Too Scary; Didn't Watch

Chart trend

Position in the Film Reviews chart (US), last 90 days.

#1#5#8JunJulAugSep

all-time peak

138

days in the top 3 since Nov 2024

Latest episodes

Showing 20 · updated from the feed

PARANORMAL ACTIVITY: A NEW STORY LIVE ON STAGE Teaser

A bonus episode so fun we made a trailer for it - Henley had the privilege seeing Paranormal Activity live on Broadway, and the pleasure of recapping it for Sammy and Emi

Sep 11
1 min

THE WITCHES

#6 trending · Film Reviews

Come to hear how disrespectfully witches are portrayed, stay to discover if Henley ever finds understanding with Mr. Bean! Movie & Guest Intro @ 23:25 Trivia @ 35:10 R

Sep 9
2 h 05 min

COLONY

Baboons! Ants! Henley's smash hit sold out Zombie University musical! Triples is best!!! Movie Intro @ 28:40 Trivia @ 31:21 Recap starts @ 40:50 All Hellchella video

Sep 2
2 h 06 min

THE END OF OAK STREET with Joel Jensen

H3llch3lla continues! Horrorspousedent Joel Jensen returns to recap The End of Oak Street, in theaters now! You won't BELIEVE the names on some of these dinosaurs! Movie

Aug 26
2 h 38 min

TEENAGE SEX AND DEATH AT CAMP MIASMA with Casey McQuiston

In this camp we love gummy candy, explorations of female pleasure, and Gillian freaking Anderson! We are joined by our wonderful horrorspondent Casey McQuiston to dive in

Aug 19
2 h 11 min

EVIL DEAD BURN with Dan Lippert

Horrorspondent Dan Lippert returns, bringing the heat and a SOUNDBOARD! Hail to the king, baby!! Movie & Guest Intro @ 08:50 Trivia @ 24:10 Recap starts @ 32:15 TW: S

Aug 12
2 h 00 min

JURASSIC PARK with Wes Larson

H3LLCH3LLA: TRIPLES IS BEST is here! Wes Larson is back!! Life, uh, finds a way, babyy!! Movie & Guest Intro @ 8:29 Trivia @ 19:35 Recap starts @ 28:32 All Hellchella

Aug 5
1 h 53 min

WE BURY THE DEAD with Spooko

Had to get our Australian Horrorspondents back for this one!! Movie Intro @ 25:00 Trivia @ 29:32 Recap starts @ 31:40 See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy

Jul 29
1 h 51 min

RESIDENT EVIL: APOCALYPSE

Tube top freedom now! Movie Intro @ 19:20 Trivia @ 21:30 Recap starts @ 25:55 Follow the show: @TSDWpodcast on Twitter, TikTok, and Instagram. Check out our Patreon

Jul 22
1 h 30 min

RED ROOMS (Vault Release)

This one is TOUGH but that's ok because from here on out it's only love and light

Jul 15
1 h 26 min

THE PURGE: ELECTION YEAR

Happy belated 4th of July! We live in hell! Movie Intro @ 21:43 Trivia @ 26:09 Recap starts @ 28:27 Follow the show: @TSDWpodcast on Twitter, TikTok, and Instagram.

Jul 8
1 h 32 min

WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT KEVIN (Vault Release)

This episode was originally released as a bonus episode on our Patreon in June 2024. Find more bonus episodes at www.patreon.com/tsdwpodcast Recap starts @ 11:15 Follo

Jul 1
1 h 12 min

GOTHIKA

Henley can't get enough turn-of-the-century cinema!!!! Movie Intro @ 19:20 Trivia @ 22:27 Recap starts @ 25:20 TW: Rape, suicide Follow the show: @TSDWpodcast on Twi

Jun 24
1 h 41 min

COHERENCE

Emily has picked yet another very difficult movie to recap!!! (Spoiler alert: she knocked it out of the park) Movie Intro @ 19:30 Trivia @ 21:53 Recap starts @ 29:12

Jun 17
1 h 47 min

BRAINDEAD (1992) with Sarah Sherman

Sammy is out this week but not to worry - Sarah Sherman (Live + in the Flesh, SNL) is taking up the mantle! Get ready to get goopy nasty! Movie & Guest Intro @ 07:45 Tr

Jun 10
1 h 28 min

BACKROOMS

Movie Intro @ 11:40 Trivia @ 16:13 Recap starts @ 29:00 Trailer Follow the show: @TSDWpodcast on Twitter, TikTok, and Instagram. Check out our Patreon for bonus epis

Jun 3
1 h 37 min

OBSESSION with Michael Johnston and Megan Lawless

We love this movie, we loved talking to Michael Johnston and Megan Lawless, and we love YOU a normal and healthy amount!!!! Movie Intro @ 17:00 Trivia @ 19:20 Recap st

May 27
2 h 04 min

IS GOD IS with Mallori Johnson

We got to talk to the absolute superstar Mallori Johnson about this special movie, which we HIGHLY recommend going to see in theaters if you can! Movie Intro @ 22:05 Tr

May 20
2 h 27 min

HOKUM

The perfect Mother's Day film, we had loads of good craic! Movie Intro @ 16:27 Trivia @ 20:24 Recap starts @ 25:31 Follow the show: @TSDWpodcast on Twitter, TikTok, a

May 13
1 h 40 min

OPERA

It's Giallo time! Movie Intro @ 18:36 Trivia @ 22:41 Recap starts @ 25:30 Follow the show: @TSDWpodcast on Twitter, TikTok, and Instagram. Check out our Patreon for

May 6
1 h 35 min

Chart positions

Where Too Scary; Didn't Watch ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Sep 12, 2026).

#5 ▼ 1 Film Reviews US

#44 ▼ 7 TV & Film US

What listeners say

A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.

I love this podcast, the 3 hosts, and their guests. The premise is amazing and I always listen before watching a movie. However, the Jurassic Park episode is my GO TO lately when I am anxious or get upset at one of the world’s worst inclinations.

Mandie- mom of the best son · Aug 2026

I’ve been looking for another horror movie podcast since I love Scream! But they are so erratic in posting and then I went on a Reddit rabbit hole to find something similar and these ladies nailed it. I love their banter, the movie choices and the pace of the show.

BreezyBeeJaspee · Jul 2026

My sister and I have loved TSDW for years, but I listen to far fewer episodes these days…because I love horror movies now! And I want to watch before listening! Thank you ladies for unlocking a whole new world of stories for me with the power of friendship and empathy. (Also my sister and I got to watch the original cut of The Descent at our local theater—thank you!!)

wolfgirl7200 · Jul 2026

Just discovered this one in my suggesteds a couple days ago. I just re-watched I Know What You Did Last Summer, so I listened to that episode and I love that they noticed the same things that I noticed and had the same takes. I felt very seen lol. Just listened to the Midsomer episode yesterday and I'm so grateful to never need to see that movie but to now be educated and understand pop culture references to it 😄 Looking forward to exploring the long back catalog for the rest of the summer. It's like listening to ghost stories ❤️

Shereals99 · Jul 2026

I listened to several episodes, but Signs and Thanksgiving have completely turned me off from this podcast. I can’t even remember who was doing the storytelling for Signs but it was painful to get through. They clearly don’t like horror movies, and freak out at the smallest things, so this podcast doesn’t really make sense. If anyone wants an amazing podcast for horror films, listen to Scream!

angie.83 · May 2026

We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.