Sincerely Supernatural Podcast

Travis Walton | The UFO Abduction You Can't Dismiss

In 1975, Travis Walton disappeared in the Arizona wilderness after his coworkers said they witnessed him being struck by a beam of light from a strange object.He wouldn't

The Night My Wife Saw The Hat Man

My wife had just gone to bed when she saw something in her bedroom that she still can't explain.A dark figure known as the Hat Man appeared in the room as she was trying

Something Was Stomping Up the Basement Stairs

In this episode we're reading stories submitted by our listeners and viewers—and one of them involves a haunting that kept getting harder to explain.A man began having st

He Looked Into Its Eyes… Then He Couldn't Move | Las Vegas Alien Encounter

There is a 911 call, police body-camera footage, security footage, videos from the area, reports of a fireball in the sky, and a strange circular mark reportedly found in

The Giant of Kandahar: Did U.S. Soldiers Really Kill a 12-Foot Giant?

The Giant of Kandahar is one of the strangest stories to emerge from the war in Afghanistan. According to the account, a U.S. military unit encountered a massive red-hair

Real People, Terrifying Encounters: Mimics, Ghosts & Shadow Figures

What if the person you see isn't really the person you think it is?In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we read some of the creepiest viewer-submitted paranormal st

Roswell Part 2: Did the Crash Change Our World Forever?

Roswell didn't end with the crash.In Part 2, we examine the eyewitnesses whose stories never changed—including Glenn Dennis, Jesse Marcel Jr., Frankie Rowe, Sheriff Georg

What Really Happened at Roswell? | The Complete Timeline (Part 1)

On July 8, 1947, the U.S. Army announced it had recovered a "flying disc" near Roswell, New Mexico. Just hours later, the story changed.In this episode, we reconstruct th

"That's Not Human!" | The Moore's Creek Battlefield Encounter

A late-night drive past Moore's Creek Battlefield takes a terrifying turn when a man spots what appears to be a bloody soldier standing beside the road. Moments later, so

We Read Your Creepiest Paranormal Stories

In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we read true stories sent in by listeners from across the country. From ghostly apparitions and shadow people to unexplained cr

New Jersey Mantis Man | Chilling Eyewitness Encounters

Two fishermen. One river. Two terrifying encounters.In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we investigate two eyewitness reports from New Jersey's Musconetcong River

The Hopkinsville Goblins | The Night They Surrounded the House!

In 1955, two families in rural Kentucky claimed their farmhouse was surrounded by strange, glowing creatures unlike anything they had ever seen. What began as a reported

The Barney & Betty Hill UFO Abduction | Real Hypnosis Audio

In 1961, Betty and Barney Hill reported what would become the most famous alien abduction case in history. Years later, under hypnosis, Barney recalled terrifying details

Backcountry Mystery: Tree Knocks & Whistles in Wyoming's Wind River Range

In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, I interview my brother Richard about a series of strange experiences while hunting deep in Wyoming's remote Wind River Mountain

My Wife's Terrifying Bigfoot Encounter in the Montana Woods

In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, my wife shares her firsthand encounter with a towering Sasquatch deep in the Montana wilderness. From strange noises in the for

My Daughter’s Most Terrifying Paranormal Encounters (Phone Call from Inside the House)

In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, Morgan shares multiple real-life paranormal experiences from her childhood, teenage years, and adulthood—including unexplained

The Mysterious Montana UFO Cases Nobody Talks About

Did the first real UFO footage come from Montana?In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we dive into the shocking Mariana UFO footage captured over Great Falls in 195

Black Eyed Kids: Real or Internet Hoax?

The Black Eyed Kids are one of the internet’s most disturbing urban legends…but are they real?In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we dive into the original 1996 Bl

The Rendlesham Forest Incident (Real Military Audio)

In 1980, military personnel stationed near Rendlesham Forest encountered strange lights moving through the woods — and recorded the event on tape.In this episode of Since

Can Bigfoot Speak? The Sierra Recordings.

Hunters deep in the Sierra Nevada Mountains recorded strange, unexplained sounds in the wilderness. What they captured has left many wondering… could this be Bigfoot?List