History Is Sexy - Podcast Rankings and reviews

Emma and Janina makes boring history so interesting to listen! Emma is very good at citing actual evidence for the things she talks about yet still make them sexy. ’ve exhausted all the episodes in about two weeks while listening on my commute. I feel I’ve learned so much about so many different subjects.

I absolutely love this podcast, I listen to it almost everyday! I’m currently listening to the whole podcast over again, I play reruns in the background while I clean it’s that interesting! Their banter is great and funny. They make history fun and sexy! Definitely a recommend to people interested in history!

I am a history buff but so often it’s men droning on and on about things that could be fascinating but somehow get dulled based off how they are presented. The hosts talk about these topics in an exciting and relevant way. They also assume the audience are history buffs and so they keep it appropriately academic thus presenting the information in an engaging and critical way.

Amazing hosts, really fun and relaxing history podcast with interesting topics. Began listening after reading “A fatal thing happened on the way to the forum,” by Dr. Emma Southon (one of the hosts) and have found it is a similarly refreshing and entertaining take on history. Highly recommend!

Pros: Wide range of topics, amusingly breezy synopses of various historical moments, lots of personal asides but they blend pretty well with the flow of the show. The podcast avoids droning academic recitations of historical events and keeps things engaging.

Cons: Some glaring factual inaccuracies, and a weird vibe between the hosts. Emma, the historian, has a lot of…self-regard? She’s subtly condescending to her non-historian partner, and over time this becomes quite grating. A PhD does not mean you are automatically smarter—and I say this as someone with a PhD. Sometimes I felt badly for her co-host. Additionally, they’re both very much of a Skeptical Inquirer bent; anyone across time and culture who doesn’t subscribe to a scientific materialist worldview is skewered as a complete moron. This probably resonates with a lot of people, but the meanness doesn’t add to the show. Finally, hearing Emma declare that disabled dogs should just be euthanized sent me over the edge. (She was specifically wanting to euthanize all overbred Frenchies, although I’m assuming this stance would apply to other dogs with disabilities.) I understand she says stuff like this for shock value, but…meh.
I’ve listened to about 35 episodes (not in order) and although there is good pacing and some genuinely informative and funny moments, the ick factor with this show is just too high.