First three couples are matched, weddings  - and more. Join us on Patreon for

Jul 14
1 h 04 min

One Man’s Trash, iPhones and Declining Birth Rates, Mood Boosters For Right This Second

Sarah and Mary talk tchotchkes, are iPhones contributing to falling birth rates, group texting thread etiquette, ways to boost your mood - and more. Join us on Patreon f

Jul 8
57 min

RSVP Culture Changing, “Chalance” Dating Trend, 96-Year-Old Ghost of Happy Hour Future

Sarah and Mary share their thoughts on the casual nature of current RSVP culture, the exhaustion of dating trends, a 96–Year-Old party animal - and more. Join us on Patr

Jul 1
43 min

MAFS Season 20 Update, Travis and Taylor Wedding Speculation, World Cup Ranch Dressing Craze

Sarah and Mary share their thoughts on the upcoming season of Married at First Sight, Travis and Taylor wedding rumors, World Cup food obsession, garbage woes - and more.

Jun 24
1 h 07 min

“Squatters” on A&E, Rope Jumping Tragedy, Tyra Bank’s Sues Netflix

Sarah and Mary share their thoughts on the A&E series Squatters, the horrific bridge jumping tragedy in Brazil, Tyra’s decision to take legal action, a body cam whoopsie

Jun 17
1 h 03 min

Don’t Hate on Man Cereal, Don’t Bang Your Cousin, Don’t Microwave Fish

Sarah and Mary talk Man Cereal, the risks of a $900 video recording litter box, cash to confetti, microwave crime - and more. Join us on Patreon for more of the inner sa

Jun 10
1 h 03 min

Sarah and the Case of the Mysterious Beep, Coaster Nuggets, Celebratory Splits

Sarah shares her mysterious beep saga, guy gets banned for life from Six Flags for eating chicken nuggets on a rollercoaster, viral graduation split - and more. Join us

Jun 3
1 h 02 min

Hilarious Sarah Colonna Travel Rant, Caviar Pizza, Mackenzie Shirilla Requests Kim Kardashian’s Representation

Sarah and Mary talk Jet Suite X travel rage, $55 pizza slices, Mackenzie Shirilla’s a bad egg - and more. Join us on Patreon Join us on Patreon for more of the inner san

May 27
1 h 03 min

Netflix Documentary The Crash, Pizza Hut Nostalgia, Salad Bar Confessions

Sarah and Mary share their thoughts on the Netflix documentary The Crash, Pizza Hut’s making an 80’s comeback, Thousand Island dressing bonds the girls - and more. Join

May 20
59 min

Kevin Hart Roast, Worst Ex Ever - 90 Day Fiancé Guy, McMenu Heartbreak

Sarah and Mary share their thoughts on The Roast of Kevin Hart on Netflix, the Worst Ex Ever ep w/ the guy from 90 Day Fiancé,  dollar menu drama - and more. Join us on

May 13
1 h 00 min

Should I Marry a Murderer? Probably Not.

Sarah and Mary share their thoughts on the crazy Netflix documentary Should I Marry a Murderer, Chanel’s half shoe - and more. Join us on Patreon for more of the inner s

May 6
58 min

Wink Wink

A not-so-Randy-Travis concert, dead husband holograms his own funeral Q and A, British Airways to allow in-flight phone calls (NO THANK YOU), Buddhist Monks caught with K

Apr 29
1 h 08 min

Chart positions

Where Are You My Podcast? ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Sep 10, 2026).

#13 ▲ 26 After Shows US
#84 ▲ 109 TV & Film US

What listeners say

A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.

Discovered this years ago while looking for a MAFS podcast and fell in love with the genuine and endearing friendship between the hosts and their smart and hilarious takes. Love them!

arcApple · Aug 2026

This has become my favorite podcast…and I listen to a lot. Sarah and Mary are so funny and relatable. I love their MAFS recaps but also love their other ones just as much.

Lsqueo · Aug 2026

When I listen, I feel like I’m catching up with a couple of girlfriends. Been a Sarah fan for a long time and her and Mary together are so fun!

lila 63936293 · Jul 2026

Love this podcast! Sarah and Mary are hysterical. I laugh out loud and look forward to every episode. I watch shows I probably would not otherwise just so that I can listen to the recap. The overtime episodes are THE BEST!

Terri459 · May 2026

I was excited to find this and hear discussion about the most recent season of Married at First Sight. Most of the episodes are just a big long plug for their pay to listen program and shows. They talk way too long about things that don’t matter and their own experience but if you want to hear more you can become a paying member.. don’t waste your time

Han!$796?&7 · Dec 2025

We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.

More podcasts like Are You My Podcast?

Popular shows in After Shows, for your next listen.

Browse charts by category

Daily updated Apple Podcasts rankings for the United States.

About Are You My Podcast? on Reason.fm

Here you find the Apple Podcasts chart positions of Are You My Podcast?, its latest episodes to listen to directly, and reviews from listeners. Rankings are updated daily for the United States.

Contact

Questions or issues? Reach us at hello@reason.fm

0:000:00