LOVE MURDER artwork

True Crime · Jessie Pray and Andie Cassette

LOVE MURDER

by Jessie Pray and Andie Cassette

Jessie Pray and Andie Cassette team up each week to tell stories of love and relationships gone fatally wrong. This show is all about seemingly normal people driven to terrible madness by passion and rage. Hang out with your new best friends each week to discover how someone can go from sweet to murderous in the blink of an eye, and to hear all the ways murder can give love a real bad name.

Latest episodes

Showing 20 · updated from the feed

Hockey & Home Invasions: Tom Clayton & Kelley Stage Clayton

Kelley Clayton seemed to have built the perfect life: a beautiful home, two beloved young children, and a marriage to a handsome former professional athlete — but when th

Sep 30
1 h 15 min

The Pooperintendent, the Cornell Pumpkin, and $1.5 Million in Chicken Wings [Bonus Episode 103]

School is back in session, so Jessie counts down six of the most ridiculous pranks and petty crimes ever committed at a school. There's a pumpkin nobody can explain on to

Sep 29
38 min

A Body in the Crawlspace and a 24-Year-Old Cold Case [Current Affairs]

Human remains found in the crawlspace of a Big Bear Lake home in 2020 are identified as Jill Maiorca, who went missing in 2007, and her former husband is charged with fir

Sep 29
5 min

Kissing & Killing Cousins: Susie Newsome Lynch, Fritz Klenner, and the Bitter Blood Murders

When investigators link two very different sets of multiple murders, they uncover one disturbing connection. This connection reveals a bitter family feud, a vicious custo

Sep 23
2 h 06 min

Husband Charged 19 Years After Wife’s Murder at His Amusement Park [Current Affairs]

In 2006, mother of three Doris Worrell was shot and killed at the Georgia amusement park owned by her husband, Jon Worrell. Nearly two decades later, after years abroad a

Sep 22
6 min

Influence to Kill: Jack Avery & Gabbie Gonzalez

They were young, beautiful, famous and raising a child together — a boy band heartthrob and influencer whose relationship played out in front of millions of fans. But aft

Sep 16
1 h 09 min

Six Weeks a Mother: The Murder of Brandi Hornsby [Current Affairs]

Brandi Hornsby was 24 and six weeks into being a mother when she was killed in her Stockton, California home in the fall of 2021. When her mother came looking for her thr

Sep 15
5 min

Murder on Big Moose Lake: Grace Brown & Chester Gillette

In July of 1906, two young lovers checked into an Adirondack hotel before setting out alone on Big Moose Lake in a rented rowboat. Only one of them would return, and the

Sep 9
1 h 35 min

The Devil at Angel’s Landing: Bernadette and David Vander Meer

A 10th wedding anniversary hike ends in tragedy when one member of the couple falls 1,200 feet to their death. It’s quickly ruled an accident, but nearly 20 years later,

Sep 2
1 h 21 min

The Three-Hour 911 Delay in the Death of Destiny Dunn [Current Affairs]

When 37-year-old mother Destiny Dunn was found dead in a Missouri motel room, her partner Nicholas Ayres was charged with her murder. Investigators say his own videos and

Aug 31
5 min

Reprehensible: Susan and Jimmy Grund

The Grunds of Peru, Indiana were a couple people just couldn’t help but notice. Susan was a glamorous younger wife, Jim a high-powered atty. Together they made a dashing

Aug 26
1 h 44 min

Introducing “Kouri Richins: The Children’s Author Who Killed Her Husband” from RedHanded

Today, we are sharing part one of a two-part series from the award-winning true crime podcast RedHanded, hosted by Suruthi Bala and Hannah Maguire. RedHanded is the UK's

Aug 25
1 h 13 min

Obsessed: The Toxic Love of Barbara Piotrowsky & Richard “Dick” Minns

When a 27-year-old beauty queen and Houston-area nurse is shot multiple times in a donut shop parking lot, the authorities have to follow a twisted path to finally catch

Aug 19
1 h 39 min

Courtney Clenney Sentenced as D4vd Is Ordered to Stand Trial [Current Affairs]

Jessie and Andie bring major updates in two cases previously covered by Love Murder: Courtney Clenney accepts a plea deal in the fatal stabbing of Christian Obumseli, whi

