True Crime · Terrible Story Productions

Not Just A Terrible Story

by Terrible Story Productions

When Stacie Love married her former high school teacher, she thought it was a whirlwind romance. Two decades later, she discovered the truth behind the day their lives unraveled: a federal search, an unseen investigation, and a story far darker than she ever knew. Not Just A Terrible Story is a six-part investigation into one woman’s search for the truth, the scourge of alleged educator sexual misconduct, and a culture of complicity that protected predators for decades.

Latest episodes

Showing 3 · updated from the feed

The Wedding | Episode 2

Stacie and Brett's relationship wasn't a secret—their community watched it unfold. Some saw it as a fairy tale. Others felt a quiet unease. In this episode you hear what

Sep 15
43 min

The Cool Teacher | Episode 1

Fifteen year-old Stacie Love was just a sophomore when she met the young, charismatic English teacher, Brett Fischer. He was the "cool" teacher, and she wanted to be his

Sep 15
33 min

This is Not Just a Terrible Story

In 2005, Stacie Love's life was turned upside down by a knock on the door. Twenty years later, she discovers the truth about her marriage to her former teacher and a cult

Sep 4
2 min

Chart positions

Where Not Just A Terrible Story ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Sep 17, 2026).

#113 ▲ 59 True Crime US

What listeners say

A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.

I am so moved by this podcast thus far and by Stacie’s courage. The producers handled this with so much care, thoughtfulness and humanity. Really powerful, intentional and compelling storytelling. I can’t recommend it enough!

hi10001919191 · Sep 2026

We all heard the rumors in high school. Witnessed it or maybe it was you. Excellent narration and storytelling. I can’t wait to hear the rest of the story.

P1ckle Queen · Sep 2026

We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.