Show Me The Movies

The Odyssey (2026) with Isaiah Amstutz

On this SMTM episode, the crew is joined by Nic’s hometown hero Isaiah Amstutz to traverse Christopher Nolan’s monumental summer blockbuster, 'The Odyssey.' They discuss

First Reformed (2017) with Tyler May-Gruthusen

Will God forgive us? This week SMTM goes to church with Tyler May-Gruthusen to discuss 'First Reformed!' Their conversation covers Tyler's evangelical t-shirt era, Justi

The Muppet Movie (1979) with Bailey Hunt

This week on SMTM, our hosts are joined by Muppet-aficionado Bailey Hunt for a celebration of the Muppet's big screen debut, 'The Muppet Movie!' They share their favorite

Mud (2012)

On this episode of SMTM, Justin and Nic are back with a Nic-Pick classic, 'Mud!' They get into the theme of love in the film, whether or not one can solve problems by pun

Face/Off with Jake Nordman and Tyler May-Gruthusen

This week, SMTM returns with Jake Nordman and Tyler May-Gruthusen to talk about John Woo’s unhinged classic, 'Face/Off!' During their discussion, they get into the legion

SPECIAL ANNOUNCEMENT: Summer Break + Show Us Your Movies

SMTM is hitting pause for a few weeks and will return on August 3. In this brief announcement episode, Justin and Nic invite you to reach out and share the movies you'd l

Contact (1997) with Braden Ochs

This week Braden Ochs joins Justin and Nic to discuss Robert Zemeckis’s 'Contact!' Together they get into the sci-fi trilogy Braden penned as a child, the differences bet

Jojo Rabbit (2019) with Hannah Bostick

This week on SMTM, friend of the pod (and spouse of Nic) Hannah Bostick returns to school Justin and Nic on her all-time favorite movie, 'Jojo Rabbit!' Together they cove

Super Fly (1972) with Jari Johnson

This week Jari Johnson returns to SMTM to dig into the blaxploitation classic, 'Super Fly!' The trio discuss Jari sneaking into the movie as a teen, the film’s incredible

BONUS: Sonic the Hedgehog: The Movie OVA (1996)

To celebrate a year of Show Me The Movies, Justin and Nic decided to break open a memory solidified in amber and talk about 'Sonic The Hedgehog: The Movie' (not to be con

The Hunt for Red October (1990) with Matt Moseng

Set the reactor to 110%, engage the caterpillar, and join Justin, Nic, and guest Matt Moseng as they deep dive John McTiernan’s dad-movie classic, 'The Hunt for Red Octob

Road House (1989) with Amelia Bostick and Tyler May-Gruthusen

This week, Tyler and Amelia return to remind our hosts that pain don’t hurt as they dive into 'Road House'! They discuss throat-ripping, the crime of going commando in de

Lemonade Mouth (2011) with Sophie Olson

Sophie Olson is back to usher in SMTM’s inaugural DCOM, 'Lemonade Mouth!' While discussing the movie, they get into Adam Hick’s parallel universe relationship to Lucas He

There Will Be Blood (2007) with Isaac Adams and Tyler May-Gruthusen

This week on Show Me The Movies, Justin, Nic, Isaac Adams, and Tyler May-Gruthusen team up to discuss Paul Thomas Anderson's masterpiece, 'There Will Be Blood.' In breaki

Goodfellas (1990) with Aaron Crump and Tyler May-Gruthusen

This week on SMTM our hosts are joined by fellow schnooks Aaron Crump and Tyler May-Gruthusen for a chat on Scorsesee’s 1990 mob masterpiece, 'Goodfellas.' Along with dis

Forgetting Sarah Marshall (2008)

This week on Show Me The Movies, the hosts get into a Justin-classic – 'Forgetting Sarah Marshall!' Between discussions on Jason Segel’s anatomy, Justin and Nic cover ear

Hereditary (2018) with Bailey Hunt

Grab a slice of chocolate cake and tune in as Bailey Hunt returns to talk Ari Aster’s stellar and bone-chilling debut, 'Hereditary.' They discuss the hosts’ respective sl

The Dark Knight (2008) with Tyler May-Gruthusen

This week on Show Me The Movies, superhero-obsessive Tyler May-Gruthusen is back to talk an all-time favorite of his, 'The Dark Knight.' Together they discuss Heath Ledge

The Irishman (2019) with Madison and Tyler May-Gruthusen

Join Justin and Nic as they host power couple Madison and Tyler May-Gruthusen on the pod to discuss 'The Irishman!' They get into the limits of grace, what Madison has in

Fantastic Mr. Fox (2009) with Jessica Myers

This week Justin and Nic invite Jessica Myers (sibling of the show) to dig into their favorite cozy heist movie, 'Fantastic Mr. Fox!' They cover the place the film holds