Romancing the Pod - Podcast Rankings and reviews

I love this podcast so much, Paige and Todd make me laugh until I cry. Mikey did too and I’m really sad he left but I’m wishing him all the best on his journey! From the tangents to the inside jokes to the fun facts, this podcast has everything you need to turn your day around. You guys got me to laugh through some really difficult days and for that I can’t thank you enough!!

Updating my review in 2025: I’m still listening and I mostly love the podcast now; it has definitely evolved in a great way. My only quibble is that I need Todd to stop repeating what’s already been said. Not just what’s already been said; what was JUST said. Example: in the Date Night episode (April 10, 2025), he literally repeated what Paige said at least twice: once when he repeated who directed the movie after she just physically said the words of who directed the movie, and the second time (minute 55-ish) was when they described the part where the bad guys know their address and might go after their kids at their house. This second repeat was so audacious and lengthy, I had to stop listening and leave this review. His tone is happy and he’s explaining something… that was just explained or said. It wouldn’t be so bad if elsewhere throughout the episode he wasn’t saying “yeah” or “of course” in agreement to what Paige is saying, using a tone that implies that she’s saying something obvious; the irony is that HE’S been saying obvious things the whole episode. Listen, I don’t want to leave criticism, but hopefully it’s constructive; that’s the intention. I frequently skip ahead 10 seconds without missing any threads of the conversation. I took the time to leave this review in case it’s helpful feedback and it can be improved upon. Again, I love how the show has evolved and grown. Going to resume listening to the episode now; keep up the great work.

Old review: This used to be a good podcast, not my favorite, but I like hearing about movies. Todd and Mikey are in the midst of the lamest slap-fight I’ve ever had the displeasure of listening to. (I was going to call this a d*** measuring contest, but this is more juvenile.) It’s so childish. You’re making the energy weird, especially because neither of you is dunking on each other and you both look petty. (I’m talking specifically about the Oct 26, 2023 episode for Fools Rush In, but this feedback is not restricted to just that one.) End it. Talk about movies. I don’t listen to your episodes often, but every time I give one a listen, I remember how trying it is to hear you guys and how it doesn’t have to be this way.

I’ve been listening since the beginning and cannot recommend this enough. It lets me experience the movie with a fun conversation without having to watch the movie myself. Paige, Todd and when Mikey was on makes these movies come to life for me.

This podcast is hilarious and I know my Thursday’s are going to be great when it starts by listening to Paige and Todd talk about these absurd movies !! Even if you haven’t seen the movie, the episode is worth it!
If you want good Monday’s check out Horror Virgin
#ripMikey

The dynamic is off since Mikey left. Paige has a strong personality (which is fine) and Todd just agrees with everything she says . You need a third person so there can be more banter and less hype man.

I like the premise so much but the dynamic is all off since Mikey left. Paige absolutely rocks and I love her but she’s a strong personality that overpowers And Todd, he always seems to be fighting Paige for the spotlight or something. You guys need that third person to balance out the anxious attachment energy of the show.

And you’re picking terrible movies lately. There are so many bangers (classics) you still haven’t done - you don’t have to do the Netflix no-names that only UK viewers have watched. Come on now.