Gilmore Guys - Podcast Rankings and reviews

I’ve loved this since I became addicted to Gilmore Girls just before the revival came out. I’m enjoying rewatching the show while listening to the accompanying episodes of the podcast. I just could give it 5 stars because of all of the inappropriate humor. They get too graphic sometimes and it isn’t necessary-especially whenever they have Jason Manzoukas on. There’s so much good and fun about the show, just wish it was something I felt more comfortable recommending to my friends to listen along with too

Relistening for the 4th or 5th time, probably, and 605 (We’ve Got Magic to Do, with Sarah Heyward and Sarah Ramos) is such pure and sweet energy, while still being one of the most analytical episodes of the podcast. I feel like I am chatting with old friends about a show I love, and it’s both magical and comfortable at the same time. 💕

I’ve now started to listen to the podcast on a loop, just like I watch the show every couple years. Kevin and Demi are awesome, their podcast is now just as familiar and comfortable as Gilmore Girls is for me. I still laugh out loud on a regular basis

I adore this podcast. I listen while I clean and it makes the time fly by- I’m cracking up the entire time. They’re so quick, witty, and clever!

The hosts are hilarious but sometimes it’s hard to listen to because the pace of the show is chaotic and the guests are mostly people who’ve never watched a single episode of GG and come on to talk about how much they don’t like it. The hosts are often making stuff up as they go, so the pod lacks structure and consistency, like they just said “hey wanna do a podcast?” but didn’t really put any thought into it. Their mocking sense of humor alongside the guests’ harsh criticisms make this come off as a disrespectful hate-watch podcast. And who wants that…? I’m trying to hang in there because there’s a disclaimer on the pilot episode that says it gets better lol, but when? I’m not even done with the first season and I’ve already had to skip 5 episodes out of frustration and annoyance.