How We Made Your Mother - Podcast Rankings and reviews

Josh and Craig take listeners on a nostalgic journey as they look back on HIMYM. Yet this is not just a rewatch podcast, but one that looks to uncover the secrets of the show, its longevity and the way it works itself into people’s lives for the better. Highly recommend this podcast.

I love HIMYM … I watch it almost every night as my “going to bed” show. I love Josh’s Muse newsletter too. I pay for it. It’s thoughtful without being too pretentious or precious.

The podcast is very good and I expect it will get better. I like the “behind the scenes” insights from Carter and Josh.

I’ll admit that I fast forward through the transition music. I like the song but hearing it several times during the pod doesn’t work for me. I’d prefer a non-vocal transition.

The end “analysis”by Jordana doesn’t work me either. (I don’t like it with the Wiser than Me pod either).

Perhaps it’s because she wasn’t involved in the show and isn’t a fan.

I’d recommend including her in the convo with Carter and Josh (like Nick Viall) so we can get to know her and hear her insights as a newbie with the hosts or don’t include her at all.

The current format feels like an abrupt transition (warm to cold).

Again, just my thoughts on what I think will be a brilliant pod.

I love HIMYM and have probably watched the entire series 5 times. This podcast is like a warm hug. They are both natural and lovely. But umm (IYKYK) please change the New York song to instrumental only. I love Josh’s music, but hearing those same two refrains over and over is driving me a little nutty. Much love.

One of my favorite shows. I watched the series through about 10 years ago and decided to do it again this year. I’ve already finished it but find myself turning it on almost every evening because I just love the laughs and storylines. So excited to have this podcast as a rewatch option with part of the cast and creators, how fun!