Camp Shame - Podcast Rankings and reviews

I was a camper at Camp Shane in 1988 and 1989, and later returned as a counselor in 1998, 1999, 2004, and 2009. Each of those experiences ranks among the best times of my life. I still have close friendships from camp—and I even met my wife there.

Having attended camp across so many different years, I witnessed a lot of changes. But nothing ever took away from the experience or would have stopped me from going back or recommending it to others. I believe some people expect too much—it’s camp! David was always good to me, and I never had any issues with things like getting paid.

Camp Shane wasn’t perfect, but it was real—and it gave so many of us a place to grow, make lifelong connections, and feel like we belonged. For that, I’ll always be grateful.

Only three episodes in, this podcast proves itself to be both gripping and deeply unsettling. Its narrative is provocative, emotionally resonant, and unflinchingly honest—drawing listeners into a story that is as tragic as it is true. The production is thoughtful, the pacing deliberate, and the storytelling powerful. As the details unfold, one cannot help but be struck by the haunting reality behind the series. It leaves listeners with a lingering and uncomfortable question: how could such a place have existed—and worse, how did it continue unchecked for so long?

Fascinating podcast that analyzes a single weight loss camp, weaves individual campers’ experiences, and guides the listener through changes in time and perception of weight loss and diet. Incredibly interesting and human.

I am enjoying the content and the alternative perspective to our typical societal norms around health and weight. However, it’s disheartening that this would include an advertisement for a GLP-1 for weight loss. Each episode starts with a trigger warning for the conversation of body image and weight, and then to turnaround and advertise weight loss is jarring and disappointing

It was entertaining to listen to for the same reasons you’d listen to Dateline or watch Teen Mom. The “fat activism” was laughable but tolerable just to hear the story. A bunch of fat Jewish kids getting sent to fat camp? Come on somebody make a comedy series on Netflix about this already. I’ll watch it.