The Jeselnik & Rosenthal Vanity Project - Podcast Rankings and reviews

I been a fan of Anthony’s for over a decade but was kinda late to discover the podcast. I’ve since gone back and listened to every episode, even the RJVP eps. I discovered this podcast mid pandemic and shortly after started relistening from the early 2020 episodes. It was comforting in hearing their reactions as things changed and uncertainty grew from week to week, and the how they adapted thought it. Those episodes made me reminisce in a similar way to how I hold the 9/11 episode of The Howard Stern show in regard.

Anthony is still my favorite comedian, but I keep tuning in to hear the relationship between him and Gregg. The banter, the rudeness and the caring all wrapped into one shows the comfort and ease of their friendship. It’s great to see. I have a similar relationship with my best friend, people say it’s great to watch us in our element, I never really understood that until hearing your guys’ friendship on air. I have since turned my friend on to the podcast and discuss almost immediately after it drops. Though he listens at 1.5 speed which I cannot fathom.

I loved the little sister relationship with Erica, and am really starting to love Aaron as he comes into his own and joins in more and more.

The funniest episode in my opinion is the one where they discuss the Queens death. Anthony take on her cause of death and his delivery killed me and Gregg’s laugh to it just sealed the deal. I’ve listened (and watched) that probably 20 times since.

JRVP 4 Life

My husband and I have been fans of Anthony’s comedy since seeing him in Grand Rapids, MI, at the first Gilda’s Laughfest. This podcast is just as hilarious. He and Greg give a comical spin on all things relevant in the world. We love the comedy, emails that are shared, recommendations…. Thanks for making us laugh daily. -Dawn

Erica had been with the boys since the beginning of JRVP and her send off was not speaking her entire final episode and then having a prerecorded Erica's Corner at the end which was basically Erica saying "Thanks for everything guys" and not much else. The whole thing was very abrupt, jarring, and disappointing making it seem like either Erica was indifferent to leaving because she didn't say much and had a new gig with the LA Rams promising more exposure/clout for her brand or she got sacked because she had taken JRVP as far as she could and the boys wanted to go in a new direction. Erica deserved a better send off either way. For a show that advertising now makes up nearly 50% of the show, it's a chore to fast forward through all the ad reads to get to the content and the witty banter. This podcast was once one of my favorites but it's also the one I find myself unsubscribing from often then subbing back after a few months only to find that not much has changed. The majority of comedians that have the same star power or greater than Jeselnik who have podcasts get the job done with less ad reads and they still have amazing shows. Why can't this happen? RIP Erica. Shine on you crazy diamond!

I am an eye doctor and love this podcast. It is funny and informative at the same time. It is my go to podcast while driving to work.

I used to be a fan of the show but it has gone downhill since Erica left. Not only did she bring the energy, she was the glue that kept the show together. Her comedy was priceless and always spot on and now it's just two dudes talking for an hour.... I'd rather listen to static television.