What Happened When

Latest episodes

Showing 20 · updated from the feed

Episode 505: Juice Robinson

On this episode of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson welcome AEW superstar Juice Robinson! The guys watch a couple of Juice's most action-packed matc

Sep 23
1 h 18 min

Episode 504: Jamie Dundee

On this special episode of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson welcome Jamie Dundee to celebrate the incredible life and legacy of his legendary father

Sep 16
1 h 15 min

Episode 503: Austin and Colten Gunn

On this special episode of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson remember Andy "The Butcher" Williams and reflect on the lasting impact he made on the AE

Sep 9
1 h 25 min

Episode 502: Tempers Rising

On this episode of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson fire up the time machine and revisit the August 30, 1986, edition of World Championship Wrestlin

Sep 2
1 h 50 min

Episode 501: Baby Doll Betrays Dusty!

On this episode of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson fire up the time machine and head back 40 years to the golden year of 1986 for a classic edition

Aug 26
1 h 27 min

Episode 500: Rocky Romero

It's a milestone celebration 500 episodes in the making! On this special edition of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson celebrate their 500th episode w

Aug 19
1 h 17 min

Episode 499: 30th anniversary of WCW Hog Wild

It's a wild one on What Happened When! Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson cover it all, starting with Tony's incredible trip to Mexico for AEW Grand Slam, as he shares st

Aug 12
1 h 17 min

Episode 498: Dusty Is Champ!

On this edition of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson travel back 40 years to the final TBS television show before the legendary Great American Bash 1

Aug 5
1 h 52 min

Episode 497: Dr. Luther

Tony Schiavone has seen a lot in professional wrestling, but even he may not be prepared for this trip down memory lane! On this wild edition of What Happened When, Tony

Jul 29
1 h 24 min

Episode 496: RJ City Returns!

This week, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson welcome AEW superstar, actor, writer, and independent wrestling sensation RJ City for a hilarious and insightful trip throug

Jul 22
1 h 41 min

Episode 495: Alex Marvez

Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson welcome one of the original voices and true pillars of All Elite Wrestling, Alex Marvez, to What Happened When for a fascinating look b

Jul 15
1 h 23 min

Episode 494: "Smart" Mark Sterling

Tony Schiavone is welcoming one of the most entertaining personalities in professional wrestling to the show! This week on What Happened When, Conrad Thompson and Tony si

Jul 8
1 h 16 min

Episode 493: Roderick Strong

On this episode of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson welcome one of the most accomplished in-ring performers of his generation, Roderick Strong, for

Jul 1
1 h 23 min

Episode 492: Tony's Forbidden Door Preview

On this episode of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson get you ready for one of the biggest events of the summer as they preview AEW's upcoming Forbidd

Jun 24
1 h 18 min

Episode 491: Bobby Cruise

On this episode of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson welcome one of the most recognizable voices in professional wrestling, Ring of Honor's legendary

Jun 17
1 h 20 min

Episode 490: "The Natural" Dustin Rhodes

On this episode of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson welcome a very special guest, wrestling legend Dustin Rhodes! The Natural joins the show for an

Jun 10
1 h 10 min

Episode 489: Magnum TA Lost His Mind!

On this episode, Tony Schiavone takes us back to one of the most explosive periods in Jim Crockett Promotions history! After being reprimanded by NWA President Bob Geigle

Jun 3
1 h 39 min

Episode 488: Magnum TA & Nikita Koloff Face Off!

On this edition of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson fire up the time machine and take you back 40 years to one of the most explosive stretches in Ji

May 27
1 h 34 min

Episode 487: "The Dapper Yapper" Justin Roberts

On this laugh filled and story packed edition, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson sit down with one of AEW's most recognizable voices, Justin Roberts. Known as the "yappe

May 20
1 h 54 min

Episode 486: RD Evans

On this episode of What Happened When, Tony welcomes his close personal friend and AEW writer/producer RD Evans! RD shares stories of his love for WCW and Goldberg. He al

May 13
1 h 35 min

Chart trend

Position in the Wrestling chart (US), last 90 days.

#1#17#33JulAugSep

all-time peak

days in the top 10 since Nov 2024

Chart positions

Where What Happened When ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Sep 29, 2026).

#28 ▼ 5 Wrestling US

What listeners say

A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.

WHW is the wrestling equivalent of listening to your uncles tell stories, during the holidays, after they’ve had a few. Very informative, but just nonstop laughs.

TheRealMatsuda · Oct 2025

Any true old school wrestling fan will enjoy this podcast, for both the nostalgia and for Tony’s old school take on today’s product. Dude has grown and evolved with the business, which means there’s hope for all of us lapsed fans as well. Maybe it’s not for everyone, but it’s been a favorite for me since day one. If you say it’s never made you laugh, “you a lie”. Keep up the great work guys!

Mr.IKnowWhatIAmTalkibgAbout · Aug 2024

Finally a podcast that doesn’t take itself too seriously. A lot of fun and a lot of memories of wrestling years gone by.

Mikell7676 · Feb 2023

I have listened to What Happened When since the podcast began, and it is my favorite wrestling podcast to listen to. Listening to Conrad and Tony is one of the best parts of my week. This podcast brings me a lot of joy, and I encourage any wrestling fan to give it a try. They will have you in tears from laughing, and you won't want to miss an episode.

Brian A. Smith · Dec 2022

We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.