Welcome to your cozy corner of the internet, where movies are merry, commentary is cheeky, and holiday spirit lasts all year long!
We’re Jennifer and Josh, two TV movie fanatics working to create your favorite Hallmark hangout! We're diving deep into very sleigh bell-worthy (and sometimes cringe-worthy) movie, one episode at a time. From hot cocoa takes to heartfelt debates, this is your go-to channel for festive fun and sharp-witted reviews! (Not affiliated with Hallmark Media!)
Latest episodes
Showing 20 · updated from the feed
Hallmark's 'A Season of Promises' 2026 Review - WATCH THIS MOVIE!
Have you ever had to start over in love? We see that play out twice in Hallmark’s new Christmas movie “A Season of Promises”. This movie stars Ali Liebert, James Denton a
Nov 11 32 min
Holiday Unplugged: A Screen-Free Christmas, a Split Verdict! | Quick Watch
The family is unplugging. Josh and Jennifer? We’re not on the same wavelength. 🎄
We’re reviewing Hallmark’s Holiday Unplugged, starring Nikki DeLoach and Juan Pablo Di P
Nov 10 10 min
The 12 Dates of Christmas (2026) Review | Lucy Hale & Ian Harding Reunite!
Is The 12 Dates of Christmas (2026) worth watching? 🎄❤️Lucy Hale and Ian Harding reunite after Pretty Little Liars in this Christmas romantic comedy, streaming on Hulu an
Nov 9 6 min
Merry Memories Review: Coal, With a Christmas Bow | Quick Watch
We’re putting a Christmas bow on this lump of coal. 🎁
Josh and Jennifer review Hallmark’s Merry Memories, starring Lindura and Brendan Morgan... and this time, our Gold
Nov 9 14 min
Hallmark's 'Who's Coming For Christmas?' | 2026 Christmas Movie Review
Jennifer and guest co-host Marissa recap Hallmark’s 'Who’s Coming for Christmas?'.
Following Julie’s attempt to fill her late grandmother’s Christmas Eve table and the
Nov 5 35 min
Hallmark's 'Adopting St. Nick' - Was he Santa Claus?! (2026 Movie Review)
If a retirement community, an ugly sweater contest and a major reno got together, you’d have this move wrapped in a bow.
Hallmark's new Countdown to Christmas movie, “Ad
Nov 3 42 min
Hallmark's 'A Danish Christmas' - We are booking a trip NOW! (2026 Movie Review)
Pack your bags, because we are traveling to Denmark in this recap and review of Hallmark’s new countdown to christmas movie “A Danish Christmas”; starring Emilie Ullerup
Nov 2 26 min
Hallmark's 'What If Christmas?' - We were wrong about this movie! (2026 Movie Review) QUICK WATCH
If a giant handblown heart ornament could transport you to an alternate life and make you wonder WHAT IF, would you put it on your tree? 'What If Christmas?' stars Lori L
Oct 29 13 min
'Forgotten Holiday' is a Hallmark Christmas movie we will never forget! (2026 review)
A marriage proposal, a restored jukebox and a case of holiday amnesia are featured in this new Hallmark Countdown to Christmas movie, 'Forgotten Holiday' starring Daniel
Oct 27 32 min
Winter Wonderlanes: A Strike or Gutter Ball? | Hallmark Christmas Movie Quick Watch
An old bowling alley. An old love. Old memories of her late grandfather. But Winter Wonderlanes is a new and fresh location for a Hallmark Christmas movie!
Is this movi
Oct 24 16 min
Mr. & Mrs. Christmas: Does the Romance Add Up? | Quick Watch
One Christmas Market. Two potential lovebirds. Does the romance add up, or should someone check the holiday budget? 🎄
We’re reviewing Mr. & Mrs. Christmas, starring Pasc
Oct 19 10 min
Holiday Touchdown: A Bears Love Story — Full Recap, Review & Gold or Coal
A reporter. A firefighter. A grandmother with 500 Bears games on her résumé. Hallmark has assembled its roster, but does Holiday Touchdown: A Bears Love Story deliver whe
Oct 18 33 min
Hallmark's "’Tis the Season for Setups": A Christmas Kickoff… or a Snooze? | Quick Watch
The countdown is ON. The spark? We’re still looking. 🎄👀
Jennifer and Josh launch our Countdown to Christmas 2026 coverage with a Quick Watch recap and review of Hallmark
Oct 17 12 min
"The Spirit of Halloween": A Spooky Sweet Surprise! | Quick Watch
Bah, hum-BOO! 🎃
Jennifer gets into the spirit with a Quick Watch recap and review of Hallmark’s The Spirit of Halloween, starring Meghan Ory and Kevin McGarry.
