From murder, to crooked cops to tax evasion and scams, the world of true crime TV is full of stuff that makes us scream “I Think Not!” If you liked the smash hit comedy podcast "Obsessed with Disappeared," you’ll love this new show from co-hosts and best friends Ellyn Marsh & Joey Taranto. Join Ellyn, Joey – and all the characters that live inside their gorgeous heads – for true stories and the campy television that covers them. Get ready to laugh, cry and think about true crime in a whole new way.
Latest episodes
Showing 20 · updated from the feed
True Crime Rundown: Lindsay Clancy Update & The Alexander Brothers
#21 trending · True Crime
This week on the True Crime Rundown, Ellyn goes over updates in the Lindsay Clancy case while Joey brings us the news of the Alexander brothers, three brothers convicted
Nov 2 30 min
Season 6, Episode 12 (Unsolved Mysteries)
The deaths of two American soldiers and friends are ruled suicides, but their family and friends suspect foul play. Corrupt police officers terrorize Miami in the 1980s,
Oct 28 1 h 05 min
True Crime Rundown: Megyn Kelly
This week on the True Crime Rundown, we do a deep dive on Megyn Kelly and her transformation from a journalist to... what she's doing now.
Hosted by Simplecast, an Ads
This week on True Crime Rundown, we dive into Collin Gosselin's new book which is a very candid look at the abuse he alleges he suffered from his mom, Kate. Then, we disc
Oct 26 32 min
Season 6, Episode 11 (Unsolved Mysteries)
A San Francisco detective opens up a cold case to a group of Murder 101 students for help. Dian Harlin was a 43-year-old resident of Morro Bay, California, affectionately
Oct 21 1 h 05 min
True Crime Rundown: JP Miller & Russell Brand
This week on the True Crime Rundown Joey gives us an update on the trial of JP Miller and Ellyn discusses the Russell Brand trial.
Next week we'll be covering Collin Go
Oct 19 27 min
Season 6, Episode 10 (Unsolved Mysteries)
A deputy chief police officer is the prime suspect in the point-blank murder of a political fundraiser. Larry Costin was found shot four times in his trailer, and his sec
Oct 14 50 min
True Crime Rundown: Russell Brand
This week on a special part 2 of the True Crime Rundown, Ellyn and Joey deep dive into Russell Brand, his career and the allegations against him as his trial begins.
H
Oct 13 20 min
True Crime Rundown: Christa Pike
This week on the True Crime Rundown, Ellyn and Joey do a deep dive on the second failed execution attempt on Christa Pike, her hospital stay and what this means for her a
Oct 12 21 min
Season 6, Episode 9 (Unsolved Mysteries)
A controversial new theory may identify the real-life subject of the Mona Lisa. The case of Raymond Young, who disappeared after being charged with 17 counts of tax evasi
Oct 7 1 h 06 min
True Crime Rundown: Cornell
This week on a special part 2 of the True Crime Rundown, we deep dive on Cornell.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about o
This week on the True Crime Rundown, we cover Ken Urker's recent shocking death, the failed execution of Christa Pike and end with an update on Lindsay Clancy.
Hosted
Oct 5 35 min
Season 6, Episode 8 (Unsolved Mysteries)
A deadly house fire kills twin sisters in California, and their half brother is suspected of arson. A German man needs help finding his Canadian birth father. A bank exec
This week on the True Crime Rundown, Joey covers all of the current updates in the Nolan Wells case and Ellyn discusses the Caleb Flynn trial.
Hosted by Simplecast, an
Sep 28 42 min
Season 6, Episode 7 (Unsolved Mysteries)
A truck driver reports seeing a missing Memphis businessman, giving his family hope that he's alive. A Colorado couple hires a contractor to build their log cabin and fal
This week on the True Crime Rundown Joey is solo as he covers two cases this week. First up is Yvonne Missy Woods who was sentenced to 10 years in prison for manipulating
Sep 21 35 min
Season 6, Episode 6 (Unsolved Mysteries)
A family in Lake Wales, FL, experiences mysterious events that make them believe their house is haunted. A Massachusetts town is shocked by the brutal murder of a beloved
Sep 16 50 min
True Crime Rundown: Lindsay Clancy & Story Updates
This week Ellyn wraps up the trial of Lindsay Clancy, but also does a rundown of updates for many stories we've covered in recent months. She discusses Casper O'Brien, Br
Sep 14 30 min
Season 6, Episode 5 (Unsolved Mysteries)
A devout Hasidic Jew and father of 12 conducts international banking scams netting hundreds of millions of dollars. A woman looks for the teacher who changed her life in
Sep 9 56 min
True Crime Rundown: Tupac, Lindsay Clancy & Keshia Golden
This week on the True Crime Rundown we continue our coverage on the trials of Lindsay Clancy as well as of the murder of Tupac. We also discuss Keshia Golden who plead gu
Sep 7 38 min
Chart trend
Position in the True Crime chart (US), last 90 days.
#1#76#151AugSepOctNov
#54
all-time peak
222
days in the top 100 since Nov 2024
Chart positions
Where I Think Not! ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Nov 3, 2026).
A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.
I first listened to this because I loved Patrick from TCO and this was another way to listen to him. Well, Ellyn turned out to be the real attraction and when she brought Joey in, this show really found its niche. I absolutely adore them both and I listen every week. Patrick who? Don’t skip this hilarious show from two incredibly talented people, it’s just a ton of fun plus also crime!
skanaksjajdofkabsbd · Dec 2024
Absolutely LOVE this podcast! Such a funny spin on true crime. 100% recommend!
TraciLovesTrueCrime · Oct 2024
Hilarious, shocking, entertaining, sad, perplexing, compassionate, clever and SO MUCH HEART! I first found Ellyn & Rabia and then (of course) fell in big love with magical Joey. You two have become part of my routine and life. I have laughed out loud, cried, introduced friends and family to you and rooted for you as your careers grow and lives are touched as a result. Sending you all my best on waves of rainbows and sunshine. Keep glowing you gorgeous golden souls.
AZDB2 · Oct 2024
I love this podcast and I love Ellyn and Joey!! I love how loud and funny they are, but also how serious and sensitive they can be when needed. I haven’t met them in person, but I feel like we’ve been friends for years. This podcast makes my work day much easier. If you’re not listening…what’s wrong with you?
Seastar503 · Sep 2024
The last episode opened with literally eight minutes of self promotion. Then I counted and averaged, there were ads every 5.5 minutes. I listen to podcasts all day and support the ads, they provide free content and I use the promo codes. I’m on board with this system, but this was nuts. And if the content in between was great I’d be like yes fine, thanks for the ads. It’s not funny enough for entertainment and they’re not doing the real journalism that other pods are doing. Also please no fart songs, I’m not in middle school.
eileen in brooklyn · Nov 2024
I like true crime podcasts where the podcasters are authentic and empathetic… this podcast lacks both… these two are trying so hard to be funny, cool, and relevant at the expense of the actual true crime story they are trying to tell. Their personalities, jokes, and conversations feel forced and contrived. Not a fan.
jordynlynsey · Oct 2024
We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.
More podcasts like I Think Not!
Popular shows in True Crime, for your next listen.
Here you find the Apple Podcasts chart positions of I Think Not!, its latest episodes to listen to directly, and reviews from listeners. Rankings are updated daily for the United States.
