The Michael Kay Show

Latest episodes

Showing 20 · updated from the feed

Hour 1: McCarthy to Start

Is it too soon to start J.J. McCarthy for the Giants? Do the Yankees have answers for their failures? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoice

Oct 22
52 min

Hour 2: Mike Lupica

Do you blame Aaron Boone or Brian Cashman for the Yankees failures? Mike Lupica says Hal Steinbrenner doesn't seem to fully understand why his fans have a right to be ups

Oct 21
48 min

Hour 1: The Yankees Speak

How frustrated are Yankees fans after hearing Hal Steinbrenner and Brian Cashman speak? What does need to change with the Yankees? Learn more about your ad choices. Visi

Oct 21
55 min

Hour 2: Paul Finebaum

Paul Finebaum says the expanded college Football playoff will greatly benefit the SEC and the Big 10 because of their strength of schedule. Are Giants fans happy with how

Oct 20
48 min

Hour 1: Bring Boone Back

Do you agree with the Yankees bring back Aaron Boone? What will the message be to Yankees fans when the organization does speak? Is this Boone's last chance to win with t

Oct 20
54 min

Hour 2: Jets Coaching and Yankees Ownership

Is coaching holding the Jets back? Does Hal Steinbrenner care about winning? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Oct 19
49 min

Hour 1: Giants Starters

Is it time for J.J. McCarthy to be the Giants starting quarterback? Does John Harbaugh play too many word games with the media? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit p

Oct 19
52 min

Hour 2: Jose Caballero

Is baseball headed to a lockout that will cause them to miss games? New York Yankees, Jose Caballero says there is no one to blame but them as the players for not perform

Oct 16
51 min

Hour 1: Dan Orlovsky

Dan Orlovsky says it is absolutely realistic to believe the Giants can win the NFC East. Do you like small markets in the World Series? Learn more about your ad choices.

Oct 16
49 min

Hour 2: Chris Simms

NBC Sports' Chris Simms says he doesn't understand why the Saints are favored over the Giants. Hit & Run – Rangers goaltending, Don Mattingly hired by Phillies, Kevin Lon

Oct 15
51 min

Hour 1: Boone's Job

Will there be a decision made on Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone soon? Is Aaron Boone just doing the job he was hired to do? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcas

Oct 15
52 min

Hour 2: Mike Lupica

Is it time for the Yankees to make a change at manager? Mike Lupica says that if the Yankees are going to make a change, it needs to be a full change and not blame one pe

Oct 14
50 min

Hour 1: Accountability or New Players?

Do the Yankees need to hole their players accountable or do they just need new players? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Oct 14
49 min

Hour 2: Ian O'Connor

Columnist for The Athletic, Ian O'Connor says that while Aaron Boone is a very good manager, it is time for the Yankees to bring in a new voice. Do the Yankees need to sp

Oct 13
49 min

Hour 1: All-In Theories

Does anyone know what Aaron Judge means by "all-in?" Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Oct 13
53 min

Hour 2: All In Yankees and James Edwards III

What does Aaron Judge mean by saying the Yankees need to be "all in?" Is it concerning that criticism has been coming from within the Yankee family? James Edwards III of

Oct 12
50 min

Hour 1: A Giant Tie

Was it the coaches or the players that messed up the end of the Giants game? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Oct 12
52 min

Hour 2: Buster Olney

Buster Olney says there needs to be more accountability with the Yankees players. Do the Yankees need a new approach to analytics? Learn more about your ad choices. Visi

Oct 9
51 min

Hour 1: Stop Rewarding Losing

Do comments out there signal unrest in the Yankees room? Do the Yankees need to stop coddling their players if they don't win? Hit and Run – Mike Ditka passes away, Dak w

Oct 9
52 min

Hour 2: What Needs to Change?

What changes do you want to see the Yankees make? Is it time for a new view? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Oct 8
49 min

Chart trend

Position in the Sports chart (US), last 90 days.

#1#99#196JulAugSepOct

#23

all-time peak

days in the top 50 since Nov 2024

Chart positions

Where The Michael Kay Show ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Oct 23, 2026).

#107 ▲ 44 Sports US

What listeners say

A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.

I am always checking out new podcasts and nothings ever seems to hold a candle to this one. I am a Yankees fan, so this helps, but this show discusses great facets of NY sports while not being solely focused on NY. Keep it up guys!

Bhardt · Oct 2024

As a NY Yankees/Giants/Knicks fan living in Germany this show is a must for me every day. I love the show and get a lot of laughs from the debates of Michael, Don, and Peter. Also get a lot of laughter from some of the bad phone calls the guys get. In my younger days growing up in Upstate NY listening to the Yankees on radio I only wanted to hear John Sterling call games. I have become a much bigger fan of Michael as a broadcaster of the Yankees since starting the show.

Coreperformance · Dec 2023

The best sports show on radio. The chemistry, wit, and insight between the three personalities stand out against any other.

RealMusicSarno · May 2023

Living in California, I can’t listen to the guys live. But this new format is the next best thing! I absolutely love feeling like I get to experience the show in its full, zaftig format. You miss a minute, you miss a lot!

Mahlergrooves2 · Sep 2022

I used to listen years ago when the MKS daily when they had more baseball and Yankees content. These days they are a mix of everything, and though I will listen to other shows that mix everything, the content and delivery is simply not entertaining on this show unless it’s baseball related. Kay has great knowledge and insight of baseball and particularly the Yankees. Yankees should be considered his core. But it seems like the show tries to diversify despite its strength. Therefor baseball comes up few and far between these days. Listening on all other topics is futile. I’ll still check once in a while on the podcast to see if there’s a Yankees topic. But even that, you still need to sit through not worthy content. Dons rants are entertaining, but his delivery otherwise is dull. Peter should not be talking sports. He may have basketball knowledge but he doesn’t seem interested in any other topic outside of social and political ones. I wish there was a Michael Kay podcast with him just discussing the Yankees with or without Don. I’d rate that a 4 maybe even 5. But in its current form, it’s so bad I have even stopped looking for Yankees content on this podcast.

Albearrrr · Mar 2023

We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.