Our curated selection of reviews
I love this podcast. Matthew is a great host who has gallons of personality. He does a deep dive into The Traitors, with fun and knowledgeable and diverse guests, including many cast members from the US and UK shows. Very well produced, with fun regular features. I look forward to every episode. Highly recommended!
Read more
I can’t get enough of this podcast! As someone who doesn’t have access to watch the UK, Australia, or New Zealand series of the show, these recaps are just as entertaining as watching. Please keep making more episodes!!
Read more
Definitely my favorite Traitor podcast! I love how Matthew works through the episodes and hearing different thoughts and insights (and sometimes yelling at my phone when something is missed lol). I would 100% recommend!
Read more
Thanks for the wonderful, entertaining, informative podcast. I love the format, the small deception on a show all about deception is a fun twist! Keep up the great work!
Read more
I really enjoy The Traidar Podcast, and Matthew Keeley truly does a fantastic job. He’s thoughtful, balanced, and clearly puts real effort into the show. That’s why I’m petitioning for a David-free podcast. I want the show to succeed and get back to its best version.
Unfortunately, I had to stop listening because of David. His tone often feels very angry and at times misogynistic, and he frequently takes jabs at other Traitors podcasts. He even says he doesn’t care if people find him annoying or too much, and he tends to double down on any opinion that isn’t his. I’ve heard the same energy when he appears on Why X Lost. It changes the vibe and makes the podcast hard to enjoy.
I truly hope the team reads these reviews and looks at how many listeners may be tuning out. I will happily change this 1-star review to 5 stars once he’s no longer on the podcast.
Read more
What a disappointment. This is usually my favorite Traitor podcast by far, but David’s poor knowledge of the players, along with two terrible cohosts for the first two episodes whose input suggested they knew little about the actual game, is bringing this podcast down terribly. I’ll be listening to all of the other Traitor podcasts except this one for US S2 coverage.
Read more
We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts
