Video Games · Matt Martens and Hunter Donaldson
by Matt Martens and Hunter Donaldson
The definitive ranking of all every video game, every week at a time. If you work in the gaming industry, please stop making games while we catch up.
Showing 20 · updated from the feed
Position in the Video Games chart (US), last 90 days.
Where Old Gamer’s Almanac ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Nov 1, 2026).
A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.
Been listening since go (SCPT transplant), but this recent episode on Slay the Spire 2 had me rolling - Spire is and will always be bae <3 Love the energy, discovered new games and genres through you guys, and like so many, am mildly dismayed by the harsh judgement of Halo 3... Despite that, love the show, the rotation of guests works really well, and as an aging gamer myself, this look back format deserves a chef’s kiss. Hope to catch you guys on a game one day, keep up the excellent work gentlemen.
OGA is a fun tour through the annals of gaming in the past 50ish years! Hunter and Matt do a wonderful job of highlighting forgotten gems of gaming in passionate and insightful ways. They don’t take themselves or their opinions too seriously, but rather try to keep the atmosphere fun and informative! I love their guests! EJ and Sun being the most often reoccurring guests, but they’re all great, and do a great job of preventing things from becoming stale. Matt and Hunter also come up with fun topics and varied episode formats that accomplish the same goal. They always seem to be asking themselves “How can we highlight important games in a fun, interesting, and new way for the listener?” They’ve introduced me to so many amazing games I’d never played before (*cough* Celeste 🐐 *cough*) and I’m so grateful for that. It’s really fun to play along! Another nice thing is that you can start pretty much anywhere in the podcast’s backlog of episodes. I recommend finding an episode about one of your favorite games and hitting “Play”! Don’t worry, even when they don’t like a game, they’re still respectful of the work that went into it and the kids whose childhood the game may have been a part of. Thanks so much guys! Keep up the good work!
Matt and Hunter give insightful and hilarious commentary that makes me think about these video games in ways I didn’t before. 10/10 will listen each week
So far, this is the only video game podcast I've ranked in my comprehensive ranking system of all video game podcasts, but I'm pretty confident that it's at the number 1 spot out of my current sample size. Out of the first 15 episodes, I have bought 2 games because of this show, and one of them wasn't even covered yet. (Celeste and Hades, for reference.)
I wish I could recommend this show. I like these guys, I’ve listened to one of their other podcasts SCPT for a long time, but you really get the sense that they actively dislike the format of their own show. They have either abandoned or openly disdain of their own self-imposed gimmicks, such as keeping a ranked list of the games they cover, or sticking to releases from a specific time period. Playing the games in advance of making an episode is treated as a chore, particularly for Matt. I think this has now reached a crescendo in the most recent episode on Mortal Kombat 2, wherein the guys stated that they didn’t like the game and thus didn’t even play it. Ok, then maybe don’t cover it? The final nail in the coffin for me is the language. I get that it is a show targeted towards adults, but any podcast that I can’t have on in my car when my kids are around is likely to drop from my following list. It’s a shame, because I have found my kids really like some of the old games from my childhood, and they would probably get interested in playing some of these classic games after hearing about them from people who played them when they were new. Best of luck to them in their other shows, but I’m unfollowing this one.
We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.
Popular shows in Video Games, for your next listen.
Daily updated Apple Podcasts rankings for the United States.
Here you find the Apple Podcasts chart positions of Old Gamer’s Almanac, its latest episodes to listen to directly, and reviews from listeners. Rankings are updated daily for the United States.
Questions or issues? Reach us at hello@reason.fm