Drama · Homestead on the Corner | Realm
by Homestead on the Corner | Realm
In 2018, famed horror writer Anna Sheridan disappeared, leaving behind only a box of mysterious cassette tapes. Detective Sam Bailey is tasked with piecing together what happened to Anna Sheridan from the seemingly impossible encounters she recorded, but as the scattered pieces of the puzzle come together, Bailey discovers that the picture is even stranger – and more dangerous – than it seemed.
Showing 20 · updated from the feed
Position in the Drama chart (US), last 90 days.
Where The Sheridan Tapes ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Sep 20, 2026).
A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.
Brilliant claustrophobic horror podcast; stellar writing; disturbing BGM. The actress playing Anna is actually quite good, despite the negative comments - she does monologue acting, with nothing to work with, not even a mouse or a small stream flowing beside her in the mines... considering how difficult monologue acting is, I thought she did a terrific job - but to those who disagree I can only say that YES - It would be great if Homestead could’ve hired Meryl Streep to play Anna, but she demands way more money than they could have raised... (and it’s odd that there weren’t the same to be said for the GUY’s monologue 😑)
Alternate title: LGBTQ Scooby-Doo. This show has so many fantastic elements. It has an overarching mystery peppered with interconnected creepy pastas. It’s Stranger Things meets The Twilight Zone. Very fun when it’s fun. Unfortunately a large portion of the time, it’s just characters whining to themselves about their post-teen angst. Those episodes are about as engaging as an emo kid’s diary. But it does sort of have a “dust yourself off and do hard things” message despite that.
This show seems so good and I tried to stick with it but I listen with headphones and the background noise & music include constant high pitched tones and beeping. It gave me a headache after a few episodes - if you’re sensitive to those types of noises be sure not to use headphones when listening to this show
I love “found footage “ podcasts and horror/suspense style of mystery. I found this is a great podcast to listen to since my others from Pacific Northwest are not coming out soon. I really like the opennes of the podcast which includes getting high and lgbtqia characters. I feel seen! Heard! And love you for this.
I really wanted to like this. The idea sounded enticing. The music was engaging, and the start had me hooked but I found little else to keep me going. By episode four I had to call it quits. The narrator sounds like he’s trying to emulate some old Noir style detective which kinda comes off sounding forced. Meanwhile the character mixed with the voice acting for Anna makes her come off as the biggest airhead. She comes off as more of a character that belongs on a sitcom. Like I picture her having a coffee mug stating “No paranormal phenomenon till I’ve had my coffee”. I just feel like she undercuts any sort of tension a situation has with her oblivious nature. Which makes me lose any sort of tension. Again the story was getting kind of interesting. But I can’t feel any anxiety or worry about Anna when she certainly doesn’t.
Feels like some episodes are filler, having you sit through teenage angst until something substantial happens. It has great potential, but too much fluff.
We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.
Popular shows in Drama, for your next listen.
Daily updated Apple Podcasts rankings for the United States.
Here you find the Apple Podcasts chart positions of The Sheridan Tapes, its latest episodes to listen to directly, and reviews from listeners. Rankings are updated daily for the United States.
Questions or issues? Reach us at hello@reason.fm