Aug 17
7 min

The Widower and the Au Pair: Jason Corbett and Molly Martens

In the summer of 2006, a young mother in Limerick, Ireland suffered an asthma attack at home. She didn't survive. Her husband was left alone with two babies, a dog, and a

Aug 12
1 h 36 min

Senseless: The Murder of Janice Zengotita-Torres

When a devoted mother & wife vanishes on the ten-minute drive between her work at a discount clothing store and home, police look at the most likely suspects—but after so

Aug 5
1 h 03 min

Sara Gilson Killed Days After Viral TikTok About Estranged Husband [Current Affairs]

Oklahoma influencer and mother of two Sara Gilson was trying to escape an allegedly abusive marriage when she learned her estranged husband, youth basketball coach Jeremi

Aug 3
5 min

Force of Nature: The Hurricane Harvey Murder of Crystal McDowell

A loving mother with a tragic past disappears during Hurricane Harvey, leading investigators to suspect the three men closest to her. Sources: 1. 48 Hours. 1988. 2. Da

Jul 29
1 h 15 min

The Houston Murder Suspect Fighting Extradition From Italy [Current Affairs]

Lee Gilley was awaiting trial for the capital murder of his pregnant wife, Christa Bauer Gilley, when prosecutors say he cut off his ankle monitor, fled the country using

Jul 28
6 min

The Fatal Attraction Murder: Carolyn Warmus, Paul Solomon, Betty Jeanne Solomon

A stagnant long-term marriage comes to a shocking end when one member of the couple is murdered in their own home. But was the killer the spouse, the wife’s lover, or any

Jul 22
1 h 56 min

Chart trend

Position in the True Crime chart (US), last 90 days.

#71
all-time peak
78
days in the top 100 since Nov 2024

Chart positions

Where LOVE MURDER ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Oct 5, 2026).

#155 ▼ 7 True Crime US

What listeners say

A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.

Love this podcast! Feel like I’m listening to my best friends!! Great story telling and details along with relatable laughs!!

LD5640 · Sep 2026

I’m a fan of true crime podcasts with deep bookish (i.e. not just TV derivative) research, a lot of heart, not too much superfluous banter, and great, natural host chemistry. Jessie and Andie check all of those boxes. Also - re: the most recent ep about the Bitter Blood murders — that was the first and LAST true crime BOOK I ever read. Somehow, I love the detail when I’m watching or listening (as in the Love Murder version) but have a hard time with it on the page … I still remember reading about how those boys were treated, neglected, medicated, etc. by Fritz and their mom. Ugh. You did justice to a horrific story. Thanks for doing all that true crime reading / digesting / storytelling for my benefit while I stick to reading about fictional murders ;) Pod on Jessie and Andie!

Wordworker6 · Sep 2026

I love listening to Jessie and Andie. They’re great storytellers with a sense of humor, but they’re still respectful of the victims. Highly recommend!

Liz_AM · Aug 2026

I have been waiting for these two to make their way to Apple Podcasts since 2022 — not that it stopped me from finding a way to listen every single week… or going back to binge all the episodes I somehow missed. At this point, listening to Andie and Jessie feels like my weekly “spill the tea” session with two friends who just happen to know an alarming amount about murder. 😂 I’ve recommended Love Murder to SO many friends, and every single one gets hooked. The best way I can describe it: Investigation Discovery meets true-crime book meets Netflix documentary… with a little girls’ night thrown in. Even when they cover a case I already know, I still listen because their deep dives into the people, relationships, backstories, and all the “WAIT…WHAT?!” details make it feel completely different. Love Murder is literally the podcast that got me into podcasts — and after all these years, it’s still the one I look forward to every week. So yes, I’m VERY happy you’re finally on Apple Podcasts. It’s about time, ladies. 🩷

LoveYouMuchlyEllie · Aug 2026

We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.

More podcasts like LOVE MURDER

Popular shows in True Crime, for your next listen.

Browse charts by category

Daily updated Apple Podcasts rankings for the United States.

About LOVE MURDER on Reason.fm

Here you find the Apple Podcasts chart positions of LOVE MURDER, its latest episodes to listen to directly, and reviews from listeners. Rankings are updated daily for the United States.

Contact

Questions or issues? Reach us at hello@reason.fm

0:000:00