News Commentary · National Constitution Center
by National Constitution Center
A weekly show from the National Constitution Center hosted by Julie Silverbrook and Tom Donnelly where listeners can hear the best arguments on all sides of the constitutional issues at the center of American life.
Showing 20 · updated from the feed
Position in the News Commentary chart (US), last 90 days.
Where We the People ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Sep 20, 2026).
A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.
I think Jeffrey Rosen does a truly incredible job moderating thoughtful, and even friendly debates between people who disagree often profoundly. The conversations are subtle, sensitive, deeply informative. I teach moral and political philosophy at a small liberal arts college, and so I often think about how to make conversations just like these possible. Each episode is a wonderful model. In fact, right now I’m teaching a class on the philosophy of law and I am now even thinking of assigning some of these episodes to my students. Thank you, Jeffrey Rosen! I genuinely believe you’re doing a service to our country and its citizens. PS: a couple of reviews have claimed to discover a left-wing slant. I consider myself to be a conservative (in something like the Burke to Oakeshott tradition) and I am often frustrated by ideological bias and dogmatism in public discourse—but I have to say I found the claim that this podcast has any such bias utterly, utterly baffling. Every episode I’ve heard represents views on diametrically opposed sides of a legal or political divide, and both sides are represented by a brilliant, careful, well-informed thinker. This is exactly what makes it such an amazing podcast. So don’t listen to the haters! Instead listen to this amazing podcast.
Legal scholars engage in friendly debate representing opposing views. Immensely refreshing to hear well educated guests calmly and clearly present where they agree and disagree on high profile legal matters of the day. There is the occasional outlier, but it’s obvious that Jeff selects guests who are interested in informing the listener instead of the vitriolic combativeness we’re used to hearing from members of congress.
The current episode fails to challenge one of the guest’s assertion that Wicca is nothing but a “pseudo religion” despite it being practiced in its modern form for the better part of a century in America, and many of its adherents believing it’s much older; despite even the nation’s military and department of veterans affairs formally recognizing it as a bona ride religion; and despite the likely fact that he knows precious little about the philosophy and practices of Wicca. Furthermore, that same guest expounds on the virtues of Mormonism, a.k.a. The LDS Church — which itself was considered and maligned as a pseudo religion or harmful cult during its first decades and sometimes still is considered so by others. What a sad and disappointing irony that the same self-described atheist gay ethnically-Jewish man championing the virtues of LDS “peacemaking” and accommodation of other groups including members of minority groups (as opposed to his “sharp Christianity”) himself maligns and dismisses, out of hand, the minority religion that is Wicca and its believers. I say all this as a non-Wiccan monotheist.
Thoughtful, respectful discussion among distinguished scholars. I’m a lawyer, but you certainly don’t need to be one to enjoy this podcast. Please rethink inviting Sarah Isgur on the panel in the future. I value her intellect, and appreciate her viewpoints. However, her manner on the February 27, 2025 podcast was unkind, and frankly appeared to put the other panelists in an awkward position. She poked fun and laughed at an author who was not present to defend themselves. I would love to hear panelists with her views, but without the inclination for this type of behavior.
We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.
Popular shows in News Commentary, for your next listen.
Daily updated Apple Podcasts rankings for the United States.
Here you find the Apple Podcasts chart positions of We the People, its latest episodes to listen to directly, and reviews from listeners. Rankings are updated daily for the United States.
Questions or issues? Reach us at hello@reason.fm