Sincerely Supernatural Podcast

Three Strange Stories and the History of Halloween | Season Finale

SLNT Faraday BagsWe're closing out the season with a special Halloween episode of Sincerely Supernatural!This Halloween, we're exploring three bizarre, disturbing, and un

Reptilian Aliens, Telekinesis & UFOs | My Brother's Unbelievable Experiences

What would you do if you encountered something that wasn't human? And what if strange things kept happening throughout your life? On this episode of Sincerely Supernatur

The Dogman Mystery | Encounters and Ancient Connections

What if the Dogman is more than a modern cryptid? What if the terrifying creature described by witnesses throughout history has a connection to something far more ancient

Montana Cattle Mutilations: UFOs, Bigfoot & Fallen Angels?

In the 1970s, reports of mysterious cattle mutilations in eastern Montana raised disturbing questions. But what if the cattle weren't the only unexplained phenomenon in t

Noah’s Ark May Have Been Found in Turkey… Again

What if the remains of Noah’s Ark really are sitting in the mountains of Turkey?A recent re-discovery has once again brought the controversial Durupınar formation into th

Something Whispered His Name From the Closet | True Listener Stories

In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we're reading more true paranormal stories submitted by our listeners and viewers— and these encounters get seriously unsettlin

Travis Walton | The UFO Abduction You Can't Dismiss

In 1975, Travis Walton disappeared in the Arizona wilderness after his coworkers said they witnessed him being struck by a beam of light from a strange object.He wouldn't

The Night My Wife Saw The Hat Man

My wife had just gone to bed when she saw something in her bedroom that she still can't explain.A dark figure known as the Hat Man appeared in the room as she was trying

Something Was Stomping Up the Basement Stairs

In this episode we're reading stories submitted by our listeners and viewers—and one of them involves a haunting that kept getting harder to explain.A man began having st

He Looked Into Its Eyes… Then He Couldn't Move | Las Vegas Alien Encounter

There is a 911 call, police body-camera footage, security footage, videos from the area, reports of a fireball in the sky, and a strange circular mark reportedly found in

The Giant of Kandahar: Did U.S. Soldiers Really Kill a 12-Foot Giant?

The Giant of Kandahar is one of the strangest stories to emerge from the war in Afghanistan. According to the account, a U.S. military unit encountered a massive red-hair

Real People, Terrifying Encounters: Mimics, Ghosts & Shadow Figures

What if the person you see isn't really the person you think it is?In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we read some of the creepiest viewer-submitted paranormal st

Roswell Part 2: Did the Crash Change Our World Forever?

Roswell didn't end with the crash.In Part 2, we examine the eyewitnesses whose stories never changed—including Glenn Dennis, Jesse Marcel Jr., Frankie Rowe, Sheriff Georg

What Really Happened at Roswell? | The Complete Timeline (Part 1)

On July 8, 1947, the U.S. Army announced it had recovered a "flying disc" near Roswell, New Mexico. Just hours later, the story changed.In this episode, we reconstruct th

"That's Not Human!" | The Moore's Creek Battlefield Encounter

A late-night drive past Moore's Creek Battlefield takes a terrifying turn when a man spots what appears to be a bloody soldier standing beside the road. Moments later, so

We Read Your Creepiest Paranormal Stories

In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we read true stories sent in by listeners from across the country. From ghostly apparitions and shadow people to unexplained cr

New Jersey Mantis Man | Chilling Eyewitness Encounters

Two fishermen. One river. Two terrifying encounters.In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we investigate two eyewitness reports from New Jersey's Musconetcong River

The Hopkinsville Goblins | The Night They Surrounded the House!

In 1955, two families in rural Kentucky claimed their farmhouse was surrounded by strange, glowing creatures unlike anything they had ever seen. What began as a reported

The Barney & Betty Hill UFO Abduction | Real Hypnosis Audio

In 1961, Betty and Barney Hill reported what would become the most famous alien abduction case in history. Years later, under hypnosis, Barney recalled terrifying details

Backcountry Mystery: Tree Knocks & Whistles in Wyoming's Wind River Range

In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, I interview my brother Richard about a series of strange experiences while hunting deep in Wyoming's remote Wind River Mountain