Reason.fm Logo
Top 100 podcasts Charts

History of Japan - Podcast Rankings and reviews

History of Japan
History of Japan Isaac Meyer

No rankings available for this podcast.

Our curated selection of reviews

The_Gaucho 09/09/2022
This unassuming podcast serves as an incredible and in-depth survey of (literally) all of Japanese history. Don’t let it’s simple delivery deceive you: this is in substance a Hardcore History of Japan, but with infinitely greater frequency. I look forward to being a supporting listener. If you’re interested in Japan or Japanese history—DO NOT skip this podcast.
Read more
DCKID357 04/17/2021
I love just about everything for this podcast. It begins with a quick summary of the political narrative and then breaks down the Japanese historic culture by taking on various topics. It’s amazing listening to the end of the samurai and then the history of Hokkaido and then the rise and fall of communism in Japan as opposed to a single linear narrative gives so much more of an appreciation for one of the most unique countries on earth. For most podcasts that want to talk about modern nations I think they should replicate Isaac more often.
Read more
Jason E L. 10/14/2022
Explains nearly everything from the feudal era to the modern period, from intricacies of the Shinto religion to major political scandals, providing a comprehensive overview of Japan. The channel usually runs with multi-part series, broken up with pieces about important literature and poetry. Meyer handles subjects with care, offering all sides but without sacrificing objectivity, something sorely needed for exploring the history of the LDP, and calls out exceptionally foolish people with a wry sense of humor.
Read more
Kaizoku.gari87 08/29/2023
My main problem with this podcast is the author’s complete failure to appreciate any form of literature which requires a human soul to enjoy. I began listening as a kind of brush-up for my MA exams, but by the time I finished them (and had listened enough that the topics about which I pride myself in being knowledgeable could be covered), I realized the flaws and simple carelessness of the author’s research. Though factual historical information is often (but not always) correct, whenever there is any call to interpret, he tends to run with a preconception, singling out one or two other scholars who - at least partially - share his views, or else simply declaim opinions with no academic backing whatsoever.

To give a particularly egregious example, the first episode on Kawabata Yasunari may be more or less factually correct, but his errors do not end with a total misunderstanding of Kawabata’s aesthetic. I have no idea how one could read the term “mono no aware” and decide the closest translation was “impermanence.” (This calls to attention another of the author’s failings: a modest capability with the Japanese language at best.) “Aware” is most often interpreted as “pathos,” so “mono no aware” is most often rendered as “the pathos of things.” It is an aesthetic of wonder and pain, care and loss and terrible but subtle beauty, and yes it would not be meaningful without impermanence, but that does not make them the same thing. The closest translation to the English word “impermanence,” and the Buddhist concept which Myers - for some incomprehensible reason - quotes directly from the Heike is “mujou.”

I have to say, as a PhD student in Classical Japanese literature myself, this is the first time I have ever heard anyone evoke the Heike in a discussion of “mono no aware.” For the very simple reason that the two concepts are essentially chalk and cheese. It was painful to listen to Myers even mention the kokugaku movement - and Genji monogatari itself! - but not Moto’ori Norinaga’s obsession with the Genji, the work from which Norinaga himself coined “mono no aware” as an all-encompassing aesthetic and mood of the work, and of Heian literature more broadly. Norinaga was notably much less interested in literature created AFTER the Heian Period. Such as, for example, the notably un-aesthetically motivated war story, Heike monogatari.

As for why this topic was so particularly painful to me as a human being, I initially started writing my MA thesis on “mono no aware,” and read all three major translations, as well as the original Genji obsessively for the first two years of my degree. I later switched to reading gender politics in Heike, thus I consider myself relatively well-read in both these works. And what, I gather, Myers was attempting to seek out in bizarrely quoting Heike in discussing “aware” was the Buddhist overtones of the text, a later and likely politically-motivated addition to make the whole work - originally a disjointed collection of anecdotes from the Gempei War - more cohesive as a narrative. It is not an aesthetic. And fundamental misinterpretations like this, quite frankly, could only be made by someone with either a poor understanding of the Japanese language - like the high, obscure and lyrical language which Kawabata was known for - or lacking a soul entirely. I would sooner trust Myers’ political episodes, but the blatant ignorance toward not only literary value but the history of Japanese literary scholarship are contemptible enough not to give the show any of your valuable time or attention.
Read more

We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts

All Podcasts
Spotify Ranking

Categories:

After Shows
Alternative Health
Animation & Manga
Arts
Astronomy
Automotive
Aviation
Baseball
Basketball
Books
Buddhism
Business
Business News
Careers
Chemistry
Christianity
Comedy
Comedy Fiction
Comedy Interviews
Courses
Crafts
Cricket
Daily News
Design
Documentary
Drama
Earth Sciences
Education
Education for Kids
Entertainment News
Entrepreneurship
Fantasy Sports
Fashion & Beauty
Fiction
Film History
Film Interviews
Film Reviews
Fitness
Food
Football
Games
Golf
Government
Health & Fitness
Hinduism
History
Hobbies
Hockey
Home & Garden
How To
Improv
Investing
Islam
Judaism
Kids & Family
Language Learning
Leisure
Life Sciences
Management
Marketing
Mathematics
Medicine
Mental Health
Music
Music Commentary
Music History
Music Interviews
Natural Sciences
Nature
News
News Commentary
Non-Profit
Nutrition
Parenting
Performing Arts
Personal Journals
Pets & Animals
Philosophy
Physics
Places & Travel
Politics
Relationships
Religion
Religion & Spirituality
Rugby
Running
Science
Science Fiction
Self-Improvement
Sexuality
Soccer
Social Sciences
Society & Culture
Spirituality
Sports
Sports News
Stand-Up
Stories for Kids
Swimming
Tech News
Technology
Tennis
True Crime
TV & Film
TV Reviews
Video Games
Visual Arts
Volleyball
Wilderness
Wrestling

About History of Japan ranking

Here you find the Apple Podcast Rankings of History of Japan.

Contact

Do you have a question or an issue on the website? Please get in touch with us at hello@reason.fm

Privacy Policy