What's Our Podcast? with Beck Bennett and Kyle Mooney - Podcast Rankings and reviews

I have a lot of love for these two, as well as many of their guests. I enjoy the podcast because they don’t take themselves too seriously and it feels like you’re just hanging out with friends. I knocked off one star because a lot of times it feels like there are inside jokes that I am not in on. And I’m also a little jealous that I haven’t been invited on the show. But I am nobody so, fair.

This concept is so fun. It’s fresh and funny, which is what one would expect from Kyle and Beck. I’m already re-listening while I wait for more.

I think this has the potential to be the funniest podcast out there. I just wish Kyle would lean into his goofy side more instead of trying to redirect back to normalcy! The goofs make this show!

What makes this podcast so awesome is the friendship between Beck and Kyle however the concept is also quite fun. The fact that they hand over the reigns to their guest means that something unexpected is always happening and it’s so fun to watch the two of them try to manage the chaos. I love you two don’t ever change!!!

I love them both and was excited to see they had a new pod! But, turns out it’s just another podcast where comedians just riff on mike like a couple of inexperienced AV club teenage boys.
No substance, no style, no point of view and most importantly, not funny. Was hoping for something fresh and original from these two but this is a hard pass in the oversaturated podcast world.

Look, I like Beck and Kyle. Loved em on SNL, like when I see them in TV and films, etc. But this is not something that anyone was asking for. It reeks of entitlement to think “hey, we’re popular, we should have a podcast”, even though they have zero experience, and no actual premise for a show. Kyle in particular is a horrible interviewer, always bringing the conversation to a halt. There’s no premise, nothing to talk about other than just riffing with the guest and talking over eachother, and judging by these first few episodes, the guest sounds totally blindsided, not even knowing what the show they’re on is.

We don’t need every white male comedian to have a podcast.
Stick to what you know. It’s really telling that they apparently recorded a dozen episodes with high profile guests, before even announcing the show. Just reeks of privilege, another avenue to make money for people who are already in the 1%. I expect this show to last maybe a year before fizzling out, especially if they keep up this “non premise” which the guests obviously don’t know what to do with.