A Hallow
Oct 15 5 min
"Christmas Under the Stars": Our 12 Pods of Christmas Summer Series Finale!
We’re closing out 12 Pods of Christmas under the stars! Jennifer and Josh recap and review "Christmas Under the Stars", where a newly unemployed finance guy lands at a Ch
Oct 15 23 min
The Christmas Train: Next Stop, Coal? | 12 Pods of Christmas #11
Our 12 Pods of Christmas journey pulls into its 11th stop: The Christmas Train.
With that cast and a cross-country Christmas romance, what could go wrong? Jennifer and
Oct 13 25 min
"Countdown to Christmas" 2026: Jennifer & Josh’s Most Anticipated Hallmark Movies!
Our Christmas movie calendars are about to get crowded. But which premieres have us REALLY excited? 🎄
Jennifer and Josh each pick their five most anticipated movies from
Oct 9 21 min
Holly & Ivy (2020): Feels, a Fixer-Upper & Four Opinions | 12 Pods of Christmas
This week’s 12 Pods of Christmas pick comes with a heartfelt story and a house that needs a lot of work.
Friends of the pod, Leslie Ann and Mary, join Jennifer and Josh
Oct 6 43 min
Your Favorite Hallmark Hangout! Join Us!
We're gearing up for this year's 'Countdown To Christmas' and can't wait to have you join The Watch Party alongside us! Which movie are you most excited to see?? Drop us
Oct 2 1 min
The Christmas House (2020) (With Cousin Chad!) | Hallmark Recap & Review
It’s a full house at Do You Watch What I Watch? !
Cousin Chad of the Christmas Cousins podcast joins Jennifer and Josh to revisit Hallmark’s The Christmas House. The Mit
Sep 29 41 min
Chart trend
Position in the TV Reviews chart (US), last 90 days.
#1#98#195AugSepOctNov
#64
all-time peak
10
days in the top 100 since Dec 2024
Chart positions
Where Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Nov 15, 2026).
A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.
Jennifer and Josh nail it every time — they’re insightful, funny, and their banter is next-level. You truly feel like you’re right there with them, hanging out as they dive into their reviews. It’s a fun, feel-good listen that always brightens my day. Highly, highly recommend!
RCRCRC! · Dec 2025
I just found this podcast and I’m catching up on episodes. I really like the length and recaps of their episodes. Gold or Coal is such a cute way to rate these movies. They mainly cover Hallmark but also a few of the other networks.
Red Sox⚾️16 · Nov 2025
Josh and Jennifer never disappoint! From cry counts, to BMOPs, to gold or coal, I’m always highly entertained and in a more Christmasy spirit. Sit back and feel the coziness as if you were in front of the fire with your hot chocolate even if you’re really on the freeway to work. Best pod for the whole year!
Diaper Jeanie · Aug 2024
People love to argue about when it might be “too soon” to start welcoming in the holiday season. I say it’s never too early for Christmas music, Christmas decorations, holiday Starbucks drinks or holiday movie podcasts. The friendly folks from Do You Watch What I Watch will help you quickly get into the Christmas spirit with their fun reviews of the guilty pleasure holiday movies from Hallmark, Lifetime, etc. The quick easy listens are perfect for quick trips to the tree farm, the bakery or the gazebo. Warm and fuzzies all around with Jennifer and Josh!
Daniels313 · Nov 2023
We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.
More podcasts like Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews
Popular shows in TV Reviews, for your next listen.
About Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews on Reason.fm
Here you find the Apple Podcasts chart positions of Do You Watch What I Watch? | Hallmark Movie Reviews, its latest episodes to listen to directly, and reviews from listeners. Rankings are updated daily for the United States.
