Scare You To Sleep - Podcast Rankings and reviews

Scare You to Sleep is a hauntingly captivating podcast that masterfully blends chilling storytelling with atmospheric sound design. The host’s voice is smooth, slightly sultry, and remarkably easy to listen to. It draws you in gently, creating an immersive experience that feels both intimate and eerie.

The production quality is superb. Each episode features carefully curated soundscapes and music that enhance the storytelling without ever overpowering the narration. Unlike many podcasts in the horror genre, Scare You to Sleep avoids jarring or unnecessary sound effects, maintaining a balance that keeps the listener engaged rather than distracted.

The story selection is equally impressive, ranging from eclectic spooky tales to allegedly true encounters. The “Guided Nightmares” episodes are a particularly unique feature as it blends a touch of ASMR with horror in a way that’s unsettling in all the right ways. If you’re like me, the rambles at the end of each episode are a hidden gem. I could listen to them for hours; they add a personal, calming touch after the intensity of the stories.

I highly recommend Scare You to Sleep for anyone who enjoys horror with elegance, listeners who appreciate atmospheric tension over cheap jump scares, and those who love to be gently unnerved before drifting off to sleep. Though some stories may push boundaries, they never go too far, and even in moments where I worried two tales might become overwhelming, the narrative remained tasteful and impactful.

This podcast is a must listen for fans of spooky storytelling, well-crafted audio experiences, and anyone craving a darker lullaby to end their day. Beware: You will never hear another podcast the same again.

I found this podcast from a search looking for horror podcasts to listen to before bed. When I started listening I would play it before bed to fall asleep to but after a while I found it hard to fall asleep while listening because the podcast is so good that I actually wanted to hear all the stories. Now I only listen when I’m wide awake to listen to the awesome work the host Shelby does. This is easily one of my favorite podcast and I look forward to new episodes every week. I highly recommend it!

i’ve been listening for years but never used apple podcasts until recently. this show and shelby being so cool and interactive on social media have been consistent and amazing from day one.
her narration style is incredible, the stories she chooses are always top tier, and the dark reddit episodes are absolute peak.
please never stop

When I can’t sleep or really bored your voice is so soft I fall asleep all the time I love everything about this podcast

The perfect podcasting voice. She’s very intentional with the stories she tells and is so incredibly talented! Always love the content Shelby puts out