CreepTime The Podcast - Podcast Rankings and reviews

So I am a 44-year-old mama for who loves true crime mysteries, paranormal crime documentaries and I’ve never really got into podcasts but within the last month, I’ve been searching for some good ones to listen to while I’m working and I found you guys. I am absolutely addicted. I listen to you 10 hours a day nonstop on Spotifyand I just started following and got the premium episodes on my Apple. Your podcast is amazing. I love both of you. I sit there and I try not to laugh too loud while I’m working lol but sometimes it’s really hard. I’ve watched your videos and just love watching you guys interact and love all the costumes. I’ve told so many people to check you guys out and to listen to your podcast and everybody that I’ve told absolutely loves you.

I stumbled upon CreepTime when I was looking for a podcast to gain more information about the unsolved case of the boy in the chimney. I’m so glad I gave this show a chance because I have truly grown to love Sylas and Stew! The storytelling style, mixed with breaking for commentary and conversation flows so well. I appreciate their sense of humor to break things up a bit as well. The dynamic between Sylas and Stew is as if you are in the room with them, talking about creepy, mysterious and sometimes disturbing stories.
I highly recommend any crime junkies to give this show a chance! And remember, you can’t trust county.

Sylas and Stew do such a phenomenal job balancing the heaviness of cases with a great sense of levity and humor. Admittedly their style might not be for everyone, but it absolutely is for my girlfriend and I! One of the highlights of our vacations/roadtrips is turning on Creeptime and hanging out with you guys. Thank you for bringing us these cases to deep dive into!

I’ve been listening for a couple of years now. My ex and I would listen while making tacos on taco Tuesday. The last Tuesday before the hiatus we were still together and then we broke up that weekend. I felt so empty with my love gone AND Creeptime on hiatus. I have now gone back and I’m re listening to all episodes. I am now a premium member so I get the extra content (much needed). Y’all have provided so much comfort and laughs despite the heavy cases and heartbreak. I can’t thank y’all enough for making my days better. I’m ecstatic for your return this Friday. 🤍