Into The Dark - Podcast Rankings and reviews

No exaggeration, sometimes knowing I have an 'Into the Dark' episode to listen to gets me out of bed on Wednesday's. I love the diversity of the content, the vibe of the show, and Peyton's storytelling! One of my top 5 favorite podcasts (along with MWMH, of course) of all time!! :)

I bounce back and forth between this podcast and MWMH! Peyton does an AMAZING and educational job of telling true crime stories. She is always factual, does her research, and has so much empathy for the victims and their families. She may be just telling the story, but she brings awareness to us. I literally love her and daisy ofc! My favorite crime podcast 🤍

I love how Payton always goes into depth with the story of the victim of each case. These topics can be so hard to talk about but she always shows the upmost respect for the victim and their close relationships. I love listening while I clean, drive, or workout. Great podcast!

I started listening to this podcast after finding a specific episode. I love the way she is open about her struggles with mental health and how doing the podcast helps with that. I have my own struggles as well, and listening to podcasts is how I get through it. I’m a forever a listener!

I absolutely love MWMH, been listening since 2020, I’m a paying subscriber but into the dark just isn’t my cup of tea, I loved binged and when the podcast switched I thought it would be the same but it’s not. Payton is great however I’ll just stick to MWMH.