Our curated selection of reviews
I came over from being an avid Morbid and Seriously with Annie Elise listener, and I’m so glad I did! These girls have that same fun, friendly vibe, and their case deep dives are super well-researched and easy to follow. Totally binge-worthy—so excited to have a new true crime fave! Keep it up!
Read more
I have listened to only one case so far, one episode on Laci Peterson and there is an inaccurate piece of info. Amber Frye did not know that Scott was married so calling her a mistress is incorrect due to the fact that she did not know he was married. She thought Laci was dead as Scott told her that his wife had passed away prior. Outside of that, good info, but inaccurate info makes me hesitant and wonder what else is inaccurate. Please do your own research as much as you can on every case you listen to, on any Podcast. The victims deserve that.
Read more
Coming from THT - true crime and Morgan Absher!! My 2 favorite things in one podcast! Loved the episodes, and excited to go check out more of Kaelyn’s shows!
Read more
One of the best and in-depth deep dives I've ever heard! Great dynamic between both hosts and can't wait to hear the next case.
Read more
The high rating is due to the obsessive fans of the hosts' other podcasts.
This show would probably upset anyone who actually appreciates and listens to true crime. The hosts are annoying and disrespectful.
If you're going to tackle true crime, at least approach it with the respect and seriousness it deserves.
Read more
Dang. I really wanted to like this podcast bc I love true crime and Two Hot Takes, but I couldn’t even finish an episode and I tried several. It feels too scripted for my liking. Maybe I’m just used to one of the guests knowing the case and the other guest learning about it, like in my favorite pod People are the Worst. Maybe I’ll try this one again at a later time.
Read more
We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts