MrCreepyPasta's Storytime - Podcast Rankings and reviews

Been listening for almost ten years, my favorite narrator out of all of the ones I’ve heard! Voice work is great, and no irritating cadences or trying-too-hard voices like some other ones I’ve found. The story choices and ambience sound effects are great too!

Haunting and engaging. MCP draws you in with his natural, amiable voice then never fails to make you shiver like you did when you were 8 years old and afraid of what lives in your closet.

This guy does a great job telling stories that keep you engaged from start to finish. I listen to so many different podcasts and am an audio book addict so you can trust me when I say this narrator is one of the best in the industry! Bravo!

im rating this 5 stars because it is amazing and the storytelling is excellent but i have noticed an issue. a lot of the episodes ive been listening to have been repeating words or sentances and for a few of them i just thought it was for the storytelling but the episode im listening to right now "i dared my best friend to ruin my life. hes succeeding" at around 1 hour through, it went back to an earlier part of the story (maybe 40 minutes) but it isnt showing up if i accidentally rewinded it. i have also found this in the gas station jack episodes (that was amazing btw) and several others including the shorter ones. i love this podcast soooo much! another thing that i think would make it even better is a trigger warning in the episode description for triggering topics (like self harm, suicide, drug abuse, eating disorders, ect) so i and others in recovery can avoid those episodes. to mr.creepypasta, thank you so much for this podcast. it has always been a great place for me to get my mind off of life and hear some amazing horror stories for free! your voice has conferted me so much through the past few monthes which have been tough. eagerly awaiting the next bonesaw vic episode!

again, thank you so much for this

I’ve been an MCP fan for AGES, namely subbed on YouTube. Then when I got into podcasts, it was a seamless transition! MCP is a great reader, and I love the effort put into editing and details like music and sound effects.

That said, the ads are getting excessive. I was fine with ads at the beginning, if annoyed. Then ads were at the end, and, hey, everyone’s gotta make money! But the ads just right in the middle of the story are too much. It completely takes me out of the horror mood, and ruins the moment. If this continues, I’m going to unsubscribe here and watch on YT with an ad-blocker. I don’t want to do it, but it’s just gotten to be too much. If this changes, I’m happy to edit my review and raise the stars to 5, because I love LITERALLY everything else. But the mid-story ads are a no.