Marcus In The Morning Second Date Update

Colin's Pre-Date Ritual Freaked Mariah Out

Colin thought drinks with Mariah in Mill Valley went SO well that they decided to keep the night going back at his place. That's when Mariah started noticing some... inte

Hailey Left Before Finding Out the Truth About Trevor

Hailey saw what she thought was a MASSIVE red flag and decided to get out before the drama started. The only problem? She didn't stick around long enough to find out whet

How Did Miguel Misread Hannah's Vibe?

After drinks in Redwood City, Miguel walked away feeling hopeful. Hannah was bright, curious, and honest about how exhausting dating in your thirties can feel. No awkward

Mark & Julia's Point Richmond Date that Wasn't on Point

Mark hit us up confused, and honestly, fair enough. His date with Julia checked all the boxes: drinks and dinner on the water in Point Richmond, a peaceful vibe, good con

Marcus' Friend Told Shannon Something She Couldn't Ignore

We've had people ghost AFTER a first date, but Shannon basically ghosted Marcus DURING THE DATE. One minute they're having drinks with some of his friends, the next she's

How Could Liam Do That to Heather?

Heather thought the date went great. Liam was funny, confident, and easy to talk to. They connected over travel, pets, and childhood fears—and she left smiling. But after

Evan's Dating Strategy Gave Molly the Immediate Ick

When the hostess greeted Evan by NAME, Molly didn't think much of it. When the server already knew his drink order, she started getting curious. And when she finally lear

Colleen Caught What Derek Was REALLY Doing

Everything was going great until Colleen realized she may have gotten the WRONG impression about Derek. The problem is, she thinks he intentionally created that impressio

Jenna Found THIS Under Calvin's Seat

Imagine finding something suspicious in your date's car... laughing it off... and then HE ghosts YOU. That's exactly what happened to Jenna after an amazing night with Ca

Mitchell Says It's Efficient... Dana Says It's INSANE

Dana says she absolutely would've gone out with Mitchell again. Then she saw something she was NEVER supposed to see. Mitchell insists he technically didn't do anything w

Rebecca Couldn't Believe What Alex Was Ordering

The date was going perfectly until Alex turned dinner into something Rebecca definitely did NOT sign up for. What started with one extra entrée quickly escalated into a s

Why Was Adam SCREENING Brooke on the First Date?

There are normal first-date questions... and then there are whatever Adam was asking Brooke. She tried to go along with it until the questions became suspiciously specifi

Ashley Thought Ben's Horror Movie Dating Theory Was WILD

Ben says there was a method behind his first-date movie choice. Ashley says that "method" is exactly why there won't be another one. What seemed like a normal horror movi

Samantha Passed Eric's Test... But He Failed Hers

Samantha was willing to overlook an awkward moment during an otherwise great first date. What she wasn't willing to overlook was realizing it might not have been an accid

Jason's Free Food Hack Gave Nicole the Ick

Dinner was going great until the ENTIRE restaurant got involved. Nicole thought she was helping Jason celebrate something special, but after the date she discovered one t

Five Minutes in Ryan's Apartment Changed Everything for Vanessa

The date itself? Amazing. What happened AFTER the date? Absolute chaos. Vanessa noticed something suspicious inside Ryan's apartment, but the way she decided to get answe

Why Did Lauren Ask Reid About THAT on a First Date?!

The vibes were great until Lauren started asking questions that sounded less like flirting and more like an interrogation. Reid finally asked what everyone would've been

Matt & Monica's First Date Had a Secret Audience

Matt says he picked the restaurant because he loves the atmosphere. Monica thinks there might've been a VERY different reason. One awkward interaction turned into an even

The Hinge Date That Had Leo Hooked and Jasmine Shook

Leo met Jasmine on Hinge and went for cocktails in Oakland. She was stylish, sharp, and had an edge he loved. They talked music, travel, and dating horror stories, and by

Apparently Dinner with Bryce & Naomi Came With Terms & Conditions

Apparently paying for dinner gives you certain privileges... at least according to Bryce. Naomi had a VERY different interpretation, and their first date ended with an ar