Our curated selection of reviews
Andie is an amazing story teller and strikes the perfect balance of analysis and empathy for victims and families. However, my absolute favorite thing about the podcast is Jessie’s commentary. I’ve never loved the podcasts with commentary but Jessie is just so clever, amazing sense of humor and she’s so good at weaving in words of wisdom while making us laugh! I love Andie and Jessie’s friendship too - this is one of the only podcasts I listen to because I love the hosts (the stories are interesting too).
Read more
I'm thoroughly enjoying this podcast. I love Andie and Jessie's chemistry and I really like how they share these stories. I'm also impressed at how many of these true crimes I haven't heard before. And I'm a true crime junkie, so that is saying something. Thanks, ladies!
Read more
Found this podcast only a few weeks ago, I absolutely love the pod cast. You two girls make such a great team sharing great crime stories. You keep it so entertaining while covering some serious topics and so professional sharing your information- I’ve been binge watching everyday- and this has become my new favorite ❤️ keep the stories coming, we are loving them!
Read more
Such great story tellers. I also love how they don’t just focus on the murder but also shine light to the victims. The latest Thanksgiving episode had me crying. Thank you for getting me through the moments in my life. Can’t wait to binge listen to the Patreon episodes!
Read more
We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts