In a world obsessed with True Crime, follow Charlie Incarica as he investigates one of the
Truest* Crimes ever committed. Come for the crime spree...stay for dessert.
*Not true, per se. And by "per se," we mean "at all." So to speak.
Follow to hear what the New York Times would likely say is "The last True Crime podcast you'll ever listen to."
Shop TMK Merch at: https://the-murderer-killings-a-true-crime-podcast-shop.fourthwall.com/
Chart trend
Position in the Comedy Fiction chart (US), last 90 days.
#1#98#194JunJulAugSep
#2
all-time peak
23
days in the top 3 since Dec 2025
Latest episodes
Showing 10 · updated from the feed
Episode 9 - The Finale Destination
Send us Fan Mail
Branigan’s instincts start convincing her more and more that they’ve convicted the wrong person. Meanwhile, as Charlie prepares to leave Shady Grove, he
Dec 10 2025 24 min
Episode 8 - The Penultimate Episode
Send us Fan Mail
It’s Christmas in Shady Grove, and as the trial date looms, Charlie decides to stay in town to take in some holiday traditions, such as Mayor Lyons’s On
Dec 10 2025 23 min
Episode 7 - The Seventh Episode
Send us Fan Mail
As the murder investigation continues, a power struggle to seize control of the massive Shady Grove Pudding empire intensifies between Teddy Putnam and
Dec 10 2025 10 min
Episode 6 - The Sixth Episode
Send us Fan Mail
After a brief absence, Charlie returns to Shady Grove to find the town is growing restless due to lack of progress in the investigation. Interim Acting
Dec 10 2025 15 min
Episode 5 - The Fifth Episode
Send us Fan Mail
The investigation begins to heat up as now Acting Interim Chief Taylor Branigan takes the lead on the case, and applies pressure to Margaret Mandragora-
Dec 10 2025 21 min
Episode 4 - The Fourth Episode
Send us Fan Mail
Charles gets help untangling family history from Vanessa Holmes, author of the definitive biography of the Putnam Family, Blood Pudding. Unfortunately,
Dec 10 2025 26 min
Episode 3 - The Third Episode
Send us Fan Mail
Charles is thrilled to announce new sponsors for the podcast, including Amanda’s company Shady Grove Pudding, now both “Proud sponsors and victims of Th
Dec 8 2025 20 min
Episode 2 - The Second Episode
Send us Fan Mail
Charlie dives deep on the history of Shady Grove, and its beloved pudding foundry, which has supported and shaped the community for over a century, and
Dec 8 2025 19 min
Episode 1 - The First Episode
Send us Fan Mail
A triple-homicide in a small rural community leaves more questions than answers. On a tip, Charlie Incarica decides to use his expiring airline miles, e
Dec 8 2025 24 min
The Murderer Killings Podcast: Season 1 Trailer
Send us Fan Mail
"Follow" to be the first to hear what the New York Times would likely say is "The last True Crime podcast you'll ever listen to."
Thanks for liste
Nov 21 2025 1 min
Chart positions
Where The Murderer Killings - A True* Crime Podcast ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Sep 11, 2026).
A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.
Come for the crime spree, stay for the hot wings. The Murderer Killings is what happens when Jack Canfora and Michael Satow (who also plays podcaster Charlie Incarica, a name so Italian-American it should come with a side of gabagool) decide the true crime industrial complex has earned a public flogging. Over ten 19-minute episodes, Charlie uses expiring airline miles to embed in Shady Grove, home of a pudding foundry (not factory, foundry), to investigate the murder of pudding heiress Amanda Putnam-Hart, a former 'pudding-based performance artist' in Berlin. Suspects include her twin brother, her estranged husband (whose mother is the Governor), and Margaret Mandragora-Jones, 'thick as a glacier with a thyroid condition.' COVID hampers the investigation and Chief Ebner's access to hot wings. The mayor embezzles relief funds to stage a 'One-Man Christmas Carol.' The trial opens January 6th, 2021, and a forensics finding 'justifies, at minimum, three more episodes,' the genre's most honest sentence. Five stars.
Sounder86 · Apr 2026
“This is the funniest podcast in history” declared my 12 year old after episode one, and I agree fully.
The absurdist humor, pudding puns, over-the-top and under-the-top characters had me laughing for days (I recently binged).
Please, someone pick up this series for a second season!!! I’ve gotta have more Shady Grove!
PBinGSO · Mar 2026
The absolute silliest spoof of a genre. LOVE. A must-listen to for anyone familiar with true crime and all its idiosyncrasies.
LiladyKT · Mar 2026
I loved every minute of listening to this show. I had no idea it would be so funny. Worth a listen for anyone who likes true crime, but wants break.
NccuRN · Feb 2026
We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.
More podcasts like The Murderer Killings - A True* Crime Podcast
Popular shows in Comedy Fiction, for your next listen.
About The Murderer Killings - A True* Crime Podcast on Reason.fm
Here you find the Apple Podcasts chart positions of The Murderer Killings - A True* Crime Podcast, its latest episodes to listen to directly, and reviews from listeners. Rankings are updated daily for the United States.
![THE DOUBLE[S]](/images/1896474452.png)
